#TalesFromTheCrypt #ECComics #FittingPunishment
This week hosts Fred and Tim enter the funeral parlor for “Fitting Punishment,” Season 2, Episode 12 of HBO’s Tales from the Crypt — a brutal tale of greed, abuse, death and revenge from beyond the grave starring Moses Gunn, directed by Jack Sholder and co-written by Child’s Play creator Don Mancini.
Before “Fitting Punishment” came to HBO, the story appeared in The Vault of Horror #16 in 1950, written by Al Feldstein with artwork by legendary EC horror artist Graham “Ghastly” Ingels.
Fred and Tim exhume the original comic, digging into Ingels’ wonderfully gruesome artwork, EC’s obsession with poetic justice and the story’s connection to H.P. Lovecraft’s “In the Vault.”
How much of Lovecraft survives in EC’s version? How does Feldstein turn the premise into a vicious morality tale? And what changes when HBO resurrects the story forty years later?
Then we turn to the 1990 HBO adaptation, directed by Jack Sholder, filmmaker behind A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy’s Revenge, The Hidden and Alone in the Dark, from a screenplay by Jonathan David Kahn, Michael Alan Kahn and Don Mancini, creator of Child’s Play and Chucky.
Moses Gunn stars as Ezra Thornberry, a miserly funeral director whose concern for the dead extends only as far as the money he can squeeze from their grieving families.
Ezra cuts every corner imaginable — stealing valuables from corpses, skimping on embalming fluid and reusing coffins — while convincing himself that his cruelty is somehow righteous.
Then his recently orphaned nephew Bobby, played by Jon Clair, arrives looking for a home.
Ezra sees free labor.
Bobby sees exactly what kind of man his uncle really is.
And when Ezra’s greed turns into violence, the dead eventually decide it’s time for the undertaker to receive a fitting punishment of his own.
Fred and Tim break down Moses Gunn’s towering performance, Jack Sholder’s direction, the episode’s funeral-home atmosphere, gruesome practical effects, dark comedy and increasingly vicious sense of justice while comparing the HBO adaptation directly with the original EC Comics story.
We also look at the episode’s distinctive place in Tales from the Crypt history as the series’ only episode built around an entirely Black main cast.
Finally, Fred and Tim unlock the Vault of More for another collection of deep-cut recommendations inspired by the episode.
• Fitting Punishment — Season 2, Episode 12
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0716847/
• Jack Sholder — Director
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0794791/
• Don Mancini — Screenplay
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0238841/
• Moses Gunn — Uncle Ezra Thornberry
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0348214/
• Jon Clair — Bobby
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0163216/
• Teddy Wilson — Clyde
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0934209/
• John Kassir — The Crypt Keeper
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0440885/