In May of 2004, 3 suitcases containing the dismembered remains of Bill McGuire were pulled from the Chesapeake Bay. His wife, Melanie, claimed she hadn't seen Bill in the days leading up to his murder, but a jury didn't buy it and convicted her of for first-degree murder. Did Melanie McGuire kill her husband, or was it Bill's gambling debts that cost him his life? Tune in to hear Karla's and Michael's take on this twisted case!
