Listen

Description

Hello and welcome to the Political Party Pooper Playbook.

I didn’t put calls to action at the end; subscribe, comment share. So here’s some buttons.

A note to the listener. I really hate listening to myself on audio. I know everybody says that. But I really do have a voice for newprint. HOWEVER! I discovered in editing my last podcast that my stuff sounds 100% better when played at 1.25 speed. It’s much more engaging. It sounds like Ben Shapiro with an earthier voice. Do with that knowledge as you will.

In last week’s P4B podcast I set up this series and spent a bit of time defining the motivation behind the article America’s Growing Zero Sum Economy. Subtitle: It’s also where you find many of the nation’s ultra-rich.

My first point was a take down of the churlish, class envy subtitle. The previous episode will give you a flavor for the series.

Today, I will dispense with the title itself.

The first and recurring rebuttal to that is this: There is no such thing as a zero-sum economy. This term, much like “trickle down economics”, is a contrivance created by the left. It invents a problem to use as a cudgel with which to attack clear minded, productive, free-market people. That’s where the power of the Left comes from. Emotional outbursts and silly populists notions.

I didn’t use the example of trickle down economics without a reason. I used it as a historical reference to demonstrate how the Left always get economic issues wrong. And I am 100% confident Reich used the term frequently during the Reagan years to try to prevent the 30 years of economic growth we experienced, thanks to the Gipper.

Now, he wasn’t, in his own mind, trying to prevent the expansion. He was just busy being wrong and promoting his Ivory Tower political narrative. That’s what happens when you get into a money gun fight with a broken political knife.

Anyhoo, When Reagan brought Art Laffer and the Laffer Curve into play to support his tax cut proposals, the Left immediately carted out the term “trickle down economics”. As Thomas Sowell pointed out in an article about the subject, NO ONE in the Reagan administration, no one handling the Supply Side argument, said the economy would benefit by money trickling down from rich to poor. And that was never any basis for their efforts.

The Left knew this. But they claimed that the Laffer curve was just that, and Supply Side economics was voodoo economics. What they were intentionally overlooking was Supply Side economics is precisely how an economy works. History proves this. The power and control Lefties see in central planning, which people like Reich espouse, is where economies go to die.

Getting it right

The actual effect of Reagan’s cuts, as with JFK’s and Trump’s cuts is a certain and undeniable ripple effect that happens across the entire economy. The effect mimics perfectly, the ripples in a still pond when you throw a pebble into it. The ripple don’t get to a certain spot and stop. They don’t just stay in the rich side of the pond. They eventually reach the entire pond.

An economy is stones of all sizes being thrown into the pond without let up. What a low tax rate and free market ALWAYS DOES it allow for more people to throw more stones into the pond. And it allows the ripples to reach everywhere in the economy.

I know there will be silly push back on this historical reference. I therefore provide the following:

The Kennedy Tax cuts and resulting expansion and Government revenue: Economic economic growth and increased government revenues.

The Reagan Tax cuts are severely skewed by many as having failed.

I would argue that people like Wessel at the link above, are thinking zero-sum nonsense. Growth throughout the 80’s was nothing short of spectacular. Confidence in the economy was astounding. Everybody was throwing stones in the pond and getting wet.

What went wrong was two-fold. First, after putting a responsible economic plan into effect, Reagan and Congress went on a spending bonanza. And the Gipper started to get cold feet. He signed little increases back into the code instead of letting the inevitable growth occur. And the spending did what all spending does, it created a lag on an otherwise astonishing economic machine. And despite the needless and damaging spending, the US went on a long and successful growth curve.

Left in place revenues to the federal government would have seen steady growth, but the inexcusable spending ruined it. If you expand an economy money does pour into the treasury. But if you outstrip the growth with spending, then yes, revenues as percentage of the GDP will shrink.

And anyone who says the Trump cuts weren’t a “social good” (as we’ll see, this is a Reich tag line) you just aren’t living in reality. His policies put the economy in overdrive - twice. Then Brandon killed it all with his “social good” projects and his massive executive overreach.

The tip-off for me that David Wessel, was thinking in zero-sum terms was his use of the term winners and losers. The whine of central planners.

The “zero-sum” nonsense in Reich’s article and elsewhere in recent history is meant to mean that the economy is a finite thing. If I win, you lose. If congress cuts taxes we get less government revenue. Period. And if I don’t get a personal benefit from a transaction you carried out with someone else, that means what YOU did was a zero-sum transaction.

All of those statements are ONLY true when we are operating in a centrally planned, dystopian economy. None are true in the free market (a slowly dying entity in the US). And Reich repeats the phrase again and again in his piece. And here’s where he tips his central planning hand.

“You might think a rational society would heavily tax zero-sum work while subsidizing work that generate lots of social good.”

Not only is Reich stuck in this historically failed concept, it emerges in almost everything he writes. He and others like him, ten of thousands of them, are teaching this lunacy to our kids. Doubt me not!

Almost all LEGAL financial transactions result in “social good”. They fuel the process by which WE improve OUR lives. The “social good” Reich is clearly espousing in his Substack is the kind of “social good” politicians, the media and ivory tower do-gooders want to saddle us with.

Saddle is the perfect word here. The Left want to use their “social good” as a means of control. It is ultimately demeaning and the more people “benefit” from this kind of “social good” the less likely it is that they will ever be able to go through life without the government on their backs.

This is almost exactly the same kind of “social good” Mexican cartels employ to keep them in business. They make small gestures and give “gifts” to the people in their regions to keep them quiet. The idea is if El Scumo, the narcotics guy, builds a little school in your village or hands out Christmas gifts for your kids, you might develop a bit of amnesia when the federales come sniffing around.

You’re being played for chumps!

Accordingly, the Left (and not a small number of GOP political whores) are enriching themselves at our expense. To continue doing that they are working to control every aspect of our lives (ESG much?) To smooth their way and do more of that, they “give” you things. The more you take, the more they’ll give. Every year they increase the amount of other peoples’ wealth which you can enjoy by keeping them in office. Talk about creating winners and losers!

And as we’ve proven in the endless, phony “war on poverty” we’ve been “fighting” since LBJ, no real good comes from the “social good” people like Reich pontificate about.

We’ve spent multiple trillions, in this “war” on programs that have the veneer of Reich’s “social good”. By gradually debasing respect for value - the value of personal property, the value of civil behavior, the value of respect and accomplishment and keeping one’s word, even the value we hold for our own health - the “war on poverty” has created a society overpopu…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.streetpolitics.us