Often when reading or listening to two Lefties talking about political opponents is like listening to twelve year-olds talking about another early adolescent more popular than they are. They share nonsensical comments that both know are not true. The nonsense binds them together, taking on perverse meaning in their silly, little lives.
And so it is most mornings when I plug into the media to check on my Lefty counterparts. This morning I read an article so devoid of reality I had to share it with you. It’s in a Washington Post column called Today’s WorldView by Ishaan Tharoor with Sammy Westfall. In it, Tharoor interviews Jacob Heilbrunn, historical revisionist of the first order - and all around middle school mean girl.
But don’t worry. The delivery is tarted up to be quite august and intellectual. But it’s as substantive as Harvey the Rabbits fuzzy ears.
I don’t have the time or space to pick it all apart here. Like many Lefty articles, as they list myth after myth to meet their fantasies, it would take a small book to completely and factually refute. I’ll hit some of the most ridiculous points.
Right out of the gate is the episode title: Trump, Orban and the GOP’s deep obsession with foreign demagogues.
Hmmm. Biden is the MOST powerful demagogue in the world right now. What, with his Nuremburg rally in front of Independence Hall or that circus stunt SOTU on Thursday - that was top-shelf demagoguery. I had four pages (8 1/2 x 11) of shorthand notes. There couldn’t have been more than three full thoughts in the whole speech that were fact or reason-based. And I’m pretty sure the GOP isn’t obsessed with him. And Trump is only obsessed with sending him back to Wilmington.
But this is the second most common theme in Lefty propaganda, isn’t it? They USUALLY can’t form a cogent argument against people working in their own best interests, so they need to toss out labels. For the record, I doubt the average WAPO reader can define demagogue without a dictionary. Tharoor surely knows this. But it’s a snappy epithet and he backs it up with the number one label Lefties hurl around at their peril - racist.
Yeah, we’ll see that here too.
Tharoor’s first use of the term demagogue (I’m already tired of using the word here) is directed at Victor Orban, Prime Minister of Hungary. He is referred to as the “bete noir” of the EU. Do you see the mean girl oozing out there?
But why is his noir so bete? Well, they are glad you asked. The point of the article is the GOP’s obsession with dictators. The implication here is that Orban is a dictator and Trump and the GOP are obsessed with him. And Jacob Heilbrunn is hawking a book, absurdly entitled America Last: The Right’s Century-Long Romance with Foreign Dictators. The premise in the title is wildly removed from reality. More about that in a minute or two.
From ALL evidence, of course, Orban is nothing of the sort. He is a duly elected Chief Executive with a clear majority in parliament. He is clear-minded in what he wishes to accomplish in office.
If there is a weakness in Hungarian politics it is that there Supreme Court is elected. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see the folly in that.
But that wasn’t Orban’s idea.
The offense Orban is most guilty of is putting the interests of his citizens above that of the EU, as does Germany, France, Italy, Poland, Greece (when they have two pennies to run together) and the UK before Brexit.
BUT…stand by for the R word…his biggest snub of the EU is Orban digging in his heels against the free-flow of foreign Muslims into his country. And THIS is where the charge of racism comes in. Leave aside that fact that Islam is a religion, not a race. Leave aside that the countries sending the hoards are geographic entities. Leave aside that many pouring over the borders have declared that they are colonizing Europe to bring their backward religion to the infidel. It is the backward cultures, crime, crowding and primarily the Dark Ages version of the religion he wants to keep out of his country. Where race factors into any of those considerations, he has the guts to say he doesn’t give a shit.
And it would appear that propagandists, like the “conversants” in the WAPO article, have not gotten to the Hungarian people. They agree with Orban and rewarded him with an election. So much for demagoguery and racism and the dictator nonsense.
So here I am, about five minutes into a critique of an article it took me less time to read. I’ve barely progressed beyond the intro. That is what worries me about modern “journalism” and what people see. This is a perfect example of throwing out talking points, invective and outright falsehood (usually just strongly implied, so it can be denied later) and it washes over the busy reader, who shakes his head and worries - oh my! The GOP likes crazy dictators! That’s what rags like WAPO see as victory - the furtherance of your ignorance.
People like Tharoor know the pace of life. They know you’re skimming information. His guest, Heilbrunn hopes you’ll react to a splashy title and might even buy his book. You don’t have time to digest and thwart this kind of garbage.
But I do. It’s what I do. Always check in with the skeptic. This is especially true when breathy, agitated “liberals” are screaming “racist” or “dictator” or “do it for the children!” Always follow up with a skeptic. You will almost always find real truth there. At least you’ll have a balanced view upon which to make a more sound assessment.
There are others who fill this role nicely. But I am the most handsome, and know Ron Cori, so that makes me sort of important.
Does size matter?
In what other ways does the WAPO article toy with perception? Well, it seems Tharoor has confused political acumen with…size. Right out of the gate Tharoor tells us that Hungary is a small country, with a small population. In context it is crystal clear that he is disparaging Orban’s worldview because he’s from a small country.
Dear reader, he is saying, only people who live in large countries with HUGE populations and strong central governments can possibly understand the complexities of life. What, with all the planning and controls and regulation the MUST be maintained… Who is this uppety central European to make decisions for his own people. Thank GOD Americans and Western Europeans are so docile! And look at the size of their countries! Their Lefties must be brilliant!
Oh, but are these Lefties brilliant? Are the Europeans still so docile? More on those questions in a future article.
The “history” here is just laughable!
In an effort to CREATE the illusion of a pattern here, regarding populism, and racism and love of dictators among whom Heilbrunn calls the “right” he has made a hash of history, often making it up out of whole cloth, at least in this interview.
He says that the “right”, going back to 1920 and before were enamored with the Kaiser, and the “rising of tide of color”. Perhaps Heilbrunn might endeavor to study history before presuming to write about it.
From the Civil War through the 1960’s the greatest concern for the “rising tide of color” was among what we now call the American Left. From the KKK to Woodrow Wilson and FDR’s progressives to labor unions, the people who openly exhibited their fear and/or loathing of other races were Democrats.
Heilbrunn conflates business men with political figures and ethnic Germans, three distinct entities with different motivations as being enamored with the Kaiser. For the Germans the Kaiser may have meant something. But he didn’t mean the same thing to “conservative” politicians or businessmen. The businessmen wanted business. Pre-WWI, the racist Wilson was quietly working AGAINST the wishes of the Amercian “left” and “right” to get us into a war we didn’t REALLY need to fight.
Wilson had hegemonic international ambitions. Right or wrong, he knew if we flexed our industrial, and thereby military muscle on the Europ…