Paul Worthington is a brand consultant and President of Invencion, a strategic advisory practice he founded in 2011. Previously he was Client Principal & Head of Strategy; Strategy Director; and Senior Strategist at Wolff Olins in New York. He writes the newsletter Off Kilter and has written for Fast Company.
I start all of these conversations with the same question and the same little prelude, because I borrowed this beautiful question from a friend of mine. She helps people tell their story. She’s an oral historian. And the question is so beautiful, I stole it from her, but it’s very, very big. So I kind of over-explain it the way that I do now. So before I ask it, I want you to know that you’re in absolute control and you can answer or not answer any way that you want to.
And the question is, where do you come from? Again, you’re in absolute control and you can answer or not answer any way that you want to.
Well, of course, being a born contrarian, my first reaction is to answer that question by saying, where do you come from conceptually in this world that we live in, as opposed to where do I come from physically? But I’ll answer it the old-fashioned way first. I originate from the Shetland Islands in Scotland, which is very far away from anything.
We used to describe it jokingly as the center of the North Sea. It has about 20,000 people and about 300-odd thousand sheep. And I lived there for the first 18 years or so of my life, went to college, and ended up from college being in London.
After working in London, I ended up in New York. And these days you find me 20-odd years later in Connecticut.
What was it like growing up in this, as you say, the center of the North Sea?
Well, funnily enough, I’ll give you a comparison to New York. So the island that I come from is called Unst, and Unst is the very furthest north island in the United Kingdom. You cannot get any further north and still be in the UK.
And it’s on the same latitude as Bergen in Norway, and it’s somewhere a little bit south of the Arctic Circle. Unst is almost exactly the same size and shape as Manhattan. It’s roughly three miles across and 12 miles long, but there’s about 600 people living on it instead of 6 million.
And its claim to fame, funnily enough, is Treasure Island, the book. If you look at the map of Treasure Island, it’s almost the perfect map of Unst. And the reason is that Robert Louis Stevenson’s father was a lighthouse engineer. And when Stevenson was a boy, he spent a whole year or so in Unst while his father was building and overseeing the lighthouse, Muckle Flugga, which is the most northerly lighthouse in the UK.
And so years later, when he wrote Treasure Island, he used his memory of Unst to map out the island in the book.
This is unbelievable. It’s such a particular and unique place to grow up. At what point do you discover how unique it is?
I feel like it’s just how you grew up, but then there must be some moment where you realize, my gosh.
It’s funny, because I think when you’re a kid, you’re very cognizant of how unique it is in all the wrong ways. As a child, I remember distinctly watching the ads every Saturday morning or whatever for things like McDonald’s. Of course, there’s no McDonald’s, or Kentucky Fried Chicken.
So you go on holiday and the first thing you want to do is, I want to go have McDonald’s, because you’ve been watching all these ads for six months and you haven’t been able to consume this horrendous food. So you’re very cognizant in that sense. I think when you get older, you reflect back on it and you realize that it is an incredible place.
It’s funny, being able to go back as a tourist gives you different eyes on a place where you grew up, because you had a very different idea of it as a kid. And it is very beautiful. It has some incredible birdlife.
The sea is right there. Obviously, it has a fishing history. But just being able to go off in a boat and see the cliffs and the seals and the dolphins and occasionally see whales.
You don’t realize at the time, when you’re a kid, how special that is, when you drive down to watch the pod of killer whales in the bay and you can hear them. You don’t realize, when you watch them on film, on TV or YouTube or whatever, that these things are really loud. They’re definitely talking to each other.
But that is a real life history. A long time ago, I came from a very far away place.
And how remote was it? Or how much was there back and forth?
Shetland itself is a 14-hour ferry ride from the mainland of the UK. So you get on the ferry at six in the afternoon and you get off at eight in the morning. It takes about an hour on the airplane. It’s a couple hundred miles offshore.
So it’s pretty remote. But it’s also very connected, because it was the hub of the UK’s oil industry in the 70s. So when I was growing up, it was very connected to the world, because the oil industry is a global industry.
What I’ve realized as I got a bit older is it’s generally much more cosmopolitan than other Scottish islands that are much closer in, if you like, but don’t have that connection to the global economy in the same way.
And do you recall what you wanted to be when you were young, Paul? What did you want to be when you grew up?
That’s a funny question. I think, like a lot of boys of my era, my first love was I wanted to be a fighter pilot. And then I found out that you couldn’t be a fighter pilot and wear glasses.
So I was screwed. My pilot dreams were dashed at a young age when I found out that glasses wearers weren’t allowed to fly at Mach 2.
And so now catch us up. Where are you now? And tell us about the work that you do.
These days, I am in the sunny town of Wilton in Connecticut, about an hour and change north of New York City, living the suburban dream. As anybody who has children in New York will know, it’s a very difficult place, an expensive place. And so you often make the move into the suburbs.
And we did that during the COVID period. And it’s great. Love it.
It’s a nice place to live. In terms of what I do, I would say there’s two things that I do. The first is that my main business is a consulting business.
I do primarily brand strategy consulting. I’d caveat and say that it’s that overlap between company strategy, corporate strategy, and brand strategy, and how you are delivering what the business is trying to achieve through the brand. And it’s very much what is the world of corporate branding.
I prefer to call it organizational branding, because it’s not always a corporation, but it’s typically an organization of some kind. So what you’re not branding is a specific consumer packaged good, product, or service. What you are looking at is what is the combined human endeavor of this organization and what does that ladder up to, and what does that mean as a brand, and how does that potentially umbrella across multiple product and service offerings, but also give people a sense of what’s going to come next and what they should expect in terms of innovation.
And I come from what I would call the organization-out school. I spent 10 years at Wolff Olins in my past. Wally Olins was the pioneer of corporate identity as a concept.
We don’t really use that term anymore, but if you were to read his book from 1989, there’s a direct lineage to how I do what I do, which is that he was really looking at the inside of an organization and saying that an organization has a personality, it has a certain way of being, it has a set of cultural norms, and that you can capture that and then reflect that internal reality into the external world.
And so I think that’s very much my lineage. I’m very much looking at what is it that makes this organization unique? And as a result of what makes this organization unique, what does that mean for a competitive advantage relative to the markets that they serve, relative to the products they might make, relative to the experiences they might create?
It seems like a long-winded way of talking about it, but I think we’ve…