Reparations: A new and pointless scam. I said the quiet part out loud.
I just had an interesting read. Check out this article.
What Happened When One Illinois Town Passed Reparations
Any type of reparations that take the form of property or cash or goods or favor would be an unmitigated disaster. The popular number being bandied about in DC is $1.2 million per person affected. It cannot work, and should not be tried for a number of reasons.
It’s an abuse of governance.
First, the same thing would occur in our economy as does with the minimum wage (outlined here in the last segment). From the first day such funds would be turned loose on the economy, that same economy would begin to float to a point commensurate with the wealth of the total population equal to where it was before the reparations.
In other words, you would have inflation. In this case we’d be talking about a $10 trillion hit. That would be a lot of inflation. The recipients would become titular millionaires. But not for long.
The rest of the population, having no increase in their wealth, would weather the inflation foisted upon them. This is seen as a good thing by many people. But those people are ignorant. You don’t fix a past injustice with a new one, as much as many want that to be so. Creating injustice is not the job of ANY government.
The government, especially our federal pig, have done lots of stupid things pitting citizens against each other. They’re constantly taking from one to give to another. That doesn’t make doing it again right, especially on this scale.
Have you learned nothing of corruption?
The other immediate result from such a silly idea would be abuse on a scale never seen before in this country or any other. Not only would black people who are not entitled to the money apply for the money, but so would the Chinese, Romanian, Russian, Ukrainian, American (etc, etc, etc) hackers would apply for and RECEIVE the money long before Uncle Stinky figures out he’s being flimflammed. It happens in the tens of billions of dollars every year in every government program and is considered part of doing business. In this case, because SO MANY people would be questionable in terms of entitlement, the nation take a multi-trillion dollar bath.
And speaking of that…
Who would be the beneficiaries of all this benevolence? And who gets to pick? If you’re talking Jim Crowe, no one whose family came here after 1964 would be entitled to anything. If the issue is slavery, no one from the islands or whose family reached these shores since reconstruction would be entitled to anything.
I would argue that ANYTHING that happened to ANYONE ELSE entitles you to absolutely NOTHING! But you see the point.
Further, what of the black people who built successful lives for themselves and are now richer than god already? Don’t they give lie to the group grievance? Or should they also get the same money a single mother living in West Philly gets?
Should a citizen of African descent, living in Atlanta, whose father moved them here from Bermuda 20 years ago be snubbed while his neighbors all get a windfall?
And what do we tell Native Americans? What of the Japanese? The Chinese? People they don’t know, who look like them, suffered at the hands of history. What is their cut?
Then, there is the general pointlessness of the exercise.
No matter how it all shakes out, people will still be people. There will be exceptions to what I am about to say, but they will be painfully few.
Also, if you have never learned how to budget and don’t know how to handle large sums of money, then what I am about to say would happen even faster to YOU.
The lottery story is fraught with people who win big and go broke within a couple of years. And we are talking tens of millions of dollars. So there will be a percentage of the reparation recipients, maybe a sizable one, who will go belly up real quick.
Within 3 or 4 years, 90% of all the money doled out will be in the hands of the same people who own 90% of all the money right now. They are already in a position to earn that money from you as a matter of course.
This is not a racial thing.
The average person in this country, regardless of race and usually because of their own poor decision making, doesn’t have enough money to survive 60 days if their money is cut off. Those people would have to go on the government dole immediately after a loss of income. VERY few have money set aside for retirement, despite how easy the government makes it to do so. In too many cases we are talking about people who make really good money.
This is because we are, for the moment, an irresponsible consumption based economy. In the early 70’s we started to see mostly two income households. Did the adults in those families suddenly have a commensurate increase in savings?
No. They had a commensurate increase in spending. Suddenly, a twin or a row home was beneath their respectability. It had to be a 3 bed, 2 bath single family home! Two cars went from a luxury to a requirement. Free TV entertainment (oh, yeah, you HAD to have a nice TV already) became cable, then subscriptions.
Don’t even mention what daycare costs became.
So, with new wealth, sometimes considerable increases, we saw no increase in fiscal responsibility; only an increase in consumption.
Apple, Microsoft, Disney, Exxon, Ford…and on and on…all know this. I’d be surprised if it took them even 3 years to relieve the vast majority of reparations recipients of their “found” money.
Let’s expound on the pointlessness.
Expensive houses carry high taxes. There are exceptions, but most of the country would have to move to low tax areas. The gulf coast is GREAT for this. But then with the migration, those areas would be come high tax areas. And housing is just one example of the long-term calamity this idea portends.
So, sticking to the idea that people would USUALLY continue to be who they are, housing would become a problem pretty quickly. We’ll say recipient A moves out of where they live and use a huge chunk of their income to buy a house outright. The idea would be to move up in quality or out of an area they don’t like. Such a house would not come cheap. And you would need an income large enough to keep up with maintenance and taxes. If A relies on what is left of the “found” money, they will be handing it to companies or the government at a pretty rapid rate.
Recipient B might decide to bank most of the money and put some money down on a house. That would be how I’d go. But I live small intentionally. The 2008 housing bubble and everything we’ve done since show us that MOST people still buy right up to what the bank says they can.
Sure, the lender will say, with your job and the distributions from your reparations, you can put so many thousands down and make a payment of this much. So very quickly people would be living for the nice new house they bought. And all that found money would be pouring into the bank’s coffers.
In both cases the average recipient A and the average recipient B would find themselves in a new house and living the same way the lived before reparations. Few would suddenly find they could live in that house and join the country club their neighbors go to. They won’t be able to afford it. If they pretend and do it anyway, their money will run out even faster.
But, what if I’m wrong?
Let’s say the vast majority of recipients defy history and bank the cash. They max out their 401k every year and live small. Well, that creates a new set of issues.
First, as we said, we are already going to trigger an inflation problem just by increasing the money supply by the $10 trillion Uncle Stinky had to borrow or print to give you the “found” money. So while you are planning your future with your “found” money, your middle class neighbors are getting slammed with the…