Alex loves history. He sort-of likes novels. He adores anything east of Germany and west of China. So what’s stopping him from even cracking open what was acclaimed as Georgia’s answer to War and Peace?
Robin guides Alex through Nino Haratischwili’s thousand-page family saga: eight lives spanning revolution, Stalinism, exile, the collapse of the Soviet Union—and a cursed recipe for hot chocolate. Along the way, they ask whether magical realism improves historical fiction, why prestigious historical novels can feel less inviting than genre fiction, and whether Alex bought The Eighth Life to read it or simply to establish a Caucasus section on his bookshelf.
Plus: the books they actually finished, Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey, Ezra Klein’s highly political interpretation of it, and next episode’s unfinished biography of Andrew Jackson.
Spoilers throughout, although they may matter less when one host hasn’t opened the book and the other has mainly read the plot summary.
Chapters
00:00 — Georgia’s thousand-page War and Peace
01:39 — The highest-rated unread book so far
03:39 — Eight lives, one family and a century of Georgian history
06:43 — Why Georgia fascinates Alex
12:49 — God’s own holiday paradise
16:32 — Why Alex bought the book
20:01 — Why history works for Alex—and novels don’t
22:37 — The entire family saga in ten minutes
25:03 — Cursed chocolate and the limits of magical realism
33:00 — Is Alex any closer to reading it?
34:16 — Would The Eighth Life work on television?
37:24 — What makes historical fiction enjoyable?
44:43 — Why Alex prefers institutional histories to spy novels
46:00 — Award-winning history versus history with “genre juice”
48:56 — Ratings, completion rates and the final reckoning
52:03 — Will Alex ever open the book?
53:43 — The Caucasus section of the bookshelf
55:35 — What Robin and Alex have actually been reading
56:44 — The Odyssey, Christopher Nolan and Ezra Klein
59:05 — Next time: Andrew Jackson and American Lion
Mentioned in this episode