Today I talk about the bookends of 1964 and 2024, specifically about the idea of the “perverse incentive” of free tuition. A prominent and potent argument on the part of reactionaries post-1964 was that state university systems that offered free higher education were in fact fertile ground for rebellion, essentially because there was nothing at stake for young people. The answer or response to this condition of course was to price higher education, i.e. to end generous grants, privatize loans, and start charging tuition. The contemporary reality, however, shows how much those earlier arguments in fact failed: we live in a period of profoundly straitened conditions — millions of students graduate with a mountain of student debt — and yet the rebellions continue. This is a major contrast with the early 1960s: students then had every expectation of graduating into a growing economy, finding life long secure employment and so on. None of those things hold true today. And yet the rebellions continue. What is more, police hostility and the threat of ordinary violence has become universalized, as has surveillance. The two worlds are in fact quite different, and our role is to see how we got from one to the other.