Listen

Description

For more videos, visit my YouTube channel.

I’m away but alas staying in touch with political news at home, and thought I would check in with one of the best public opinion quants about where we stand right now …

TRANSCRIPT: Paul Krugman in Conversation with G. Elliott Morris

(recorded 5/13/26)

Paul Krugman: Hi everyone. Returning today to G. Elliott Morris, my favorite polling and public opinion analyst. We’ve had an eventful time with redistricting and there’s a lot of stuff going on, so we’ll see where this goes. The big news is, of course, the Court leaving Democrats stunned by overruling the referendum with Virginia redistricting, which now gives Republicans a substantial lead. You’ve been doing some analysis. How should we think about how this changes November?

G. Elliott Morris: Yeah. Big picture is: as long as Democrats are still winning the popular vote by four points, they’re still taking back the House of Representatives. A lot has changed over the last three weeks. First, the Supreme Court has invalidated section two of the Voting Rights Act. This was the portion of the law that prevented state legislatures or other state bodies from diluting the power of black voters.

Krugman: Right.

Morris: This, of course, matters for our partisan calculations, because black representatives in the South tend to be Democrats. Now the Supreme Court has said states can divvy up their votes. Republican-led states in the South, including Tennessee, Alabama, and Louisiana, have since passed, or are about to pass, maps that will take away three Democrats at least, and potentially five. So that is quite a few seats. On top of that, there has been other redistricting news. Virginia voters had passed a constitutional amendment to adopt a Democratic gerrymander that has been struck down. So Democrats in Virginia are going back to their old map, and they will lose two seats because of that—two seats that they would have otherwise gained. So, if you’re catching up on the math here, that’s three seats lost from the Democrats. It would have only been one; now it’s three.

But then we have redistricting in Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Ohio, and Missouri. If you add up all of those Republican states, they have taken away about 13 seats from the Democrats, and Democrats have gained only five or so out of California, the only state they have really redistricted. If you add up all this, then Democrats are down about six seats from the gerrymandering wars that Donald Trump started last year. And that could be potentially decisive in a close race.

Krugman: My very informal impression was that prior to all of this stuff, the kind of Republican bias of the voting was largely gone, and that the House majorities tended to more or less reflect the popular vote. But now we’re in a situation where we’re back with probably the biggest ever Republican lean there.

Morris: Yeah. So the 2024 congressional map was technically still biased toward the Republicans. If in a perfectly average year with perfectly average candidates—and that is the big “if”—if 2024 had been rerun, we would have expected Democrats to lose the majority of seats, even if they had won the popular vote by about a point. The big benefit in 2024 was that recruitment by Democrats in close seats was really, really good. So they beat expectations. But if you rerun it, it still would have been slightly biased towards Republicans. Now we’re at around a Republican bias of four points, which is close to the bias right after the 2010 redistricting. What happened in 2012? So this is pretty bad. We’re getting to the point where the structural bias in basically every electoral institution at the federal level is significantly overweighting Republican votes, just by the fact of where they live or who’s in charge of drawing the maps.

Krugman: A few weeks ago, I talked with Kim Lane Scheppele, my old friend from Princeton, about Hungary. And, you know, a lot of what Orbán did was, in fact, basically whatever the Hungarian word for gerrymandering is, but on a heroic scale. She said that they basically weighted rural voters by about 3 to 1 over urban voters. But of course, that was overtopped by a huge wave election. And you would still think that the most likely scenario, given the current polling, is probably still that the Democrats are going to probably crest.

Morris: I think the 2026 election will be significantly pro-Democratic, and that the gerrymandering won’t matter. It won’t matter in terms of who wins the majority of the seats. Democrats will still be down six seats, at least, from where they should be. But if they’re gaining twelve, then, you know, they’re still managing to recapture the House because it was so close last time. Republicans only had three extra seats at the last election. So it’s a pretty easy wave election for the Democrats. But they’ll still be down seats, like they’re still deprived of representation in the South. And more importantly, in 2028, when we’re not expecting Democrats to have such a large wave—unless the country comes to its senses. I know you talk a lot about tariffs here. That’s a big example. Then we’re expecting a much closer election. And in that 2028 scenario, this gerrymandering could give Republicans the majority, even if Democrats win the popular vote.

Krugman: Just a quick, amateur question on this stuff: to what extent is there the possibility of a “dummy-mander”? I was just thinking about the Hispanic vote—that the Republicans may have drawn these districts on the belief that the 2024 Hispanic vote was going to remain. And they seem to have really lost that, at least if the polling is at all right. Does this mean there’s a possibility that the Republicans have essentially diluted their own support in order to wipe out Democratic districts, and that they’ve opened the possibility of losing a lot of normally red seats?

Morris: So, it’s a great question. I’ve done some math on this. My own simulations of election outcomes, where I assume rationality. But Republicans basically went after five districts in Texas. Maybe two or three of those are highly susceptible to a dummy-mander. In which case, if you do the math and Latinos move 20 points toward the Democrats, and everyone else only moves ten points to the Democrats—assuming Latinos are moving twice as much as everyone else, which is pretty close to what happened in the 2025 elections—then Republicans only gain two seats out of Texas, but they’re still gaining seats. So there is a possibility that they have drawn themselves too thin in the case of a big Latino backlash. But they’re just subtracting some seats that they could have otherwise gained. So it’s not the fact that they’re going to lose overall in terms of the overall gerrymandering. In other words, they’re still coming out ahead.

Krugman: Okay, that’s slightly depressing, but I’ll take it. I find myself wondering: if we really have a very clear, massive, public backlash against Republicans, but these maneuvers keep them in control of the House, how much damage does this do to legitimacy and feelings about the government?

Morris: I don’t know how much worse feelings of legitimacy or approval of the government could get. I mean, approval of Congress is 20%, SCOTUS is 20%, and Trump’s approval rating is 35%—only by virtue of that question being really partisan-polarized. If you actually ask Americans how they approve of Donald Trump’s handling of stuff like prices and tariffs, then it’s closer to 25%. So, it would be very striking to have lower confidence in the US government to solve the problems of everyday people. Basically, this might make an impact on how Americans view the functioning of their democracy or what have you. And actually, from my point of view, that type of education could be useful for stuff like electoral reform or proportional representation. But we don’t have to get into that for now. But it’s pretty bad out there. It’s pretty bleak out there, Paul.

Krugman: The unp…



Get full access to Paul Krugman at paulkrugman.substack.com/subscribe