In this episode of Pop Culture Pastor, Dave, Cody, and guest, DJ Dangerfield, take a sobering look at American Murder: Gabby Petito, the Netflix docuseries examining the tragic disappearance and death of 22-year-old Gabby Petito. Together, they explore the deeper layers of a story that captivated the nation—discussing the dangers of hidden abuse, the role of social media in shaping false realities, and the difficult questions surrounding law enforcement, mental health, and family dynamics.
This episode doesn’t review the film as much as it wrestles with the complex human issues behind it: control disguised as love, the silence of victims, and the societal failure to protect the vulnerable. The team also examines the impact of trauma, the responsibilities of parents, and how grief—when turned outward—can become a force for healing and advocacy.
If you've watched the docuseries or followed the case, this thoughtful, compassionate conversation will help you process it through a broader lens—one that values justice, empathy, and the sacredness of human life.
