There was a moment, around 2018, when it seemed you couldn’t keep a good environmental story down. The media wanted them. Businesses were falling over themselves to announce ambitious commitments. Campaigners were finding new audiences. And the public seemed genuinely interested and invested in what might happen next.
Richard Walker rode that wave (he was also Chair of Surfers Against Sewage at the time, so forgive the pun). But it was as MD of Iceland Foods, that he took environmental campaigns into places they hadn’t always reached before, including the weekly shop of millions of British households and the back of their fridge-freezers. Yes eco was to be found in the frozen food aisle.
There was the commitment to remove palm oil from Iceland’s own-label products, the orangutan roundel appearing on packaging, and the extraordinary Rang-tan Christmas advert, which was barred from television but went on to reach a record-breaking audience online. Your kids will likely remember it.
Richard was doing something that many environmental organisations still struggle to achieve. He was making complicated environmental issues accessible, visible and relevant to people who hadn’t necessarily signed up to hear about them. And he wasn’t afraid to make enemies along the way.
When we spoke for the first edition of THE LANDED LENS, Richard described that period as a time when everyone was pushing on an open door. The environmental story had momentum. There was a sense that business, media and public opinion were moving in broadly the same direction. But the door isn’t open in quite the same way now, and that’s where our conversation got really interesting.
The green grocer’s dilemma
Richard is unusually candid about the changed landscape. The excitement of 2018 and 2019 has given way to something more difficult. Environmental issues haven’t become less urgent - after all emissions are still rising, but the public conversation has been overtaken by other pressures: the pandemic, war, the cost of living and an increasingly polarised political climate.
He describes how environmental messaging, once so energising, can now feel draining. Sometimes, he says, you can see people’s eyes glazing over. But can an ambitious environmentalist just park this and move on. The answer, apparently, is no. ‘I do feel guilty about it, definitely. To the point where I stopped calling myself an environmentalist,’ he told me.
Just to remind you - this is a man who chaired Surfers Against Sewage, wrote The Green Grocer: One Man’s Manifesto for Corporate Activism and helped put palm oil and plastic packaging into the national conversation. To me, he’s not disavowing environmentalism, but he is struggling with the contradictions of communicating it.
I know Richard from our time together at Surfers Against Sewage, and I know how deeply he cares about the natural world. But caring about something and being able to communicate it effectively are not the same thing. This raises questions that goes well beyond Iceland Foods. If someone with Richard’s experience, resources and communications instincts is finding environmental storytelling difficult, what does that mean for the rest of us?
When the story you tell isn’t the story people hear
One of the most revealing exchanges in our conversation concerns a recent Newsnight appearance. It’s actually the reason I reached out to him, and asked to talk. Richard had gone on to challenge aspects of environmental policy, particularly the costs and effectiveness of packaging regulations. His argument was that the system wasn’t delivering the environmental improvements it was supposed to achieve. But watching him, I heard something different. Here was someone I’d known as an outspoken environmental campaigner, apparently pushing back against green policies. The Green Grocer seemed M.I.A. When I put this to him, Richard explained the complexity of his position. He wasn’t challenging the ambition to reduce waste and improve recycling. He was questioning whether the mechanisms designed to achieve those goals were working.
I could see his problem. This was a technically complicated argument about packaging recovery notes, recycling infrastructure, costs and unintended consequences. It required context, explanation and nuance. But Newsnight gives you perhaps 20 seconds to make a point. Richard knows that. He’s appeared on Question Time eight times. He understands the constraints of broadcast formats better than most. But even he hasn’t entirely worked out how to communicate the distinction between challenging environmental policy and challenging environmental ambition. ‘It’s definitely work in progress,’ he admits.
This is FRICTION in action. When I work with my LANDED system for understanding the media ecosystem (primarily I deal with the UK, but it works almost everywhere), FRICTION is under acknowledged as a driver of stories, and quickly becomes a barrier. It is complicated. In Richard’s case the story Richard intended to tell collided with his public identity, the political context and the assumptions of the audience. The resulting impression wasn’t necessarily the one he wanted to create. I was part of that audience so I saw it. This raises an important lesson. The story you think you’re telling isn’t necessarily the story people hear.
Tell people without telling them off
But there’s no doubt that Richard Walker is a natural communicator, especially in less loaded times. He actually has a genius for aspects of it. He has a wonderfully simple rule for communicating with Iceland’s customers: tell people without telling them off. It’s a lesson learned through experience.
Iceland’s palm oil campaign used a small orangutan symbol on its packaging to introduce shoppers to an enormously complicated issue involving tropical deforestation, biodiversity, global agriculture and international trade. The symbol was deliberately simple. But it provided an entry point into a much bigger story. He explains that searches for palm oil increased by 10,000% following the campaign.
Compare that with Iceland’s attempts to encourage customers to switch to paper carrier bags. The bags were more expensive and, particularly in their early iterations, didn’t always perform as well when carrying heavy, wet frozen food. Iceland tried explaining why customers should pay more for the environmental alternative. It didn’t work. Why? Richard acknowledges that the messaging was probably patronising.
This is a distinction environmental communicators need to understand. I wish more of us got this. We often assume that if people knew more, understood the science or appreciated the urgency, they would make different choices. So we explain harder, adding more evidence and emphasising the consequences of inaction. But isntead of information we should focus on issuing an invitation, especially to people who aren’t normally invited.
Understanding an audience means more than segmenting it by age, income, politics or attitude to climate change. It means understanding the circumstances in which people encounter your story, what matters to them in that moment and what you’re asking them to do. A customer trying to get the frozen food home without the bag splitting has a perfectly legitimate concern. If your environmental story doesn’t recognise that, you’ve already introduced friction of the wrong kind.
The story reservoir and the story engine
I was also struck by another quality of Richard’s communication story. He didn’t necessarily start with the question that dominates so many communications meetings: how do we get this into the newspapers (with many specifying the earned media they want to get into). Iceland already had a remarkable communications infrastructure by virtue of the millions of customers visiting its stores every week. They have packaging that entered people’s homes, and stays for a while (predominantly in the freezer), an established brand identity. A website, social channels and an advertising…