The second season premiere of 1923 finds the Duttons facing numerous hardships. They struggle with a harsh winter, financial difficulties, and legal troubles orchestrated by a conniving businessman. Teonna seeks solace with her father and lover, but danger still pursues her. Spencer Dutton finds himself embroiled in violence and unexpected friendship while working on a ship. Alexandra Dutton schemes to escape her stifling family situation in England and reunite with Spencer, despite being pregnant and without funds.
