Listen

Description

The color of truth is gray.

—André Gide

In 2012, the world (or parts of it anyway) was celebrating the 200th birthday of Charles Dickens. A wealthy woman who painted occasionally with us traveled to England to be part of festivities that included meeting the queen. An adventurous widow of extraordinary means, she had hosted the china painting class at her remarkable three-acre estate—filled with museum-quality work on every wall and available surface. “I’m a collector,” she said. Owner of several homes, by all accounts generous to her family, a patron of another painter I knew, trustee of a small college…I wondered if she understood the Dickens she was celebrating.

Written by Anne Ayers Koch. Find more of Anne's writing on Substack.

Edited and produced by Geoff Koch and Amanda Barranco

MORE

As most schoolchildren used to know, between the 1770s and the 1840s, England was transformed from an essentially agricultural island into the most powerful industrial nation in the world. Machines appeared that revolutionized cotton manufacture—the steam engine, the water frame, the spinning jenny. Transportation networks—canals, roads, railroads—led to a migration from country to city overnight. What happened next—the rise of manufacturers and merchants to political and social power—resulted in the inevitable separation of heads of industry from hands that produced. But human welfare didn’t keep pace with material prosperity. No one wrote about it better than Charles Dickens.

When he first saw grimy, dirty Manchester in 1838 he vowed to “strike the hardest blow in (his) power” for victims of exploitation in cotton mills. He did so over and over, never more than in “Hard Times,” the shortest of his books, but the most direct. In fictional Coketown, a wealthy retired merchant, Thomas Gradgrind, opens a school based on his Utilitarian worldview. A world obsessed with facts. A world where one character says, “I beg your pardon for interrupting you, sir…but I am sure you know the whole social system is a question of self-interest. What you must always appeal to, is a person’s self-interest. It’s your only hold.”

In the book “Charles Dickens and the Great Theater of the World,” Simon Callow writes, “He knew what poverty was. He knew what it was to be rejected, to be cast aside, to live in squalor.” For Dickens, the narrow focus on profit maximization and self-interest created an aesthetic blindness that squeezed all poetry and kindness from life. Beginning with “Oliver Twist” and its descriptions of the terrible plight of children, he became the most popular writer in England.

My graduate seminar, “Social Foundations of Education” asked the question, “What do people value and want to see in their schools?” I began with Dickens’ “Hard Times.” The novel, with its convoluted Victorian plot, ends with only one character achieving happiness—Sissy Jupe—the person least suited for a world where facts and figures held sway over the more humble ideas of faith and charity. The graduate students were troubled. They wanted to be part of a world with a broader agenda than economic, but they were being swept away on a tidal wave of expectations and assessments that measured less and less with more and more accuracy.

Society told them what to measure, what to stress, what to value. It became all they saw. All they were allowed to see if they wanted to keep their jobs. They packed away their art supplies, music lessons, geography, history, philosophy, physical education, industrial arts. All we have left in public education is what society sees as the path to professional financial success.

...



Get full access to River Journeys at anneayerskoch.substack.com/subscribe