Listen

Description

I’ve had a fortuitous convergence of input and ideas in the preceding week.  I’ve been reading the Personal Memoirs of Memoirs of Ulysses S. Grant and The Ayn Rand Column (which surprisingly enough, is a compilation of columns Ayn Rand wrote for the LA Times in the early ‘60s. Who’d’a thunk it).

While that’s going on, I happened across a clip of Jordan Peterson discussing “toxic” masculinity.  An old favorite. And though some Boomers and the next two generations believe that history started the day they reached puberty, they may want to listen to Peterson, Grant and Rand to expand their knowledge and thinking about manhood.

The drivel about the “sensitive” male is not new.  The InstaGram dorks spouting this garbage today did not invent a new, revolutionary concept.  The idea of the “toxic” male, the “domineering” male, the mansplainer…are all phony, meaningless contrivances weak men in every generation invent to look down upon.  I’ve seen iterations of it in the 1960’s, then the late 80’s and early 90’s, then it reemerged again as fashionable around 2015.  Sadly, with the dumbing down effect of social media, the idea is a bit stickier this time around.  I think the gibberish about “toxic” masculinity this time around is amplified by the immergence of hard-core gender bending.  Before society gets to dealing with the subtle differences between “strong” and “bad” men, we will have to squash the bugs who want bearded lady circus freaks sharing the restroom with our teenage daughters.  But that is for another show.

I worry whether we’ve gone so far around the bend this time that we might not find a path back.

Sometimes it’s women who conflate the behavior of psychotic or insecure men with whom they’ve interacted, with the idea of a strong man.  These men had, or pursued, perverse power over the lives of some women. The women rightfully resented it.  But, in their minds, and because of the mistreatment, all strong men become sexual predators.  It’s like the lunatics we see frequently saying that all white people are racist by virtue of their being white, an equally stupid concept.

Also, with varying degrees of success, celebrity weaklings of various levels of fame, have succeeded in convincing at least a part of their generation that REAL men are bad. Sunken-chested weaklings are the pillars of society.  The whole mess can be far more nuanced than I can possibly account for here.  It runs the gambit from women who think their power derives from demeaning men in the workplace to males emulating weak fathers, or obsessed with their mothers, to cuckoldry.  But there is no valid reason to denigrate the role of strong healthy men in society.  When societies throughout history did that, they damaged themselves.

We’ll start with Peterson and expand out.

One of the points he tends to hammer home is the difference between men who are a danger to society - violent men, bad men - and men who are capable of violence – capable of being dangerous – but not at all cruel or violent by default.

The former is not such because he suffers from being male.  Most people, not just men, who are violent, are the way they are because they have failed in some other area of life, or because influential figures in their life failed them.  In the case of men, it can at least be said that someone, by word or deed, taught them a warped view of life and how to interact with others.  I suspect there are often psychological disorders involved.

These types of people, especially men are dangerous and behave in a dangerous way.  They tend to be violent or at least mindlessly aggressive by default.

I won’t get into how we deal with these people now.  But I am not terribly sympathetic toward adults who have come of age and not learned the error in their ways or not realized they had a problem and tried to combat it.

All this contrasts with the strong man.  Men who live a healthy life and have people and interests to protect.  Is it not best that these men be at least capable of violence?  Should his home be invaded, is it not the highest good that he be capable of putting a bullet in the skull of the invader rather than seeing his family harmed?  If someone enters his place of business, attacking customers or destroying his property, is it not correct that he causes that to stop, by violent means if necessary?

On this subject, Peterson makes an excellent point.  A man with the capacity to be dangerous, who would only employ that propensity, when necessary, is not a bad man.  Conversely, the man who is not dangerous because he is weak, is not automatically a good man.  One might argue that if he remained weak in all situations, he is a bad man.  This despite that he might be a very pleasant person to talk to.

It's ironic that the people best known to espouse the views of the weakest in our culture (I emphasize “espouse” because it is not genuine) are Hollywood showfolk.  They tend to advance the weakest and most socially denigrating ideas in public, then go on to glorify the mindless or vindictive violence we are speaking of here, in their work.  In many cases they venerate or make excuses for the worst kinds of violence that go beyond protecting lives and homes.  Their flicks often put gratuitous violence front and center.

My take is this:  It is by allowing those with a twisted proclivity for dangerous and violent behavior to roam the streets, and by holding up the weak as good, we coarsen society.  By respecting strong men who behave respectfully and by teaching our boys to become such men, we improve society immeasurably.

There will be a button, with the others, below the audio line and text, for a video.  There you can see Peterson’s views firsthand.

Ayn Rand’s take on manliness

As I said earlier, there is nothing new in this conflict of ideas.  With the least exception, a straight line runs from the political Left, those who wish to control our lives and be obeyed, and the people who seek to denigrate personal strength and free thought.  You won’t find too many people, men or women on the Right, for example, who care a lick about your “personal” pronouns.  Nor will you find many there who wish to raise weak, docile men. 

In one of Ayn Rand’s columns, she spoke of the media’s reaction to the TV series, The Untouchables.  As you might expect, in the context of this post, the media elites were panning the very qualities in the main character and storyline, that this post endorses.  The writers and producers intentionally created Elliot Ness with a morals-based sense of purpose.  He was intensely focused, slow to anger, but quick to destroy that which would destroy the society he protects.

Here's how Rand sees Robert Stack’s “Ness”:

By the austere, unsmiling grimness of his manner, the total self-confidence even in moments of temporary defeat, so total that it can afford to be unstressed, the controlled intensity, the quiet absolute dedication to the moral justice of his task, Stack conveys the integrity of a truly untouchable man – a man whom evil cannot tempt, because it has nothing to offer him.  By the faint, occasional hints of a bitterly patient weariness, he projects that fighting evil is not a lark or a glamorous adventure, but a grim job and deadly battle.

As Rand points out, it was these very traits the softies in the media attacked in their reviews of the series.  If the term “toxic masculinity” existed in the 60’s, the triggered reviewers of The Untouchables would have ALL used it.  They did not then, as the InstaGram knuckleheads do not now, understand the actual qualities that make men, real men, men who strengthen society. 

The cyclical concept of weak or primarily sensitive men being superior is a contrivance.  It is the creation of weak men and insecure women lashing out against qualities they lack, and perhaps wish they possessed.  But they don’t – so they try to belittle the men who do.

Ulysses S. Grant

I included Grant in this discussion because I happened to have his and Rand’s books open at t…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.streetpolitics.us