Listen

Description

Carnival took up Monday but I kept it on the low-down, a quick early morning dance at the wings of the parade which passed so close to my flat I practically ran out there in my pyjamas, the women and men and gender queer glorious in their collective finery; the beauty on show took my breath and gave it back in armfuls of fish net flesh and feathers. I noticed me noticing the complete absence of eyes on me which just goes to show how used to I am to being visible, a creased and funny-looking white lady out dancing like she doesn’t care who’s watching which after years on dance floors in all kinds of weathers, I don’t, but it turns out I am used to being watched. The ego of me shamefully taking a reckoning, the whiteness of me revealing its thousand year old entitlement to the centre ground. Carnival is truth, a complicity of community in action. It’s happiness and fun a challenge to a thousand year old story that says I am the trunk and you are the boughs. Oliver Radclyffe talked about this when we explored how cis het is not a neutral position. And sam baker and Angie Browne and I talked about this on Wednesday when we converged our thoughts around menopause and women and visibility.

I have been visible for much of my life, certainly to the exterior world outside my childhood home, I had all the attributes granted high status by an environment constructed of the thesis it’s the fittest who survive - fittest being white and western and wealthy and heterosexual and cis-gendered. If in the seventies such words and examination were the norm, these would have been all my labels. Andrew Wille and I have since proudly declared ourselves politically queer and non-binary though the idea of labelling myself anything feels laughably right-on and inappropriatly young. As Dora Carrington said, “I’m a female human and Iive in Mexico.” I’m a writer. Everything else is secondary to that.

But to pick up the river of my thoughts from that small diversion - I noticed how I noticed I was of no interest whatsoever. There were no eyes on me apart from the occasional smile across oceans of dancing, the rhythm being our language, and it stood out to me, this noticing, that without noticing at all I had been used to being visible. These reckonings come in stages. This was another and it fed into the river of conversations I’ve been having, adding and enriching, as did a Radio 4 programme I happened upon where a group of scientists questioned why the famous “survival of the fittest” adage which Darwin never said, has been taken up as THE story when all of nature bears out the truth that it is in fact survival of the symbiotic, the most collaborative, those life forms which recognise and value community.

I’ve become interested in understanding us as stories, and this story, that we are top-down, zero sum, every man for himself creatures of selfishness and singularity is the story becoming singularly fiction in its visibility. Isolationism, monoculture, and separation are across the board the ingredients for a miserable life and death by a thousand lonely nights. Look at an Oak marooned in a ploughed field. Feel closely and you’ll hear them cry. We need each other. You don’t need me to tell you that. Even the solitary writer, getting up at 5am every morning to plough on with a novel which may or may not grow and seed and sprout into something you’ll one day hold in your hands needs their family of friends as antidote, which is what I’m doing now, off to celebrate C with lunch and then off further to St Pancras International, the Eurostar and France.

Eleanor

ps

Also, this happened. I’m so chuffed and thrilled that I actually feel shy about it.

Thank you, Kit. This is community in action.



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit eleanoranstruther.substack.com/subscribe