Good evening.
1.
At the end of last week’s update I touched on legibility, the human inclination to simplify complex systems so as to impose control over them. Treated extensively in the 1990s by political scientist and anthropologist James C. Scott of Yale University in his book Seeing Like a State, legibility is an intellectual cousin to high modernism, which exudes unwavering confidence in the potential of science and technology to master nature, including human nature, to meet human needs.
The Bauhaus movement is perhaps legibility’s most beloved transatlantic celebrity. On the hilly banks of the Roaring Fork River, where I’ve been bolted down for much of the pandemic, the vision of Austrian émigré and Bauhaus instructor Herbert Bayer has left its imprint all over the valley. Inside the ruminative Aspen Institute, expert curators staff a dedicated gallery.
But elsewhere too has modernism exerted its hold. When an elite group of European planners met in Athens in 1933 to proclaim a new vision for cities, they called themselves modernists. The Athens Charter, as the vision came to be known, cherished legibility and advocated freestanding, monofunctional buildings laid out neatly on a grid but surrounded by vaguely-defined no man’s land, and it has proliferated on a global scale since.
In 2019, architect and leading researcher at the Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts Jan Gehl refuted in a new book foreword:
All in all, these new [modernist] principles represented the most radical course change in the history of human settlement. And, by and large, there was never a proper assessment of whether these changes actually worked for mankind. They, in fact, did not…as exemplified by the widespread discontent...
2.
In 2010, the United States National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and the University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH) co-founded a consortium to investigate systems engineering and to advance its discipline. It turns out one of the pre-dominant issues confronting large-scale systems engineering is that of system complexity. In the consortium’s seminal publication Engineering Elegant Systems: Theory of Systems Engineering, the co-authors explain:
System complexity is defined as a measure of a system’s intricacy and comprehensibleness in interactions within itself and with its environment. This definition points to two factors in complexity: (1) Physical/logical intricacy and (2) human cognitive comprehension.
Note that last bit on the human element. We’ll come back to it a few more times in this update.
The consortium goes on to provide a granular table of properties of a complex system:
What’s remarkable is that of the five properties, two, emergence and nonlinearity, aren’t even internal to the system but stem from the limitations of the human mind.
In social sciences too have these properties amply manifested. Nineteenth-century French economist, journalist, and member of L'Assemblée nationale Frédéric Bastiat wrote in his 1850 pamphlet That Which is Seen, and That Which is Not Seen:
In the sphere of economy, an act, a habit, an institution, a law, gives birth not only to an effect, but to a series of effects. Of these effects, the first only is immediate; it manifests itself simultaneously with its cause — it is seen. The others unfold in succession — they are not seen: it is well for us, if they are foreseen.
Between a good and a bad economist this constitutes the whole difference — the one takes account of the visible effect; the other takes account both of the effects which are seen, and also of those which it is necessary to foresee.
Across the English Channel in 1691, John Locke successfully argued that the government ought not to cap interest rates, because lenders would find ways to evade the law and pass the cost of evasion to “widows, orphans and all those who have their estates in money”. Those the government intended to protect would perversely end up with higher liability. The reasoning has withstood the test of time, as central bankers and economists even today acknowledge and try to mitigate the same concern in major interest rate and price control policies.
3.
At the moment, space is again in the headlines. Thanks to a handful of space cadet billionaires but also the current pandemic alerting us to the monstrously tragic consequences of tail risk, expansion of human presence into space has taken on greater moral meaning and urgency.
This space expansionist view rests not only on a wealth of science fiction by generations of influential writers such as Jules Verne and H.G. Wells, but also substantial work produced by serious scientists, engineers, military planners, and an informed, diverse, global space intelligentsia. Indeed the name of this newsletter, the Ion Drive, takes inspiration from the eponymous electric propulsion system for spacefaring.
In ISSUE 3: The Case for Space, I borrow the words of Mark Hopkins, an economist and board member of the National Space Society:
The vast majority of resources in the solar system lies in space rather than on the Earth. This is true of both materials and energy… The sun produces ten trillion times more energy than what is currently used by the human race. If we could bring just a small percentage of that to Earth, we will have all the energy we need, and it’s a clean, inexhaustible resource. There is vast potential for increasing the size of the human economy by tapping into these resources... Space makes possible a prosperous and hopeful future for all of humanity.
But in examining the folly of legibility in forestry last week, I couldn’t help asking whether full-throated space expansionism has also fallen prey to a failure to appreciate complexity. After all, despite widely different rationales and even heated disagreement among space advocates, all take for granted expansion to space is a Good Thing. Where is the debate on the unintended consequences? On Bastiat’s that which is not seen?
It helps here to pinpoint an essential physical property of space little discussed in popular media. Although at first the void between stars and planets may seem like a wide open commons in which spacecraft can sail in any direction, the existence of gravitational wells makes specific lanes of travel more fuel-economical. Meanwhile, radiation belts and other natural phenomena lethal to machines and human life render certain zones highly undesirable. For example, the Earth’s massive gravity well means it takes more energy to travel from the Earth to the Moon than from the Moon to Mars. Linear distance matters less than fuel economy, and the void of space consists of unseen celestial, energetic mountains, valleys, deserts, and seas.
Associate Professor Everett Dolman of the School of Advanced Airpower Studies at Maxwell Air Force Base, Alabama illustrates in his 2002 book Astropolitik, Classical Geopolitics in the Space Age:
Perhaps the most intriguing point locations useful for strategic or commercial bases in Earth-Moon space are the gravitational anomalies known as Lagrange Libration Points, named for the eighteenth-century French mathematician… Lagrange calculated that there were five specific points in space where the gravitational effects of the Earth and Moon would cancel each other out… An object fixed at one of these points (or more accurately stated, in tight orbit around one of these points) would remain permanently stable, with no expenditure of fuel… The occupation and control of these points is of such vital importance that an advocacy group called the L-5 Society was formed to influence national policymakers.
Dolman compares these advantageous points in space topology to choke points in conventional military planning. Their importance is that they dictate specific tactics and rationale for not only efficient exploitation but optimal control o…