“You dance really oddly,” the teenage daughter of a friend told me at a Brussels pub disco night some years ago. “Then don’t look, nosey,” retorted I.
Let me transport you to Montparnasse, Paris, summer 1996. A long-standing friend’s getting married and, the night before the big day, is anguishing: like Genesis, he can’t dance; what would he do for the opening waltz the next evening? In the minuscule lift lobby serving three Montparnasse apartments, I take David away from the hubbub of family and teach him the basics of the English waltz and quickstep (you can’t just waltz). Next day, I make sure his shoelaces are tied and set him to go for gold at the Château de Vincennes. Henry V moved in to Vincennes after beating Charles VI at Agincourt, and those crowned heads couldn’t have been prouder of me. David looked okay, as well.
Thanks for reading The Endless Chain! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
David needed to know how to dance because people want to see the groom dance his first dance with his new bride. He wanted it to look good; I wanted it to look good for him. And I wanted it to look good for me. Surrogate pride of the trainer (“It was all your own achievement – you couldn’t have done it without me.”) But, though David seemed to be dancing for me, for the guests, for his bride, he in fact danced for himself. Everyone does.
Dance is an art form, it’s a sport, it’s poetry in motion (literally), it’s an outpouring of the soul, along with the sweaty armpits. It’s the expression of what is in the dancer and, though sometimes rehearsed, even the competition performance must feel the vibes, sentiment and elation of the original spirit of the dance: on the actor’s stage, Konstantin Stanislavski called it “emotion memory”. Although millions enjoy the spectacle of dance, the sequins and glitter, grace and elegance, at local club competitions and on TV (including gawping, back then, at Ukraine’s President trip the light fantastic) and although viewers pass judgment, as befits the occasion, one can easily overlook the fact that, in the performing arts, excellence is striven for in order to perfect the expression of that which resides in the artist because the art of artistic expression is the expression of the art in the artist. It may be wonderful to behold, but it’s intended only in second place for the onlooker; it is primarily for the artist him or herself. Just like a javelin throw.
We may judge how others give expression to what lies within them, as dancer, as ice skater, as transgender or as LGBTQI+, for that matter as Jew, Muslim, born-again Christian or atheist, but whether we approve or disapprove, condone or condemn, relish or repugn is ultimately of no relevance. It is the onlooker who makes of it relevance, and then only to him or herself along with his or her admirers, or those they would should be their admirers – if they but knew that. For that does not befit the occasion.
Just as dancing is the outer expression of the joy, perchance the sadness, of the individual, so is the expression of Pride. It’s not done to please a paying guest or contracted beneficiary. It’s a simple statement of who the individual is. It commands respect in no greater or lesser measure than life and integrity command respect. The tolerance that is mustered by the intolerant is not a benevolence on their part, even if they may persuade themselves otherwise. It is begrudged lip-service to tenets and fundaments which the society of which they would otherwise all too gladly purge the tolerated vaunts in the name of civilisation.
There circulates a widely held misconception that people who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersexual and related terms constitute a “perversion” on the ground that we consciously choose to identify in that way. That we consciously elect to live a life hiding from parts of society, lying to parents, family, friends and colleagues, skulking to bars and discos, risking physical injury from yobbos and mental injury from clergy, electing to be pointed at at school and in civil life as the odd one out, the strange one, the one who never has a friend of the opposite sex, all as we laugh with others at jokes about us of questionable hue; that schools and colleges are heaving with such individuals, every one of them tainted by our pervasive and unstoppable influence and gagging agog to subscribe to some queer agenda, so blindingly bedazzled, insidiously seduced and deviously enraptured they are with the great Gay Option: where do we sign?
The path we tread, but did not elect to tread, was laid down by many forerunners, and a key milepost came in June 1969, planted by the brave occupiers of New York’s Stonewall Café. No, we did not choose the path on which this milepost stands, but we hail Stonewall as an epiphany moment, one in which a straw broke a camel’s back and rights were demanded, in which the demand would not be and was not relinquished until met: our forerunners had to fight – a fight that no one would persevere with if they had a simple “cancel choice” option. They fought for what they believed in, and what they believed in was evidenced in flesh and blood by who they were, and it was for who they were that they had no choice but to fight. The changes were hard paid for, with personal sacrifice, in terms of hard cash to coppers (you think police are above a spot of blackmail themselves, do you?), hard terms of incarceration (whose perversion is on a standard with the equally vacuous Victorian imprisonment of debtors) and beatings and killings at the hands of the ignorant; they were never so naïve as to believe that, the day won, our battle would truly be o’er – our battle will never truly be o’er for as long as unfounded prejudice appropriates to it the self-appointed privilege of free rein; but people will have it that, before decriminalisation, we elected to be blackmailed and exploited by tortfeasors; we elected to suffer abuse and be spat at and decried and denigrated and humiliated and discriminated against and ridiculed and typified, overseen and overlooked, and trampled down by elements of our society who wouldn’t acknowledge the concept of choice and self-restraint if they leapt up and grabbed them by the throat and, if by happenstance they did, athirst as they are for the votes of those who do so acknowledge and yet would truly elect them to offices of power in misguided belief in their feigned virtues, would not then shirk from refusing the same choice to the next man or woman, be they whoever.
This is wrong; it is regression; it is so patently and arrantly absurd: homosexuality is involuntary; the World Health Organisation long ago removed it from its scurrilous list of infectious diseases, albeit the WHO may, in so doing, have lent a contrario force to those who would have it that we consciously adopt our homosexuality, as if it were a fashion on a shop rail. Let me scotch that one: it was removed from the list because it’s not a disease: you can’t catch it, you can’t make another person be homosexual. It’s like being Chinese: you’re either Chinese or you’re not Chinese. You can no more be cured of homosexuality than you can be cured of being born in Timbuktu. It’s not like eating Mongolian barbecue, instead of bratwurst across the street. It’s not a choice like dining out. It’s not a choice, period. Why would anyone think we choose this existence? If choice it were to be, then and only then would it even remotely qualify as perverse: sadomasochistic perversion. It is not and never has been a cakewalk. It’s the persecution we cannot but put up with that nonetheless makes of many LGBTQI+ people special carers and helpers of others: they’ve been in the pain, and can better understand the pain of others.
Being involuntary and born within the psyche of the individual, it squarely falls to be se…