In this episode of A New York (Giants) Minute, Ben Taylor and Peter Finelli take on the case of Aaron Rodgers vs. the 2025 New York Giants. At the request of a listener, Peter, as the prosecutor, lays out the case against Rodgers as the Giants’ quarterback, while Ben, as the defense, argues for Rodgers as a potential starter and mentor for a young QB.
The trial begins at the 18-minute mark, but before that, Ben and Peter break down Championship Weekend, sharing their thoughts on the matchups and their disappointment in yet another Eagles vs. Chiefs Super Bowl.
Vote in our Spotify poll or email us at nygminute1@gmail.com to let us know who won the trial and whether you think Rodgers should be the Giants’ QB in 2025!
If you enjoy the show, be sure to follow us wherever you listen to podcasts and share it with fellow Giants fans. To stay connected, follow us on X @nygminutepod or email us at nygminute1@gmail.com!
