Sam McNerney is a survey designer and researcher in Brooklyn. We met ages ago because, to me, he was an odd quant guy with a qualitative soul. (And, it turns out, he’d written some articles I’d referred to over and over about embodied cognition.) He’s designed surveys for Fortune 500 companies like Walmart, P&G, and Citibank, conducted over 400 studies with 100k+ respondents, published in Scientific American and TechCrunch, and teaches consumer behavior at CUNY’s BIC program.
Sam’s Writings
A Brief Guide to Embodied Cognition: Why You Are Not Your Brain
The Science of Asking What People Want
Bias the Participant: Designing Surveys That Elicit a Deeper Emotional Response
I’m not sure if you know this, but I start all of my conversations with the same question. I borrowed it from a friend of mine who helps people tell their stories. I use it because it's a big, beautiful question—but because it's so big and beautiful, I tend to over-explain it, like I’m doing now. Before I ask it, I want you to know that you're in complete control, and you can answer—or not answer—in any way you want. The question is: Where do you come from?
I was expecting something like that. It's a good, full-circle kind of question. It reminds me of a distinction I picked up early on when I started learning how to do market research—the difference between "Where are you from?" and "Where do you currently reside?" Or "Where's home?" versus "What's your address?" One is about things that can be tracked or scraped, and the other isn’t.
So, let me take a shot at answering in a way that captures the stuff that can’t really be tracked. I was essentially born and raised outside of Minneapolis. Born just north of Chicago, but I’m from Minnesota.
My mind always defaults to that when people ask a question like this. I live in Brooklyn now, as you know, so mentioning Minnesota feels even more important—as if to signal, “Hey, I’m not one of these freak New Yorkers. I’m from over there.” That’s probably the pithiest way to answer such a meaty question.
What was it like growing up in Minneapolis? What do I remember? It was a really great place to grow up. A quintessential suburban upbringing, but with the twist that Minnesota winters are long, cold, and snowy. Unlike the East Coast—especially upstate New York or Buffalo—the winters in Minnesota are sunnier, or at least they feel sunnier. I went to school in upstate New York, so I’ve kind of run the A/B test on winters.
Yeah, it only took one iteration to wrap up the experiment. There are a lot of outdoor activities: cross-country skiing, skating, ice fishing. A lot of people spend time outside—that’s the big difference. We were lucky. We had a pond in our backyard that froze over in the winter, so we spent a lot of time skating. I was outside a lot, which was just really good.
Another thing worth mentioning: I have three older brothers. They were quite a bit older than me—the oldest is about 12 or 13 years older. So, unlike a lot of my friends, I feel like I had a firmer grasp on where all of this was headed.
And by “all of this,” I mean life itself. Like, oh yeah—you go to college, then you move to a city, and you get a job. But yeah, Minnesota—I’m a huge homer. I cheer for all the sports teams. I loved it. And I miss it. You don’t move to Brooklyn for the environment or the outdoors.
Why do you move to Brooklyn?
I think—this might be romanticizing a bit—but it’s kind of like what JFK said about going to the moon: you do it because it's hard. That strikes me. I'm married and have two kids, five and two, so it's definitely difficult. The amount of space you get per dollar is terrible. And then there are just all the annoying things about living in a city. I'm fairly neurotic—I get annoyed by small noises and things like that pretty easily.
But there's an upside to all of that annoying stuff. You can't be passive or settle in or get too comfortable. You have to stay creative, stay productive. You're forced to come up with good ideas in a way you wouldn't be if you were in the suburbs, where your money goes further and life might be more comfortable.
That’s the romantic answer. The short answer is I graduated college, followed a girl—now my wife. All my friends moved to New York, so socially, it just felt like the natural thing to do.
I want to go back—when you were a kid, do you remember what you wanted to be when you grew up?
For sure. From about age four or five through twelve or thirteen, I really liked sports. I grew up playing hockey. I was always curious about the world, so while I don’t think I ever said I wanted to be a scientist, I loved learning about cool stuff—about Earth, nature, that kind of thing.
Then, around age fourteen or fifteen, I became a little more inward. I liked reading a lot more. I ended up majoring in philosophy. I loved learning about the history of science, the history of ideas. That interest gradually pushed me into the work I do now. So to me, there's a kind of fault line—obviously marked by biological changes—around twelve or thirteen. Nothing too interesting before that, but things started taking shape after.
You're in Brooklyn now—tell me a bit about the work you do. What keeps you busy these days?
To riff off the last part, when I got into philosophy, I also got really into the behavioral sciences. Not in an academic sense—I didn’t go to grad school—but I just enjoyed learning about judgment and decision-making. My timing was lucky, because the field was really starting to be popularized in a way that even people outside the space were noticing.
I’m talking about books like Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely and others. That interest pushed me into advertising, but specifically into roles that focused on research and insights. I ended up spending five or six years at Publicis in that kind of capacity.
Something interesting happened during that time. I entered the field with a strong behavioral science worldview—this idea that people don’t have fixed preferences, that they’re prone to decision-making errors they’re not even aware of. You’re not supposed to ask people what they like, because they don’t really know. The metaphor I liked was that the mind is like a press secretary, and the brain is the Oval Office—what the press secretary says isn’t necessarily trustworthy.
But then, ironically, I taught myself how to do surveys—to add value to existing clients and help with new business. Which, according to that worldview, was kind of a sin, since surveys usually involve asking people what they like. What I found, though, was that the behavioral science perspective was a bit exaggerated. And the so-called replication crisis kind of confirmed that.
You may not be attuned to this, but over the years, a lot of the major findings in judgment and decision-making—and in other parts of cognitive psychology and moral psychology—haven’t been replicable. Researchers haven’t been able to replicate them. In hindsight, it’s sort of obvious why: the incentive was to land a big TED Talk or a book deal. So the incentive was to spin these so-called counterintuitive narratives that were interesting and surprising to readers or audience members.
But what I’ve found is that people will share the information you’re seeking through a survey—if you ask a good question. And by the way, we can get into what that means. I don’t mean a philosophically deep question, like something out of the Platonic dialogues. I just mean a clear question, without jargon, that’s easy to read. Your opening actually illustrated this nicely.
I want to return to your reaction to my opening question—and the way it resonated with something you’ve learned about survey design or behavioral psychology. Is that what you're saying?
Yeah. What I’m saying is that I discovered people do have access to their preferences. They have concrete opinions they can share, but it’s up to the surveyor to extract those responses by asking simple, clear, pithy questions.
So an example—I think I might’ve s…