It’s very likely that you’ve noticed “high protein claims” penetrating more diverse food and beverage categories. But what about an adjacent product strategy that’s sneaking caffeine into anything and everything that’s quick, easy, and accessible? So, beyond the ubiquitous availability of coffee, energy drinks, caffeinated carbonated soft drinks, and tea…you can now purchase items such as caffeinated nutritional bars, jellybeans with caffeine, coffee paste, caffeinated chocolate, caffeinated gum, mouth pouches with caffeine, coffee-flavored ice cream with caffeine, caffeinated mouth spray, and even coffee-flavored cereals with caffeine. But while there are several underlying drivers fueling the caffeinated grocery trend…examining each of them is likely unnecessary when you realize that caffeine is by far the most widely used psychoactive drug, with slightly more than 90% of U.S. adults consuming it regularly. Though, like pretty much anything seen across today’s CPG industry…everything is a remix of the past. So, while startup CPG founders and Big CPG innovation teams might believe they can disrupt (or complement) the various traditional caffeinated beverage formats…this is hardly the origin point for the caffeinated grocery trend. But please don’t misconstrue these statements…I’m a strong believer that if you want to create something with lasting impact within today’s CPG space, it needs to be some combination of “new” yet “familiar.” Do something too closely related to the market leader and consumers won’t take notice…but do something too novel and they’re confused. So, as I stated earlier…successful CPG products oftentimes don’t arrive out of nowhere; they’re remixes that recycle and reimagine existing (or past) strategic elements. But while there will seemingly always be a new batch of innovative thinkers launching unconventional caffeine products…long-term successful adoption will only occur when novelty evolves into a perceived necessity. Yet, sometimes to create buzz, evoke curiosity, and/or resonate emotionally with consumers…novelty can offer a fresh way to stand out in a crowded marketplace. Obviously, there’s an increasingly popular design theory (called chaos packaging) that takes familiar products and reimagines their containers in unconventional ways. And I want to fully acknowledge how valuable chaos packaging can be when done right…but expanding a bit, I believe that “form must follow function” when rethinking category norms strategically. Moreover, it’s artistically beautiful when a format is chosen that doesn’t quite meet the normal expectations but can bring in a different consumer through its ability to serve a specific need. But have you ever read something and thought, “how did society get to this insane moment?” Well…that’s exactly what happened last week when I saw that Monster Energy acquired an ice cream brand. I guess energy drink brands had become jealous of their “caffeinated big brother” coffee being a beloved ice cream flavor and shifted their focus to disrupting the frozen grocery section. And before you try roasting me in the comments…I’m fully aware that the limited partnership Hilrod Holdings, not Monster Beverage Corporation, acquired Thrifty Ice Cream. But the “Hilrod” in Hilrod Holdings is formed by combining the first three letters of the first names of Monster Energy co-founders Hilton Schlosberg and Rodney Sacks. So, when (or if) can we ever expect to see a monster energy ice cream in grocery stores?
