Iggy, Michael, and Ken sample Eagle Rare 17 from the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection
Does the 17-year-old version of Eagle Rare meet or exceed our expectations?
Music by Adam Whitehead - https://www.facebook.com/adamwhiteheadmusic
Email us at - thewhiskeyfriends@gmail.com
#Eagle Rare #whiskey #bourbon #BTAC (Buffalo Trace Antique Collection) #aging #oakiness #tannin #palate #nose #unicorn
Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon Review
In a recent podcast episode, the whiskey enthusiasts from "The Whiskey Friends" took on the daunting task of sampling the highly sought-after Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon from the BTAC (Buffalo Trace Antique Collection). This bourbon, sent to them by Mr. Robert of the Bourbon Real Talk community, promised a journey into the world of aged and matured whiskey. Let's dive into their impressions.
Appearance:
The Eagle Rare 17, a unicorn in the bourbon world, was poured into their glasses. Its deep, amber hue hinted at the long years it had spent aging in barrels. The color alone set high expectations.
Nose:
The podcast hosts were pleasantly surprised by the nose. They described it as reminiscent of a good bourbon with a subtle hint of mustiness. It was an inviting aroma, not overpoweringly oaky but carrying the promise of something special.
Palate:
The first sip revealed the power of the aging process. While the oakiness was prominent, it didn't overwhelm the palate as some other heavily aged bourbons do. There were subtle notes of pepper and a touch of fruit, with a faint hint of banana that added a unique twist. However, the tannin bitterness became more pronounced as the whiskey finished.
Finish:
As they savored the Eagle Rare 17, the conversation turned to the finish. It was described as fairly oaky, but the addition of a drop of water opened it up, allowing more of the classic bourbon flavors to shine through. Some found it slightly one-dimensional, considering the bourbon's reputation, but it was not a disappointing experience overall.
Conclusion:
In their collective opinion, the Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon was not their favorite among the many they've tried. For such a highly sought-after bottle, they expected a bit more complexity and depth. However, the consensus was that it was still a worthwhile bourbon, and they acknowledged its potential for trading with fellow whiskey enthusiasts.
In summary, the Eagle Rare 17-Year-Old Bourbon from the 2017 vintage showcased the power of aging, with a notable oakiness and hints of pepper, fruit, and banana. While it might not have lived up to the lofty expectations, it remained a respected member of the bourbon world, worthy of a spot in any collector's cabinet.
