This week we’re joined by Robin Hanson, economist at George Mason, author of the Overcoming Bias blog and The Age of Em, and the person behind a long list of chewy, influential ideas, from prediction markets and futarchy to grabby aliens.
📜 Read the full transcriptWe start with AI and growth. Robin’s median forecast for the next decade is a burst about the size of the internet boom, concentrated in software. He expects the software industry to roughly triple, with 20% of the new revenue going to AI and most of the rest going to the top engineers who can manage it.
Then we turn to prediction markets. Why are long-horizon markets expensive, and why does it matter how long a piece of information lasts rather than when the question resolves? How should you subsidize a market so you pay for information near your actual decision threshold and decision date? Can a whale just buy the outcome?
From there we move to AI alignment. In an old post Robin argued we should “prefer law to values” when it comes to AI. If you’re picking a country to retire to, you check the crime rate, not opinion polls about people’s values. He also argues that the push for draconian AI regulation is out of proportion to the harms we’ve seen so far. Even this summer’s Hugging Face incident, in which an autonomous AI agent broke into the company’s internal systems, is in his telling “teenagers going on a joyride, doing some graffiti.”
The second half covers Robin’s newest project: cultural drift. Culture is humanity’s superpower, Robin says, “and we broke it.” In three centuries we went from hundreds of thousands of peasant cultures under strong selection pressure to a single rich, peaceful, fast-changing global monoculture that celebrates activism. That moves every parameter of a working selection process in the wrong direction, and falling fertility is the clearest symptom. Robin proposes three fixes, each a big ask:
* Unleash capitalism everywhere, including giving parents a share of their kids’ future tax revenue
* Govern groups by “number go up,” using futures markets on their long-run adaptive success
* Rally a large polity around a sacred goal that civilization can’t collapse on the way to, such as when do a million people live in space?
We close with a lightning round on science-fiction authors (Vinge, Asimov, Stephenson, and Le Guin), which includes the moment Robin reveals which sci-fi character LLMs say he most resembles.
Links & References
Robin’s work
* Overcoming Bias, Robin’s blog
* Robin Hanson, The Age of Em: Work, Love, and Life when Robots Rule the Earth, Oxford University Press, 2016. In Robin’s words, it’s “like science fiction, except there’s no plot, and there’s no characters, and it all makes sense”
* Robin Hanson, “Shall We Vote on Values, But Bet on Beliefs?”, the original futarchy / decision-markets proposal
* Robin Hanson, “Logarithmic Market Scoring Rules for Modular Combinatorial Information Aggregation”, the automated market maker that most subsidized prediction markets use
* Robin Hanson, Ryan Oprea & David Porter, “Information Aggregation and Manipulation in an Experimental Market,” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization (2006), the lab evidence behind “manipulators are sheep”
* Robin Hanson, “Prefer Law To Values”, Overcoming Bias (2009)
* Robin’s recent posts on cultural drift (book in progress):
* “Skinner, Cattell, Stewart, Wilson on Deliberate Culture”, which summarizes what’s distinctive about his cultural drift analysis
* “Five Slogans Re Cultural Drift”
* “Without A Sacred Quest, Our Civilization Falls”, the case for proposal 3
* Robin Hanson, “Explain The Sacred” (2023), the hub post for his series on the sacred, which Seth mentions
Economics of AI
* Paul David, “The Dynamo and the Computer,” American Economic Review (1990), on why general-purpose technologies take decades to show up in productivity statistics
* Timothy Bresnahan & Manuel Trajtenberg, “General Purpose Technologies: ‘Engines of Growth’?” Journal of Econometrics (1995)
AI safety
* Hugging Face, “Security incident disclosure — July 2026”, the autonomous-agent intrusion Andrey brings up
Prediction markets
* MetaDAO, which runs crypto governance by decision market
* Kalshi and Polymarket
* Robert Shiller, Macro Markets: Creating Institutions for Managing Society’s Largest Economic Risks (1993), on long-run markets for hedging
Chapters
* (00:00) Cold open
* (00:35) Welcome, Robin Hanson
* (01:32) GDP over the next decade: an internet-scale boom, mostly in software
* (03:10) Bottlenecks, priors on automation bursts, and why intelligence isn’t one-dimensional
* (07:11) General-purpose technologies: reorganization takes decades
* (08:33) Invention vs. diffusion
* (09:40) Long-run prediction markets and the cost of capital
* (12:32) It’s how long the information lasts, not when the question resolves
* (14:58) Subsidizing markets: paying near your thresholds in price and time
* (17:39) Hedging, Shiller, and what Kalshi and Polymarket are proving
* (20:15) Decision markets in the wild: the MetaDAO
* (22:18) Can a whale buy the decision? Why manipulators are sheep
* (26:11) Seth’s apes: short squeezes without information
* (27:20) AI forecasters: substitute or complement for prediction markets?
* (31:24) AI property rights: prefer law to values
* (33:38) Psychopaths, spite, and where you’d retire
* (36:43) Humans as amalgams of heuristics, and training AIs on reputation
* (40:06) Adaptive evolution of AI products, and regulation out of proportion to harms
* (42:59) Cultural drift: “we broke it”
* (44:03) Evolution of vs. in: coral reefs vs. the open ocean
* (46:37) Natural selection as a control process: the four parameters
* (48:09) From peasant cultures to a global monoculture
* (50:20) The one-time dividend of cultural merger
* (51:36) Ought from is, and the one-suitcase choice
* (54:11) Why does adaptation have to mean fertility?
* (55:35) Is Robin a nihilist? Three proposals
* (57:17) Proposal 1: unleash capitalism, and give parents a share of kids’ future taxes
* (01:01:19) Proposal 2: “number go up” on adaptive success
* (01:04:46) Proposal 3: a sacred goal: when do a million people live in space?
* (01:08:08) Lightning round: sci-fi authors, overrated or underrated
Justified Posteriors is the podcast that updates its beliefs about the economics of AI and technology, hosted by Andrey Fradkin and Seth Benzell. If we changed your priors, subscribe and keep your posteriors justified.