Listen

Description

So I need to tell you about the moment I completely lost it this week. Like, full-on silent tears sliding down my face while I was supposed to be doing podcast research. And I swear to you: this is true, I’m not making this up; I was crying because I watched two elderly men in truly questionable sweaters sing a song together. That’s where I’m at right now. That’s the quality of emotional stability you subscribe to.

But honestly? I needed this one today.

The Accidental Cultural Deep Dive

Here’s the thing about being an adult who grew up in Canada in the ‘80s and ‘90s: you spend a lot of your life convinced your childhood didn’t have culture. Like, actual culture. You’re just borrowing from everyone else, right? You’ve got American TV shows, you’ve got British comedy, you’ve got... I don’t know, poutine and hockey? That’s it? That’s what we’re working with?

And then every once in a while, maybe it’s when you’re living in a different country, maybe it’s when you’re preparing for your daughter to come home from 18 months away, maybe it’s just when you accidentally click on a documentary at 2 PM on a Tuesday; you get absolutely slammed by this wave of nostalgia that makes you realize: oh. Oh. That was it. That was the culture. It was there the whole time, and it was Mr. Dressup.

Wait, hold on. If you’re not Canadian, I need to explain this, because Mr. Dressup is not some niche thing. This is a big deal. This is 500,000 viewers a day, every single day, for 29 years. This is 4,000 episodes. This is the kind of show where Michael J. Fox, yes, that Michael J. Fox, says it taught him how to act. This is the show where a nine-year-old writes a letter saying “you’re my favorite Canadian” and the host becomes a Canadian citizen specifically because of that letter.

The Man Behind the Tickle Trunk

So Ernie Coombs, that’s Mr. Dressup’s actual name, which feels wrong to say out loud, like calling Santa Claus “Steve” or something, and he wasn’t even Canadian to start with. He was from Maine. He was a “weatherman” in the Air Force, which I did not know was a job that existed, but apparently you can just be a military weatherman? Like, not the guy on TV pointing at maps, but the actual meteorologist tracking weather patterns so pilots don’t fly directly into a thunderstorm? Wild.

Anyway, after the military, there weren’t any jobs, so he and his brother just kind of... meandered around the United States picking up odd gigs. Very normal, very “I have no idea what I’m doing with my life,” very relatable. And then he meets Fred Rogers. Yes. That Fred Rogers. Mr. Rogers hires him as a set designer, but also as a sometimes-puppeteer, because apparently Ernie was good at voices and Fred Rogers could recognize talent when he saw it.

This is also where Ernie meets his wife Lynn, who was an actual professional puppeteer working for Fred Rogers. And Fred Rogers was the best man at their wedding. Like, can you imagine? The calmest wedding in human history. The ushers are probably handing out cardigans as party favors. The cake is non-threatening and beige. The wedding singer is just a bonsai tree, and a tiny waterfall.

How Mr. Dressup Became Canadian

Here’s where it gets good. CBC, that’s the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, for the uninitiated, decides they want to fund children’s programming. And who do they call? Fred Rogers, obviously, because he’s already the king of wholesome educational content. So Fred Rogers moves to Toronto in 1962 to start Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood... in Canada. Which, just to be clear, means Mr. Rogers is ours. I’m taking credit for this. We invented him. You’re welcome, America.

Fred brings Ernie with him as a puppeteer, and they set up shop. Ernie and Lynn actually move to Pickering, which is literally the town next to Ajax, where we grew up. Like, Mr. Dressup was our neighbor. This man was driving the same roads as us, probably getting stuck at the same traffic lights, probably also confused about why the Tim Hortons drive-thru line is 47 cars deep at 6 AM.

But then Fred Rogers decides he wants to go back to Pittsburgh and do the show in the U.S. instead. And as he’s leaving, he throws this absolute alley-oop to Ernie. He tells CBC: give Ernie his own show. This guy deserves it. He’s going to be great.

And that’s how Mr. Dressup was born.

The Philosophy of the Tickle Trunk

Okay, so the show itself. If you don’t remember, the basic concept is this: Mr. Dressup has a giant red trunk called the Tickle Trunk. He opens it up, pulls out a costume: a cape, a hat, a weird vest, whatever, and then creates an entire persona around that one item. He’s a pirate. He’s a fireman. He’s a... I don’t know, a guy who works at the post office. The specifics don’t matter. What matters is that he’s playing, in this very gentle, very slow, very intentional way.

There’s also Casey and Finnegan, who are the puppet co-stars. Casey is this deeply unsettling child puppet with dead black eyes and a mop haircut, and Finnegan is a dog who never speaks; he only whispers in Casey’s ear. And Mr. Dressup would just... lean on the counter and talk to them. Eye level. Never above them. Never in a rush.

Here’s the thing that got me, though: Mr. Dressup was so intentional about inclusivity, in ways that I don’t think we even had language for at the time. Casey was non-binary before we really used that term. Mr. Dressup would say, “Casey is whatever you think Casey is.” If a kid said Casey was a boy, he’d say, “You’re right.” If another kid said Casey was a girl, he’d also say, “You’re right.” Because he wanted every child to see themselves in Casey.

And the crafts? The crafts were always made out of garbage. Bottle caps. Egg cartons. Toilet paper rolls. Because he didn’t want any kid to feel left out if they didn’t have the materials. He was literally saving trash so that every single child watching could participate.

Like, I’m sorry, what? Who does that? Who thinks that deeply about whether a four-year-old in rural Saskatchewan has access to construction paper?

The Part That Made Me Cry

Okay, deep breath. Here’s where I completely lost it.

In 1992, Mr. Dressup’s wife Lynn was hit by a car on Yonge Street. She was just walking on the sidewalk, and she was killed instantly. And Lynn was everything to Mr. Dressup. She was the one who taught him how to talk to children. She was the one who ran a daycare and would come home and explain, “This is how you teach a preschooler. This is how you hold their attention. This is how you make them feel safe.” And he would take that and bring it to the show the next day.

So Lynn dies, and Mr. Dressup is devastated. His son says that he didn’t even know how to express his feelings, so he wrote a letter to the universe and gave it to his son to read. Which is just... I can’t. I can’t with that.

Three weeks later, three weeks, he shows up on the Fred Penner show. They had already scheduled the appearance before Lynn died, and Fred Penner calls him and says, “We don’t have to do this. We can cancel.” And Mr. Dressup says no. We’re doing it.

And they do this segment together where Fred Penner plays guitar and they sing “Together Tomorrow,” and Mr. Dressup is just... there. Vulnerable. Quiet. Letting himself be sad in front of an audience of children. And Fred Penner said later that it was the most poignant moment of his entire career.

And I watched this, and I just thought: this is what we’ve lost. This is what’s missing. Two men, being gentle with each other. Being kind. Being present. No posturing. No “masculine maxing” or whatever the heck we’re calling it now. Just two people who care about each other, showing up for each other, in the quietest and most profound way possible.

That’s the culture. That’s what we had. And I didn’t even realize how much I needed to remember it until I was sitting there with tears sliding down my face at 2 PM on a Tuesday.

The Legacy of Kindness

Mr. Dressup aired for 29 years. He recorded over 4,000 episodes. Reruns continued for another 10 years af…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit dreyerdrive.substack.com