Episode Description: Welcome back to New York’s Dark Side for Part Two of our chilling deep dive into the Double Initial Murders of Rochester, NY. In this episode, Amanda delves into several major suspects tied to the still-unsolved murders of Carmen Colon, Wanda Walkowicz, and Michelle Maenza—three young girls from Rochester, NY, each with matching initials. The discussion includes known serial killers Kenneth Bianchi and Joseph Naso, as well as a shocking family connection to Carmen’s case. She also shares profiling insights and modern claims linked to the mystery.
🧠 What You’ll Hear in This Episode:
Early Suspect Leads:
Witness composite sketches and multiple car sightings linked to Michelle Maenza's abduction.
A promising lead involving a man with a light-colored car and buckled boots—details that echoed across cases.
The Case of Dennis Termini:
A city firefighter and serial rapist, Termini was suspected after a terrifying New Year’s Day incident in 1974.
He died by suicide before he could be fully questioned.
In 2007, DNA testing ruled him out as Wanda’s killer; DNA from Carmen and Michelle’s cases was no longer available.
The Theodore Given Jr. Incident:
In August 1974, two girls were abducted and assaulted in Lyons Park. Witness tips led to Given, who had ties to suspicious locations near the victims’ homes.
Although charged and convicted, his confession was controversial and surrounded by claims of police brutality.
He resembled the suspect sketch from Michelle Maenza’s case and was living near key crime scene locations at the time.
The 1976 Murder of Michelle “Shelley” McMurray:
Another young girl with double initials was murdered—this time abducted from her home.
Although initially not linked to the previous murders, her killer, James Pressler, was finally identified through DNA in 2007.
This case, however, remains separate from the original double initial cases.
⚖️ Key Takeaways:
Several compelling suspects emerged, but none were definitively linked to the original three murders.
Theories involving symbolism and psychological profiling offered chilling possibilities.
1. Kenneth Bianchi (The Hillside Strangler)
Born: May 22, 1951
Lived in Rochester: 1971–1973 (Dutch Town & Gates suburbs)
Known for: 12 murders (1977–1979), including 10 with cousin Angelo Buono in Los Angeles, and 2 solo in Washington
Connections to Rochester:
Applied to Monroe County Sheriff's Office twice
Worked as a security guard and ambulance driver locally
First mentioned as a suspect in the Double Initial case in 1979
Cleared from: Wanda Walkowicz’s murder via DNA
Not ruled out: Carmen Colon’s case (drove a similar car to the one seen at the crime scene)
Current status: Serving two life sentences in Walla Walla, Washington
2. Joseph Naso
Born: January 7, 1934, in New York State
Moved to California: 1969
Criminal History:
Multiple sexual assault charges in Monroe County (1958, 1960)
Later charged with murder in California
Victims: Included women with double initials
Evidence Found: Over 10,000 items, bondage photos, and a handwritten list possibly tied to victims
Ties to Rochester: Visited family often despite moving
Cleared from Rochester cases: DNA did not match samples from Rochester murders
Considered a possible copycat
3. Miguel Colon
Relation: Uncle and stepfather to Carmen Colon
Incident: In 1991, shot Carmen’s mother and uncle in a domestic dispute before killing himself
Remains a suspect in Carmen’s case by some investigators
Family maintains his innocence
Check out our Patreon Page!
For all episode sources and additional information about this case, please check out our episode page following this LINK.
Facebook: New York's Dark Side
Instagram: @NYDarkSidePod
The intro theme for this podcast is a section of Nightmare Machine by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), CC BY 3.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0>, via Wikimedia Commons
