Introduction
Are leaders born or made. I’m talking about larger than life leaders, the Churchills, Pattons and Elons of the world. What of the Richard “Cœur de Lion” or Ike? What sets them apart? Were they born to be what they were, or made to be?
Surely there are people with innate characteristics that we’d all agree are leadership qualities.
There are some people who graduate from institutions, which claim to produce leaders, who go on to become leaders. But those institutions are funnels for people they insist will lead one day. Do they? Do they all go on to lead in a grand way?
Without the use of a scientific study, I’d bet the number of military academy grads, Yale grads and graduates from your high school, go on to outpace their peers as leaders in about the same number. All military grads will be “leaders” be virtue of position. It’s a requirement. But most, if they make it to retirement, will not rise above a staff job. Not all Ivy League alums will be CEOs and will likely serve as functionaries in their organizations. But they all have the resources if they know how to use them; if they have the personality needed to use them properly.
Then there is the guy who is just more dogged than the next guy. He blows past all the above and all his peers and demographic group to change the world.
Whichever is the case, it is a world changer we will be talking about here. By all means, take what you learn here and apply it to your life. Change the world yourself, or at least your corner of it. I will be talking about one particular world changer in this series. He was not a genius. He was not a member of the well-heeled classes. Our subject was not classically educated.
It can be said he was “self-made”. But without the help of certain powerful people he’d have ended his life a tall, lonely, middling, Westmorland planter with bad teeth. To be certain, his mother, often harsh and demanding, almost shrewish, was a motivator. Spoiler: his relationship with her was one of loyalty, if not warmth.
So far, in my reading, one person in particular makes an over-the-top fuss about our man being a born or natural leader. And that story is likely one of the myths associated with Washington.
This episode is the first in a series, the introduction, wherein we take a deep dive into George Washington. I am going to explore, as objectively as I can, the qualities that made him the central figure in the birth of our nation and a leader.
I will take him down entirely from the marble pedestal he has occupied as a legend since 1775 and before. I will try to do a better job of statue killing than David O. Stewart who did OKAY, but quoted at least two really outlandish stories of a Washington with a big S on his chest and wearing a cape…so to speak. He did so without comment, implying the tales were true.
My intention isn’t to tear down a better man then me so we can all feel better about ourselves. I haven’t taken this project on out of disrespect. On the contrary, I hope to come away with a study from which we can all learn valuable lessons. What qualities were truly held by GW and how can we truly learn from them? Will they even translate into out age? What about the man can we pass on to our children and grandchildren truly worthy of the life Washington lived? The “cherry tree” Washington and the utterly selfless Washington are stories for 7-year-olds. I believe there are more valuable and inspiring lessons to be learned from a GW that looks more like a classy, articulate version of Rocky Balboa than the silent poser of Hollywood fame.
We will see his flaws and strengths. We will witness his evolution and compare those attributes to the view of leadership as expressed by several modern authors.
I have chosen authors who have written what seem to be sound principles of leadership, though some tend to be a bit simplistic. Maxwell would be the most blatant example of this. His The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership reads much like a Chicken Soup for the Soul - The Leadership Edition. But his points are valid and it is an easy read. This is very important for the busy exec or barnstorming politician…or his speech writer.
In fairness, I suppose it is difficult to write a book, teaching the reader how to assume the qualities of leadership, without sounding like a modern self-help huckster. Even more detailed works like Kouzes and Posner’s Leadership Challenge have this quality. So, I am happy to say that if you wish to sharpen you leadership skills to become a better CEO, coach, minister, parent, politician and so on, by all means grab a copy of any of the references I cite here and carry on smartly. There won’t be too many works for you to track. They will all be in the footnotes or a bib at the end.
In the course of researching this project, I have discovered two things SO FAR. First, GW is more interesting and multifaceted as an imperfect human being than as the inflated, but two dimensional myth created around him. Second, I like him more as a flawed human than as the myth.
In the course of this series I will draw from Washington’s biographers along with the writings of his contemporaries. You’ll hear from writers like Stephen R. Covey, John C. Maxwell, Barry Z. Posner and James M. Kouzes to establish what leadership is. We’ll hear from David O. Stewart, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, Paul K. Longmore and others to clock GW, “the leader”.
We’ll see George the teen - not very well to do in those years - and the tempestuous, perhaps insufferable young man. But not heartless. He was mindful of his mother, but not overly so. He worshiped his older brother and would have followed him through a sewer if that was where his brother was headed.
We’ll meet the George who formed life-long friendships, even through war, at opposite sides of the conflict. And a man who would alienate men who were among his staunchest supporters. (Spoiler: He learned gratitude when he was closer to 40 than to 20 years old.)
And Washington appears to have had health problems as a boy. (It seems some of our best-loved presidents were sick kids. Coolidge, FDR, TR, JFK, Madison, Jackson and Wilson. Weird.)
Did you know GW was quite the land speculator? Not always a good one - but very aggressive and greedy, and too impetuous at times, but visionary in this regard nonetheless.
We’ll see many of the foundations for the qualities this book is meant to address, as well as many of the things he had to overcome. How studious was he, how athletic, how persistent, how ambitious?
Was George a player, skirt chaser? So far my reading leaves me uncertain if his biographers are just being kind by only dropping the occasional randy hints. Or are they constricted by a lack of contemporaneous knowledge imparted by his peers? One of his land survey companions referred to him as “often lusty”. Hmmm. What would have his older brother, or his friend George William Fairfax have said in a frank moment about George the Lothario. Was he even a real Lothario? And if he was, how did that shape or effect George the leader?
For all I know, that previous paragraph may be just me, unintentionally selling the sizzle. I’m not kidding. You are going to be learning most of what I know about of GW, and ALL the leadership comparatives, within about two weeks of me learning it, based on the system I am using to create the work. More on the system later.
Washington was a gambler. That it didn’t destroy him says he probably wasn’t an addict. In fact the record is pretty clear it didn’t remain an important part of his later life. And yet, he kept a strict accounting for his wins and losses in his ledgers. How masochistic is that if you’re on a bad run?
We all know Washington had slaves. As a boy and young man, he seems to have seen slaves as not much more important than an inventory item; plows, shovels, slaves, pikes, livestock, etc. As a general, fighting for …