Listen

Description

In this episode, we tackle a brand new paper from the folks at Epoch AI called the "GATE model" (Growth and AI Transition Endogenous model). It makes some bold claims. The headline grabber? Their default scenario projects a whopping 23% global GDP growth in 2027!

As you can imagine, that had us both (especially Andrey) practically falling out of our chairs. Before diving into GATE, Andrey shared a bit about the challenge of picking readings for his PhD course on AGI and business – a tough task when the future hasn't happened yet! Then, we broke down the GATE model itself. It’s ambitious, trying to connect three crucial pieces:

* AI Development: How investment in chips and R&D boosts "effective compute."

* Automation & Work: How that effective compute translates into automating tasks (they love their sigmoids for this part!).

* Macroeconomics: How automation feeds into a fairly standard growth model with a representative agent making all the big saving and investment decisions.

So, where did our posteriors land? Listen to find out (or read the transcript at the end of the post).

The episode is also sponsored by the Digital Business Institute at Boston University’s Questrom School of Business. Big thanks to Chih-Ting “Karina” Yang for her help editing the episode.

-

🔗Links to the paper for this episode’s discussion:

(FULL PAPER) GATE: An Integrated Assessment Model for AI Automation by Epoch AI

The modeling sandbox is available at AI and Automation Scenario Explorer

🔗Related papers

* Situational Awareness by Leopold Aschenbrenner:

https://situational-awareness.ai/ and our episode about it.

* Transformative AI, existential risk, and real interest rates by Trevor Chow, Basil Halperin, J.Zachary Mazlish: https://basilhalperin.com/papers/agi_emh.pdf

* The AI Dilemma- Growth versus Existential Risk by Charles I. Jones: https://web.stanford.edu/~chadj/existentialrisk.pdf and episode.

* How Much Should We Spend to Reduce A.I.’s Existential Risk? by Charles I.: https://web.stanford.edu/~chadj/reduce_xrisk.pdf

* The Productivity J-Curve: How Intangibles Complement General Purpose Technologies by Erik Brynjolfsson, Daniel Rock, and Chad Syverson https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/mac.20180386

🗞️Subscribe for upcoming episodes, post-podcast notes, and Andrey’s posts:

💻 Follow us on Twitter:

@AndreyFradkin https://x.com/andreyfradkin?lang=en

@SBenzell https://x.com/sbenzell?lang=en

Transcript:

Welcome to The Justified Posteriors Podcast, the podcast that updates its beliefs about the economics of AI and technology.

Seth: I'm Seth Benzell, getting ahead of the automation of all productive human labor by starting a podcast. Coming to you from Chapman University in sunny, Southern California.

Andrey: And I'm Andrey Fradkin, coming to you from that place in my brain which almost forgot what I learned about macroeconomics from Bob Hall, coming to you from gloomy Cambridge, Massachusetts. And I should say that we are sponsored by the Digital Business Institute at the Questrom School of Business at Boston University. So Seth, what are we talking about today?

Seth: We are talking about the most important thing in the world, which is projecting AI takeoff and a paper that claims to add a very important element to these models. So, thinking about AGI takeoff and the arrival of these superhuman technologies that can automate all our labor, but sort of intentionally trying to think through the economic feedback loops that would go with the AI and the technology development. So, an ambitious but potentially very impactful paper.

Andrey: Yeah.

Setting the Stage: Essential Readings on AGI

Seth: So I have a question for you, Andrey, which is: as I was reading this paper about a bunch of people in gloomy Cambridge, Massachusetts, trying to project AGI—Artificial General Intelligence—timelines, I thought to myself, if I had to assign a PhD class just one or two things to read on this subject, what would I give them? Because, you know, this paper is a suggestion, but I understand you've recently confronted exactly this dilemma.

Andrey: Well, this was a serious dilemma, Seth. You see, I'm teaching a PhD course, and I felt compelled to offer one lecture on AGI and its possibilities, even though this class is about business topics.

Seth: Business, Andrey? Why are you wasting their time?

Andrey: Well, see, one of the interesting things about teaching something like this is, it hasn't happened yet. And being an empirical researcher and teaching mostly empirical topics means that there are no published papers in business or economics journals that are really getting at these issues. Right? We're thinking about the future that might affect, you know, obviously the entire world, but also, you know, what we do in our jobs. So it's a really important lecture.

Seth: And yet, you should publish this in journals! All the journal editors listening to this podcast, hi! Upside by being the change you wanna see in the world. But what did you give them?

Andrey: I gave them two readings. One was "Situational Awareness," something that we've covered on this podcast. Why did I give that reading? I wanted the students to get the insider view of what it feels like to be inside an AI company, thinking about the profound implications that might happen very, very quickly. And then I also gave them a reading that's more of a classic reading in economics about general purpose technologies and kind of the economics of whether general purpose technologies take off quickly enough and what determines how much is invested in them and how useful they are. And this is a reading by Bresnahan and Trachtenberg. And so I thought that that offered a nice contrast. Now, of course, my syllabus has many other readings that I discuss, including some other papers we've covered.

Seth: Not worried that you're not making your students read enough?

Andrey: So I, I'm worried. I, you know…

Seth: Well, we're moving to an oral culture, right? And they're gonna have to listen to the podcast if they wanna pick it up. And so, but you're basically, your reading list is the podcast, right?

Andrey: Yeah, it's a large part of the podcast, at least for this class specifically. And so it was a real joy to read for today's episode another paper that one could have put on the syllabus, but came out too recently for me to do it.

Seth: Hot off the presses, listeners. Oh, and of course, before we move on, we will put in the show notes links to the "Situational Awareness" episode that Andrey mentioned so you can get caught up.

Introducing the GATE Model

Andrey: Alright, so we're discussing this paper about a new macroeconomic model that is called GATE: Growth and AI Transition Endogenous model, that attempts to…

Seth: Alright, authors?

Andrey: Yes, we, yeah, fine. The authors are Epoch AI, et al. I'm not gonna list all of them, but you're welcome to.

Seth: I'll get it. Okay, so I'll just say there's about 10 authors on the paper. Two names that jump out at me are Ege Erdil, who I know is a leader of Epoch AI, as well as Tamay. Oh man, these names are some real challenges from these AI folks. Hopefully, AI will help me. But I will say, Tamay I have met in person in Cambridge. He brings a certain intensity to these questions. I gave some feedback on this model while it was in progress. My feedback was not a hundred percent addressed, it has turned out, but happy to raise that limitation when we get to it. But anyway, so to give some context to this, this Epoch AI group is a group of scholars who have been working for the last several years on trying to track AI progress and project the implications of AI. They've kind of been ahead of the curve in talking about the implications of AI for the economy. So I take their work on this subject very seriously, even if I take it knowing that this is not straight economics; these are definitely technologists sort of first and then economists second.

Andrey: Alright. So with that kind of introduction, let's talk about the priors.

Our Priors on the GATE Mo…



Get full access to Justified Posteriors at empiricrafting.substack.com/subscribe