In 2019, Peloton broke the internet with a new holiday commercial that many perceived as sexist and classist. But others - including the company's loyal consumer base - passionately disagreed. This viral ad, the one that launched a thousand memes and scorched the Earth on its ascent to late night talk shows, never actually got its rightful day in court. It's time to take a second look at the Peloton commercial; to hear arguments from both sides of the debate; and ultimately, to discover why it mattered so much.