Ed Cotton is a Chief Strategy Officer based in Brooklyn. His newsletter, PROVOKE, is wonderful. He spent 20 years as Chief Strategy Officer at BSSP, an award-winning advertising agency. Previously, he was Head of Strategy at McCann-Erickson in Seattle. Since 2019, Ed has been running his own consultancy, Inverness Consulting LLC. He helps brands, agencies, and marketers with strategy development across various industries, from insurance to luxury travel. Ed's expertise includes new business pitches, brand thinking, and inspiring creativity in strategy teams.
Okay. All right. So I think you probably see this coming, but I start all these interviews with the same question, this question that I borrowed from a friend of mine, who's an oral historian. She helps people tell their story and I borrow it because it's such a beautiful question, but I over-explain it because it hits really hard. And so before I ask it, I want you to know you're in total control and you can answer or not answer this question in any way that you want to. And the question is, where do you come from?
It's a great question. I've always thought of myself as... first of all, I think you can't escape national identity. Being English, you can't really disguise it. As much as I try to speak American, it doesn't really work. I think people know I don't come from this country.
At best, it confuses them and they say you're not really English. You're probably Australian or South African, but we're not really sure. But no one's saying to me, "I'm an American." I've been here over 20 years. So I haven't fooled anyone. Yeah, I think where I come from is quite important to me.
And it's a very interesting relationship because I haven't lived in that country for over 20 years. So I'm not a nomad, stateless really. I don't really feel like I'm an American and I certainly don't feel like I'm really truly English because I haven't spent time there. So I'm in this nomad land which we call "caught between two cultures," taking a very literal interpretation of the question.
But is it quite an important thing? I think that... it sounds like an uncomfortable place to be, but I think it's actually quite a good place to be because I do think that the outsider perspective is always interesting. I do think you have something, you can see things that others can't 'cause they're too close to it.
And when I first came here, you are a tourist for a number of... even though you moved to the U.S. and I talked to people who've recently moved to the U.S., I'm like, you're still a tourist. You're probably going to be a tourist for five years. Everything's going to be new.
And then there comes a moment in time where there's a sort of normalization. I remember very clearly the sort of story of, I'm living in Seattle, I've probably been there a week and there's an earthquake. Most of us know that earthquakes... Yeah, they may happen everywhere. We had one in New York the other day, but the major earthquakes like to happen in Seattle. Anyway, the word "earthquake" went through the news organizations. And there was this, I remember this scene that was on the night, it was on the evening news and it was, they were broadcasting live from a grocery store on the outskirts of Seattle, where a newscaster, a news reporter was going through a blow-by-blow account of how a bottle of ketchup may or may not have fallen off the shelf and smashed on the ground, as the only way they could dramatize the earthquake. And it was just like a classic hyperbole that in an American sense that I knew so well from being in the UK. And I've been... it's been mocked and ridiculed and used as cross-satire or I was witnessing it myself.
But over time that sort of stuff has become quite normal to me. I don't react the same way that I used to. So yeah, going back to that question, I come from the UK, I think I come from England and actually even deeper than that I'm a Londoner, so I was born in London, which is rare. It's like being born in New York City. And I think that means another thing, that cities are quite important to me. I have lived in San Francisco. Everyone loves this idea of San Francisco that is a world of these two cultures, the yin and yang, the sort of restful, mindful state can exist in the national parks that are on the doorstep. And you can also experience some of the best food in the world in the city. So this is one of the few places where you can experience that dual existence. But I actually, at the end of the day, prefer a true city. And I think New York is a true global city. And that's, again, a big part of my identity. I think that being a citizen in a city sense is really important, and important to me. I value it a lot.
Yeah. Do you have memories of what you wanted to be when you grew up? As a child, did you have an idea what you wanted to be when you grew up?
When I was in my early teens, 11, 12, I think... yeah, for a lot of my teen years, I was quite interested in animals for some reason, and I don't know why, and I think it came from my dad. My dad spent a lot of time... he's a, he was a horse rider. He owns horses, spends a lot of time in that world. So I did at one point want to be a vet. Only to discover that my math is just terrible. I could do biology. I can do chemistry to a degree, but math, it's just... if you have any desire to pursue anything scientific and you're not good at math, you really have trouble. But I did for some... I did work with racehorses. I worked in a racing stable. I got to know a lot about it. At one point I knew a lot about horse breeding, as in more like the sort of data behind horse breeding. Like, how you could trace lineages. Actually, racehorses can really go back to, there are actually three horses or four horses, Arab horses that every racehorse is descended from. If you are really nerdy, you could actually trace every horse's pedigree back. And so I... I wasn't, I went through a phase a couple of years of just being really obsessed with trying to understand what breeders, how breeders bred horses. Looking at pedigrees, why you, the mare and the stallion, what would they, what could they bring as resources to creating a new resource?
I remember I had these huge dossiers and all kinds of stuff. And I went to meet somebody very high up in the bloodstock industry. And they were like, "I can't believe this kind of, this is just unseen, unprecedented nerdism and we want to offer you a job." At 16, I think they were offering me a job to be like an apprentice bloodstock agent. What a bloodstock agent does is they buy and sell horses, mainly buy horses for wealthy owners. So you travel the world and you sit in an auction ring as these young horses, one-year-olds usually, are paraded around and you're putting bids in. It's an incredibly interesting world, incredibly exciting, but at 16, I was just way too young to make a committed decision. I'm like, "This is going to be, I'm going to have to go to college. I'm going to go and train and this would be my life and if it fails, I don't really have a fallback position.
What was the nerdism? What was the fascination?
I don't know really what, it was... I don't know where it came from really. It was just, there was... I don't, it was like just a phase I went through and it was just this incredibly analytical and really disciplined... You can only go so far. The thing is there are thousands of races every day around the world and there is no way an individual can keep up with all of them. And those races are the data that you use to calculate the value and the worth of a certain horse, certain stallions suddenly start... They start and their children start racing and there's, it's just, it's a whole really complicated world that you could just like a wormhole or rabbit hole. You can just dive into it and get completely lost. And I didn't go as far as I could have done. I've really scratched the surface. And even then, yeah, it was a lot 'cause you're doi…