Listen

Description

Carissa Justice is a copywriter, creative director in Atlanta. She is the founder of Nimble Creative, a brand studio focused on voice, naming, and storytelling. Her clients have included Google, Strava, Figma, and ThirdLove. She previously served as Verbal Lead at CharacterSF. In 2023 she founded The Subtext, an online publication and community dedicated to elevating the craft of brand language.

So I start all these conversations with the same question. You may or may not know this, but it’s a question I borrowed from a friend of mine who helps people tell their story. And it’s a big, beautiful question, which is why I ask it, but because it’s big and beautiful, I kind of over-explain it like I am doing right now.

And so before I ask it, I really want you to know that you’re in total control and you can answer or not answer any way that you want to. And the question is, where do you come from?

All right, I think I can start off with the more literal interpretation of that, which is born in Vermont, raised in Massachusetts, have lived all over South Carolina, Atlanta, California for 11 years, and then back to the South. But I think maybe the more emotional response or that might tell you a little bit more is I’m the youngest of three raised by divorced parents.

My dad was like a conservative, Republican pharmaceutical salesman, and my mom’s like a super hippie, liberal animal lover, social worker. So I feel like I got raised by two different worlds, both people that I love dearly.

And I think when I think about that question, it’s fun to think back on it, because I think when I grew up being the youngest, I had a brilliant older sister who was so smart, and then I had a really athletic older brother. So I feel like they had their things and I never really had my thing.

So I did a lot of things and tried to blend in and be the peacemaker and be the kind of easy, and I don’t want to say easy kid, but always was like, I don’t know what I’m doing. I don’t know what I’m good at. So I’ll have fun along the way.

And I think that that’s been a bit of a backdrop of my whole life. It’s doing different things and seeing what sticks and seeing what I like about it and not ever really knowing where I’m going, but trying to enjoy the ride as I go.

Yeah, so much I want to ask about, I guess the first is really Vermont. What does it mean to you to be from Vermont? And are there moments when you feel particularly like a Vermonter?

Yes, I feel like I love being a Vermonter. I only lived there until I was about five, but then my mom moved back up when I went to college. And so that’s always been like home base now for many, many years.

It’s the most beautiful state. It’s so peaceful. I feel like there’s, you could zip me down the middle and half of me belongs like off-grid in the country riding horses and wandering in tall grass.

And the other half belongs deep in a city in the grit and the grime with that rougher kind of hustle edge. And I feel like both feel right at the same time.

Yeah. Yeah, where in Vermont were you when you were there?

I was born in Brattleboro, but my mom has a farm up in Northeast Kingdom outside St. Johnsbury. That’s a beautiful place. She’s a 72 years old and still a competitive horseback rider.

She has horses and cows and chickens and sheep and whole menagerie.

Yeah. What did young Carissa want to be when she grew up?

I wanted to be an in living color fly girl for a little bit. I wanted to be on SNL. I wanted to be, I don’t know.

I think I was very influenced by whatever I was watching on TV. I think the only thing I knew in school that I was decent at was writing. So I think I always followed that because I was so, so tragically bad at math.

Dumb, dumb at math. And science was really hard. So I was like, I guess it’s English for this girl all the way. But I don’t think I knew what I wanted at all.

Can you tell a story about that? About, I guess the way writing showed up early for you?

Yeah. Well, I think my mom was doing, went back to school when I was young. And got her master’s in social work.

And so I feel like she was always writing papers and clacking away at the computer. So I think I saw her, she was very, I think she was quite the writer. Even, I think she really enjoyed that part of her studies.

And so I think that infiltrated me a little bit. And then I was not the best test taker. I was really bad at memorization.

And so I would revel at a paper project because I’d be able to do it in my own time. And so I think that was my only source of feeling like I was okay at school. So I think that, I remember writing papers and being like, oh, okay, I’ll at least get a B because I know I can nail this.

And then if I mess everything else up, that’ll be my saving grace. So I think I found comfort in being pretty good with words.

Yeah. I really identify with that, how painful, impossible math and science, they didn’t seem to enter my consciousness in any meaningful way at all. But words were very easy.

Yeah. And I think, I didn’t know it at the time, but my grandfather was a copywriter and I didn’t even for a good part of his career. And my grandmother was like an editor and also a writer.

And I think, I didn’t know, when you’re a kid, you don’t really dig into your lineage as much. But as I got older, I was like, oh, that’s so interesting. Because I always thought they were artists.

My whole mom’s side, they’re so creative, so artistic, and there’s art everywhere. And it’s all done by people in the family. And so I always like, oh, they were artists, but they were actually writers. And they also happened to be really good at art.

Wow.

And so I think I’m probably lucky for what I was maybe given a bit naturally on that front.

How did you come to discover that they were copywriters? Given what you’re doing now, that’s pretty beautiful.

I think when I was in college, I was trying to figure out my major. I think my mom, I went to see my grandmother and cause I did all my internships in New York and I went and visited her. She lived outside of Westport, Connecticut.

So I would take the train out to go see her and my mom met up with us and then I got to, they just started talking to me a lot more about her life. And I remember just being like, oh, wow. That’s so cool.

But yeah, even in college though, I don’t think I knew, I didn’t know that copywriting was a thing.

So- What were they doing? What kind of copywriting were they doing?

So my grandfather did, he was the copywriter to the art director in advertising. So we worked for a local advertising firm and just pitched ideas to local companies.

It’s funny, I just completely randomly ended up watching just because of the queue happened that way, watching the premiere of Mad Men. And so that whatever you’re bringing into this conversation, you just got all this imagery from that show.

Have you watched it, the whole thing yet?

Yeah, I watched it when it was- Yeah. So I hadn’t revisited it in a while and it was amazed at how good it felt to watch. I was a long time ago.

I don’t even know when that premiered, but it’s beautiful. That first episode is amazing. They’re all so young, of course, but it’s amazing.

It’s amazing show. I’ve watched it twice and the second time was even better because I think you have such a, I don’t know, you’re not waiting to see what happens, but you just get to see how good they play it out and the different storylines and the references. I don’t know.

It’s such a genius show and Jon Hamm is my forever number one.

Yeah. Yeah, he’s something else. Yeah, and it’s funny, even in that first episode, not to get to derail a little bit, but they have a researcher, it’d be selfishly, there’s a researcher that comes in and they’re trying to pitch the tobacco client and they have this woman with a German accent come and represent Freudian insights into the behavior.

And Don Draper is like, “What the f**k?” They’re all like, “What are you talking about? That’s insane.” They ridicule her for bringing this psychological ins…



Get full access to THAT BUSINESS OF MEANING at thatbusinessofmeaning.substack.com/subscribe