Listen

Description

Mark Earls is HERDmeister at HERD, his independent behavioral consultancy based in London. He previously served as Chair of Ogilvy’s Global Planning Council, Planning Director at St Luke’s Communications, and Head of Planning at Bates Dorland. He is the author of several influential books on behavior and creativity, including Herd: How to Change Mass Behaviour by Harnessing Our True Nature, I’ll Have What She’s Having, Copy, Copy, Copy, and Welcome to the Creative Age.

I start all these conversations with the same question, which I borrowed from a friend of mine. She helps people tell their story, and I fell in love with the question because it was so big. But because it’s big, I tend to over-explain it—the way I’m doing right now. So before I ask it, I want you to know that you’re in total control. You can answer or not answer in any way you want to. The question is: Where do you come from?

Very good question. Where do I come from? That can be answered in lots of ways, and I think that tells us a lot about how I—and we—are.

So I come from... My parents were the first out of the working class into education in their families. They both worked hard to get us a good education, and I got a scholarship. I found myself actually very lucky to have had that kind of education as a foundation. So that’s where I come from.

Education has been my family’s escape from the working class, and, as it happens, that was probably a good call. The working class that existed at the time my parents were born was based in heavy industry—which is now gone.

And where were you?A family all from South Wales. Coal and steel. My dad had a choice at 14: would he stay on at the grammar school, the high school, or would he take the pair of steel toe-capped boots that his father got him for his job down at the steel mill? That was his choice. He chose grammar school.

Wow.

Right, which was always a matter of tension between him and his family. It wasn’t the proper thing—sitting around reading books and smoking cigarettes. That’s not the proper way. Anyway, so that’s one strand of me.

Another strand is that I was exposed from very early on to other cultures. My mother was a languages teacher, and I spent the time of puberty—before and after—on railways going across Europe to visit friends of the family or to do language courses. I studied languages at university, and I’ve mostly failed to use them—apart from a couple of German girlfriends.

So my view has always been one of curiosity toward people. Not from a psychological perspective, I think—but from a cultural perspective. That’s turned out to be really important to me.

I’ve always been interested in neuroscience. I was the first person who really started talking about Damasio in the ad world. Later on, people like Wendy Gordon started bringing that into market research and insights. I brought some of that through—and, I’m afraid, I introduced Rory Sutherland to Kahneman. That’s on me.

You’ve got the Rory Sutherland-mobile now. But for me, culture is the thing. People are amazing. They live with shared beliefs, practices, and rituals. Culture is what makes us who we are. That’s where I come from—a view of human beings shaped by culture.

There’s a photograph from a family album. I must be six or seven. My younger brother and sister are behind me on one of those fiberglass kids’ slides in the backyard. And I’m in front of them, doing jazz hands.

I’ve always been someone who’s just really excited about the world—very positive. And when I’ve encountered some of the more cognitive-science-based views of human behavior in business and culture lately, I’ve been dismayed. There’s this disappointment at humanity’s inability to be rational.

But we are amazing, extraordinary creatures—even the worst of us. Extraordinary. And that’s how I approach the problems I see.

That’s so—my God, you said so much. So many things. And of course, I remember you putting these concepts forward. It was the first time I ever encountered them. I love what you just said in distinguishing between the kind of—is it sort of a culture of disappointed cognitive psychologists? That framing of our way of being in the world as a failure to be reasonable?

Exactly. Our way of being in the world is amazing. Not all of us get it right, and all of us don’t get it right some of the time.

The world—we are constantly renegotiating it. But we are still extraordinary.

Absolutely extraordinary. If you think of one of the classic desert island questions: if you were marooned on a desert island, how would you get on? Could you build a shelter? Probably it would be a bit crap, honestly. But I could probably knock something together. Maybe it wouldn’t last a monsoon or a tornado, but it could be okay.

Could you catch fish? I probably could. Could you build heating? No. Do you understand how the internal combustion engine works? Yeah, I guess so. Could you make one? No.

All of these things—this know-how—we depend on so many other people to make our lives work. It’s like each of us stands at the front of an army of human history. It’s just amazing when you look at it that way. The stuff that we don’t have to think about individually because humanity—and its culture, its storing and transmission of knowledge across generations and geographies—is just amazing.

No other species does that. It’s amazing.

It really is. And it occurs to me—I’ve struggled with this too—that all the language around the unconscious and irrational... I always return to Lakoff. I think at some point he called it “imaginative reason.” That felt like the one time I encountered a framing of our decision-making, our behavior, as something positive and beautiful and celebratory.

It is amazing. I’ve been lucky enough to do some collaboration with an academic based at the University of Kentucky, Professor Alex Bentley. We did a book together called I’ll Have What She’s Having. He’s an anthropologist and archaeologist. Mike O’Brien is another American archaeology professor. Their take on humanity is that our species is successful because of cultural evolution—our ability to store and spread information, knowledge, and know-how.

You don’t have to think every day, “Now, how do I light a fire again?” You can just look: “Oh, that’s how he does it. Let’s do that.” My shorthand is learned from over there and from here and from my own practice. I don’t have to think about it.

That cultural evolution—culture itself—is the thing that makes us different. Yes, our brains are amazing and our bodies are amazing too. Cognitive abilities are what they are, and they’re particularly suited for the lives we lead. But it’s our cultural capacity that’s the extraordinary bit.

Do you remember a younger you? As a boy, what did you want to be when you grew up?

Very good. I wanted to be a vet—a veterinarian. That’s what I wanted to be. I’ve always loved animals. I have my lovely Irish terrier sitting on the sofa here now, guarding us, making sure no one interrupts our interview. I’ve always loved animals, dogs in particular.

I kept fish as a teenager. I think that was partly a distraction from my parents, partly from the troubles of puberty. Tropical fish—not unusual, is it? I’ve always loved the outdoors. Fishing was something I learned early on, and I loved it. I thought that would be a thing.

My uncle was a chemist, a professor of chemistry, and he was sort of a role model for me. So I must have, in my head, combined the two things. It’s a science-y thing, even though I’m absolutely rubbish at—I struggled. I wasn’t rubbish. I struggled to get what I needed to in those subjects at high school. I was looking for something to combine the two.

Yeah. So what are you doing now? Where are you, and what are you up to now?

I’m based in London. I do a combination of three things. First, I’m writing and thinking—writing and thinking about this amazing thing that is humanity. I’m championing a couple of things right now, to be honest. One of them is my core thesis, which I call the “h…



Get full access to THAT BUSINESS OF MEANING at thatbusinessofmeaning.substack.com/subscribe