Listen

Description

The Righteous King Problem

President Oaks argued in April 2021 that the U.S. Constitution is divinely inspired because it protects moral agency — the freedom God requires His children to have so they can be accountable before Him. But if God values agency enough to inspire a founding document to protect it, what does His own government look like? Has He ever governed a people directly? And why hasn't He just made Himself our King already? Six questions follow that thread through ancient Israel under the Judges, through Nephite constitutional theory in Mosiah 29, and into the Millennium — one principle traced across three thousand years, landing on what it asks of us today.

Before you listen — a few caveats for every Coming Closer episode:

  1. This is not doctrine and I'm not an authoritative source for truth. But I believe asking questions is the way to come closer to Him. "Ask, and it shall be given unto you." God expects us to wonder, be amazed, and read between the lines.
  2. Leave space for the truth. This is speculation — interesting speculation, I think — but someday the whole truth will be known. Leave room in your mind and heart for it when it is revealed.
  3. I hope you'll have some Wow moments as we talk. When that happens, pause. Stop and think about why it touched your heart — maybe jot down a few ideas to pursue. The truth is absolute, but our journey to it is unique, custom made just for us, and there are moments when we simply need to stop and be amazed.

What we cover: why President Oaks calls the Constitution divinely inspired, and how D&C 101:77–80 hangs it all on agency — the therefore of verses 78–79; the two centuries Israel lived with no king but God, and Gideon refusing a crown ("the Lord shall rule over you," Judges 8:23); the day Israel demanded a king "like all the nations," and God's verdict that they had rejected Him, not Samuel (1 Samuel 8:7); Mosiah's "righteous king problem" — a righteous king is the best government, but "because all men are not just" you build a system of judges instead (Mosiah 29:13, 16); the Millennium, where Christ reigns as the one ruler who never abuses power and Satan is bound by the people's own righteousness (1 Nephi 22:26); and what all of it asks of us as citizens and covenant-keepers today.

The closing thought: John Adams told the Massachusetts Militia in 1798 that "our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people… wholly inadequate to the government of any other." One of the men who built the document knew its limits. A structure can protect agency; it cannot produce the people who use it well. The righteous king problem isn't really about kings — it's about whether the people are ready for a king worth having.

Scriptures: D&C 101:77–80; 121:39, 41–42; Judges 2:16–17; 8:22–23; 1 Samuel 8:7, 11–18; Moses 7:18; Mosiah 29:13, 16, 28–32, 31; Articles of Faith 1:10; D&C 45:59; 1 Nephi 22:24, 26; D&C 88:111–113.

Talk: President Dallin H. Oaks, Defending Our Divinely Inspired Constitution, April 2021 General Conference.