Description

In this podcast, we examine the story concerning the tribes of Gad and Reuben, who sought to settle east of the Jordan River before the conquest of the Land of Israel. Moses initially expresses strong disapproval, fearing their request would demoralize the other tribes and lead to a repetition of the spies' sin. 

The commentaries differ on the precise nature of Moses's concern and the subsequent response of the tribes. 

• Some highlight Moses's emphasis on the phrase "before God" in contrast to the tribes' initial "before the children of Israel," signifying a shift from reliance on human strength to divine intervention and a proper, God-centered intention for war.
• Other interpretations focus on the tribes' prioritization of their livestock and families over the spiritual significance of the conquest.
• While some simply see Moses testing their commitment to the entire nation.

Ultimately, the sources agree that the exchange clarifies the necessity of fighting for God's will and the unified purpose of the Israelites in taking the land.