Lindsey Wehking is the Chief Investigative Strategy Officer (CSO) at Nonfiction Research in Brooklyn. If I remember correctly, I first met Lindsey in 2021 in Brooklyn, when I reached out to Nonfiction in a fanboy kind of way. I ran into Lindsey at the 4As Stratfest in New York City, where she presented (with Jim Stengel!) “Why taking your clients into nightclubs is the future of insights.” I was excited to talk to her about her path to this work, and how they work at Nonfiction.
I think you may know this, but I say it anyway, but I start all of these conversations with the same question, which I borrow from a neighbor of mine who helps people tell their story. And I stole it because it's a big, beautiful question, but because it's a big, beautiful question, I over-explain it, like I'm doing now. So before I ask it, I want you to know you're in absolute control.
You can answer and not answer any way that you want to. And the question is, where do you come from?
I knew this question was coming, and I purposely had to resist the urge to over-engineer. I feel like it's a beautiful question, but it's also the kind of question people over-engineer their answers to. And so it's funny, I just closed my eyes and tried to figure out what visual came to mind.
And the image that kept coming to mind was of me when I was about eight years old, sitting in my dad's burgundy Ford Ranger, a 92 Ford Ranger, in our driveway with him, listening to NPR. My parents were notoriously defects from the Catholic church, and so I feel like NPR sort of became our religion. And my dad and I, he would pick me up from school when I was a kid, and my dad loved the heat, so he loved to sit in a hot car and bake like a poor man's sauna after work.
And I loved it too, so we would just sit in his hot car, sauna-ing, listening to very in-depth reporting on some anthropologist talking about the history of sex in human society, or what the Tootsies were up to. And I don't know why, but I feel like something about my personality is just forever ingrained in a shitty Ford Ranger listening to NPR with my dad.
And where were you? Where did you grow up?
Right outside of St. Louis, Missouri, on the east side of the river, so Illinois, so we were kind of edging the great western gateway.
Yeah. And you said they're sort of notoriously, I can't remember how you said it, but they left the Catholic church. What made that significant?
Both my parents came from, my dad came from a large Catholic family, and my mom came from a smaller Catholic family. But I feel like they in the era of scandal in the Catholic church, all of the priest abuse. I feel like at that time, every week a new leader of the Catholic church you found out was gambling away everyone's donations.
And so that had a big, especially my dad, that had a really profound impact on him because I think he yearned so much to believe and part of believing, especially believing in the Catholic doctrine was such a big part of belonging in his family. And yet he just couldn't stomach what he felt like was a lot of the hypocrisy and the contradiction. And because of that, he was such a seeker.
I think that's why the church of NPR, I joke, kind of was the church of our family because without the church, I think he was looking for other ways to seek connection and wisdom and knowing and not being able to put a God up there. I think we just all put, I don't know, nerd stuff, which may not be the best God, but it's not a terrible substitute.
And do you have a recollection of what you wanted to be when you grew up?
When I, God, I was probably in like kindergarten or first grade and my dad took me to work and my dad was a, he was like a network architect. He was an IT at, at Edward Jones, which is like a very old school financial institution that's headquartered in St. Louis. And, and I remember walking in and seeing all of these cubicle people and up here, I found cubicle people fascinating.
I was like, just like, there was all this like drama. Like he would tell me about how like, like lunches would go missing in the office fridge. And there would be like, like there'd be all this, like, like my dad was like a little bit of like a armchair anthropologist.
And so he loved describing the, like the politics that would happen in meetings and the way certain people would like, you know, kind of peacock for attention or the way certain people wouldn't speak their mind. And, and his way of like viewing the corporate world, I just like fell in love with. And I think at some point I like wanted to grow up to study cubicle people.
I was like, this is, this is my purpose. I will study cubicle, which is honestly not far off from what I think I do now.
What, yeah, you mentioned the anthropology even in the NPR segment and your driveway moment with your dad. Was there sort of anthropology or culture in your, in your childhood or?
We were so f*****g white. Like we were so white and without like much, much traditional lineage, I think because of all, like all, you know, we were German, German Catholic and German Protestant. And so because so much of our probably like ancestral ethnic lineage was so tied up in religion.
When we left religion, we kind of were lost of all that. And I think like, I haven't looked into this, but I, I presume there is a whole cohort of white people who feel this way of like, you know, they at one point or another, there was some break from religion in their family. And then you're kind of like left without any tradition or without any real anchor or sense of self.
And like, I don't, you know, honestly connect to like my German-ness or my English-ness. And so as a, yeah, maybe that, maybe that void is part of what made me want to know so much about how other people lived and prayed and loved. I don't know.
Yeah. Yeah. It's amazing. Do you, do you have, can you tell me a story about that void? I'm, I'm identifying a lot with what you've just described and I'm just wondering if, because I know you went, you studied anthropology in college, so there must've been some sort of appetite for that at a relatively young age. I wonder, do you remember what it was like to sort of be in that void?
Oh, I feel like I'm still in the void. I don't know. Maybe we never leave the void.
Yeah. I, I mean, I, you know, I think for the, the first few decades of like trying to figure out who I was, was defined mostly by this insatiable appetite to understand others that like, in some ways I almost didn't have a sense of self. Like it was, it was so, it was so outward looking, but in, in pursuit of, of just like wanting to know how other people lived and found happiness and found safety.
And, and, and I was always very like fascinated with communities that were kind of on the margins. And one of the biggest, one of the first like big ethnographies I did when I was in college was on a, a subculture called Juggalos. I don't know if you're familiar with Insane Clown Posse.
I have a note, I have a note here to ask you about that.
Did you, like, have you, have you ever listened to their music?
I haven't listened. I don't think I've listened to the music.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
I mean, it was very like, I mean, you know, for, for people who don't know, like Juggalos was what they call like a horror, I think this, the genre is actually called horror rap. And so they were two white guys out of Detroit who started in hip hop and rap in, I think they were coming up in kind of the nineties, but by the early two thousands, mid two thousands, they had really cultivated this like insane fan base. And they, you know, were one of like, I think we're kind of seeing a resurgence now in like pop music that has like true ritual.
And like, you get dressed up, you paint your face, you have singalongs, like it's, it's becoming like, there was a time where pop, you didn't like, didn't have fandom that way. But, but Juggalo culture was like true intense fandom. And it was like, it was a very true music subculture.
Like it,…