What do we think being “one of us” actually buys us?
Protection? Respect? An exception when the rules get ugly?
Military psychiatrists Dr. David and Dr. Robby examine the gap between belonging and protection through four very different stories:
• Sarah Huckabee Sanders’s fictional “Brad” welfare ad, and why some viewers object to the stereotype while others object to who’s sitting in the chair.
• Amy Dangerfield’s experience in Nick Fuentes’s circle, and what happens when a useful supporter starts acting independently.
• Max Naumann’s belief that his German nationalism and military service could secure an exception to Nazi persecution.
• An Army sergeant whose wife was deported, and the obligations a government has to the family of someone serving it.
These stories have profoundly different stakes. The military family’s case also raises a distinct question about institutional responsibility, without any assumption about the family’s politics.
Along the way: attribution bias, selective empathy, bureaucracy, and the social cost of changing your mind. David tests whether Robby’s defense of a soldier’s family extends beyond people in uniform. Robby declares himself a hostile witness. More than once.
When a rule hurts someone we recognize, do we find a principle that protects others, or a better argument for our own exception?
Two military psychiatrists, bourbon, and an increasingly uncomfortable definition of “us.”
Subscribe to Shrink the Nation, and tell us where you think the argument breaks