Thin threads, crazy possibilities!
When History Professor, Mile Stroud was on the Free Zone, we discussed the thin threads of history, and the profound and sweeping the outcomes of seemingly small events.
The two events we discussed were Lee’s key decision at Gettysburg and the German’s siege of Bastogne. In a later discussion with friends on FB, I expounded on the Gettysburg pivot. For those who have not seen the two episodes with Mike, and you should, I’ll leave links in the text.
Quick Ad
Help keep the P4B and Free Zone free.
Here and now, I’ll provide a more detailed consideration of these events.
My point about Bastogne centered on how, thanks to the military “genius” of Adolf Hitler, it was decided, late in the planning for what we know as “The Battle of the Bulge”, to invest Bastogne rather than bypass it. Hitler noticed the cross roads at the town and decided this geographical feature made it critical to capture, thus dooming the blitzkrieg concept behind the whole affair.
In reality, Hitler might have read something about the importance of holding a crossroad, or had a detail of key part of a larger battle provided in a briefing…and it stuck.
Yes, if you wish to hold a specific area, capturing a crossroads town is a good idea. But if the German tank division had blown past the town, the bulk of the allied armies would have had to spread out east and west to pursue the dash to Antwerp. Since the idea was to push west as quickly as possible, the idea of holding territory should have been solidly secondary, and with the Allies in the area spread thin by a hard spear thrust, and with German infantry following the thrust, rolling up Bastogne might have been a relatively easy task.
If Hitler didn’t stomp all over the planning of an otherwise brilliant maneuver, and the Germans just REACHED Antwerp in strength, even if they didn’t reconquer the port, what might have been the results? Keep in mind, the Germans got to within 20 miles of their objective. Had they not wasted precious time, ammunition and fuel at Bastogne, they might have reached Antwerp before the weather cleared.
My point to Mike was that the war would have been extended for at least a year, maybe more. Even with an organized withdrawal, after damaging the port facilities, there is a chance serious damage might have been inflicted on the British units to the north. They would have lacked supply as well as the initiative. As the allies controlled the seas by that time, a more organized “Dunkirk” might have been considered. But as a minimum the allies would have been substantially, if temporarily weakened. For the Wehrmacht to have fallen back through towns like Bastogne, and possibly held one or two, the battle just to retake Belgium would have been no cake walk for the Allies. With Patton’s Third Army and renewed air operations, closing the salient was hard enough.
We’d have reached the summer of ’45 with two major strategic problems. 1. The western allies would have likely not have been charging to Berlin yet. And 2. The Soviets would have been.
In reality, this would not have been too big a deal for FDR. He was a sick man. He had a weird fascination with Stalin. But Truman was properly broken in by his military advisors and properly saw Stalin and a necessary evil at best. Churchill would have been beside himself at the very idea of The Soviets thrashing around Germany unchecked.
And by the summer of 1945, we had the bomb. Two of them, in fact.
Considering Truman’s position, I would contend that there is no way he’d have dropped both on Japan. He wanted to end the Pacific war, to be certain. But he would have been advised, correctly, that we needed to not only crush German resistance, we had to give Stalin a front row seat to throttle back his ambitions! We’d have nuked Germany.
The guys making the “Gadgets” as the A bombs were called, would have been working round the clock to make as many more bombs as they could find materials for. How much longer would that have taken? I don’t know. But the world we live in today would look so much different!
We just might have taken Patton up on his idea of pushing the Russians back to at least their prewar position in Poland - or threatened to do so. I feel confident, after watching the mushroom cloud grow over Europe and not having one of his own, Stalin would have been okay with just ALL of Eastern Europe. But the idea of satellite states would have been shit canned. In its place would have been the complete annexation of all remaining conquered territory by the Soviets. And truth be told, there was nothing we could have done about that.
In Episode 37, Bob Zeidman talked about how easy it was to get the Germans to cooperate after WWII. He said we had fought the war in such a way that the locals feared us more than they ever feared the Nazis. The Japanese had an even more exaggerated fear of the Allies, especially Americans. They watched us level two cities with one bomb each.
What would it have done to the psyche of a European, as crazy as Hitler was, to watch the Allied powers do the same thing to a major city in Germany? It would have taken months before a German could look a Yank in the eye! Germans would have been tripping over each other to turn in every Nazi not already in the run from Allied authorities. Brits and French would have been looking over our shoulders, eyes as big as saucers. We could have gotten even more out of Bretton Wood than we actually did.
The possibilities expand exponentially with every passing year. UNTIL…Russia gets their bomb. Now loyalties would be tested.
I leave it to you to play with all those possibilities. Tell me the possibilities you see after a nuked Germany or after the next “What if…?”
Bobby Lee
But what if we now skewed the timeline so that the World Wars would have never taken place? Or taken place earlier? Or if they had been one long war? Let’s go further back in time.
Throughout the Civil War, Lee had a reputation for brilliant maneuver. He conducted himself in such a way as to make his actions at Gettysburg unimaginable. He split his forces in the face of a numerically superior enemy at Charlottesville. And won. He could have done that at Gettysburg.
He quietly slipped away from Yorktown while McClellan dithered. This was a huge win for the Confederacy. He had every opportunity to do that before the night of 2 June 1863.
I contend that Lee was starting to believe his own press releases. As he was rolling up an impressive string of victories (or at least having the Union is complete disarray, he was quoted as saying, “I never leave the field to the advantage of the enemy,” or words to that effect.
The one thing we know about the Union Army before Grant took over, was their aversion to pursuit, after engagements, won or lost.
Now, put all that together. Lee, AP Hill, Longstreet and others are looking across at the union positions. Several were advising Lee to quietly disengage and beat feet to Washington DC, which was lightly defended. It would have been a very sound maneuver. Cut loose some of the artillery and a large Cavalry element. Then push supplies and the bulk of the army off. When the sun comes up on the third a thoroughly bloodied Union army would wake to find that if there is any fighting at all it will be a Confederate rear guard action.
If he were to remain true to form, Meade (Union) would have been relieved to see the field abandoned and would likely not react until told Lee was moving on DC. By that time, it would have been too late.
Instead Lee spurned this great advice. THIS was the time he actually chose NOT to leave the field to the enemy when he had so little chance of dislodging that enemy. Both sides were taking terrible losses throughout the campaign in exchange for a few yards of ground here and there. Some spots changed hands repeatedly.
“No. Whip ‘em here. Whip ‘em here.”
Had he taken his general…