Abi shares a chillingly gruesome quadruple murder case from 1981 that remains unsolved despite strong suspicions and evidence at the time and even in the years following the crime. Upon reinvestigation, it appears the Department of Justice and the Plumas County Sheriff's Office let the case grow cold on purpose. What were they trying to hide?
On April 12, 1981, Sheila Sharp returned home after sleeping over at the cabin next door to find her mother Sue, brother John and his friend Dana all slaughtered in the living room. Her little sister Tina's remains would be found three years later 30 miles from Keddie. Somehow, Sheila's younger brothers, Rick and Greg, along with their friend Justin Smartt who was sleeping over, were left unharmed and seemingly unaware of the tragic evening's events. Justin's presence alone might be the key to solving this crime.
