This is a film full of imagination, from the story to the cinematography. Guillermo Del Toro's passionately felt film won him a Golden Globe for directing and his stamp is all over the place. Andrew is one of the many fans that praise how moving a film THE SHAPE OF WATER is. Phil is not one of those people. Despite recognizing the talent that went into creating this film, it still seemed to him like a mishmash of different genres that could not quite sell Del Toro's fantasy that a monster could win the heart of a beautiful woman. Andrew and Phil have a lively discussion on opposing sides about this critical favorite.
