For your reading and listening pleasure, and convenience, this piece is available in both written and podcast form. Take your pick!
I understand, this is quite the flex for someone with a 20-year track record advocating for action on climate collapse, who has interviewed literally thousands of experts, but I recognise a flicker of unwarranted climate optimism in myself, and the grown-up thing to do is to admit and confront it. I didn’t admit that so much as blurt it out in a recent episode of Your Climate Brain, one of my favourite go-to climate and nature podcasts. It wasn’t quite Richard E Grant’s ‘I AM A TRAITOR!’, in response to a gentle prod from Joe Lycett, but there’s a similarity. The host of YBOC, Dave Powell is a kindly man, who has created the latitude for full disclosure through his thoughtful and well rounded interrogation. Then there was the wonderfully supportive Sunday audience made up of attendees to Sustainable Fashion Week Crystal Palace (a very picturesque area of South London where the health food shop alone makes you feel ‘well held’). In the disco-lit bosom of a very groovy Hang on In There Baby, perched atop a stool the revelations came pouring out, ‘I do have a tendency to be a climate optimist, so I have to work on that’.
But it’s true, I do need to work on that. Looking on the bright side of life (something the mass population of my host country, the UK, is trained to do almost epigenetically at this point) is not generally thought of as a bad thing. But in climate terms, optimism is loaded. It can spur us into action, but it can also let us off the hook, reassuring us that things will somehow turn out fine without anyone having to do very much. And this matters because what we think and feel about climate change has consequences well beyond our own sunny dispositions. It feeds into what we’re prepared to do about it and which policies we’re willing to get behind. As a recent piece in the The Conversation examining UK attitudes after the record-breaking summer of 2026 points out really well, even getting hot and bothered about climate change doesn’t necessarily mean people will change their behaviour or back the policies needed to tackle it. So optimism can be a force for good, but it can also provide rather comfortable cover for doing nothing. Which puts me, somewhat alarmingly, on a spectrum that also includes people actively standing in the way of climate action. PEOPLE LIKE DONALD TRUMP AND JEREMY CLARKSON!
Occasionally I wonder how I’d describe Jeremy Clarkson to a mildly interested alien. A towering, dishevelled ‘Englishman’ (as he no-doubt describes himself) with the countenance of a sweaty country squire . Of course, I’d then have to explain country squires, followed by the Cotswolds, followed by Top Gear, the car programme that in its heyday left enthusiasts jabbering on about ‘torque’. Then there’s his dismissal for physically assaulting a colleague over the absence of hot meat. To get the alien up to speed I’d quickly get to his extraordinary second act as a Cotswold’s farmer, turning his general displeasure with life into a national entertainment juggernaut about producing food. I’d have to explain that he reserves particular venom for environmentalists, whom he regards as interfering killjoys intent on making everyone’s life more difficult. Finally, I’d have to explain that when it comes to climate change, Jeremy is delulu.
At the Conservative party conference last week, he took to the stage and spoke of the rotten summer and how he’d grown diddly squat at Diddly Squat farm. (I’ve stopped doing the talking to the alien thing now). This must have pricked up the ears of some green types, because there’s a determined tranche (likely Top Gear fans) who think Jeremy will come good in the end. To be fair, his show has introduced concepts like regenerative agriculture to the mass audience. Wild Farmed told me he did wonders for the profile of regenerative agriculture when they were featured. There are some who will say that if only Jeremy would watch the National Emergency Briefing he could become the climate-action messiah. Unfortunately, Jeremy will not be coming to save us. He is, at best, a climate optimist . Back to his Tory party stage appearance where he mourned a dreadful summer without rain, the paucity of the harvest and yet remained ‘optimistic. 76 was very hot, 77 was also very hot… I’m just hoping that next year will be okay again.’ Jeremy, it won’t be my love. It’s called climate change. (Now, I’m moving to calling him Clarkson).
Psychologists have a name for part of this: motivated reasoning. We are remarkably adept at interpreting evidence in ways that protect what we already believe. Which may explain why those hoping Clarkson’s farming experiences will eventually turn him into a climate champion are in for a long wait. Possibly even longer than Jeremy’s bounce-back-harvest. The more the evidence threatens an established worldview, the more energetically the mind can work to explain it away. You can acknowledge a disastrous harvest without accepting what the changing climate is telling you. Yikes.
Weather or not?
Climate or weather? For those of us who have spent decades trying to decode these atmospheric signals, the language matters enormously. I was raised on strict protocols. In the mid-2000s, when climate deniers routinely confused immediate weather with long-term climate trends, we were taught never to conflate the two. But science moves on, and so must the language we use to describe it. Following the UK’s fifth consecutive heatwave this summer, a series of conversations with climate scientists persuaded me that those old rules needed updating. I think this is what intellectual honesty demands: a willingness to revise your understanding as the evidence develops.
Although weather and climate are distinct fields, ‘Weather and climate to me can’t be separated,’ Hayley Fowler, Professor of Climate Change Impacts and Head of the Water Engineering Group in the School of Engineering at Newcastle University told me, ‘you can’t talk about weather without talking about climate change because the warmer atmosphere affects the weather we experience.’ They aren’t interchangeable terms, but she argues we need to consider them together: natural cycles shape weather, while a warmer atmosphere can intensify its extremes. In the UK, she says El Niño tends to show up as very wet, stormy autumns and winters. In earlier research Prof. Hayley and team have shown that burning fossil fuels has led to the equivalent of about three million Olympic-sized swimming pools of extra water landing on the British isles each winter.
Professor Ed Hawkins MBE is Professor of Climate Science at the University of Reading and a National Centre for Atmospheric Science research scientist, he explains it this way, ‘Obviously we experience weather day to day. We experience hot days and cold days and wet days and dry days, and that makes up our weather. But when we look over longer time periods, what we see is that on average the weather is changing. When we get hot days, they are hotter than they used to be, and when we get really intense rainfall, there is, on average, more rainfall falling from the sky.’
He then gives the first UK heatwave this summer as an example, ‘The UK heatwave was probably three or four degrees hotter because of our past changes in climate, mainly from burning fossil fuels. So, yes, the weather patterns had given us the conditions for hot temperatures, but the temperatures were hotter than they would otherwise have been because of our past emissions.’
Ed is the inventor of the climate stripes – a brilliantly simple visual timeline of temperature change: each stripe represents a year, shifting from cooler blues to hotter reds. They’ve been used on (electric) buses, trams, bridges, walls, knitwear and men’s ties. But what’s his favourite stripes outing so far? He nominates 2019 when the Climate Stripes filled the Jumbo…