Another month, another war — this one looking like a complete c*******k. I spoke again with my go-to military historian, who among other things has thoughts about shoes. Here’s a transcript:
. . .
TRANSCRIPT: Paul Krugman in Conversation with Phillips O’Brien
(recorded 3/12/26)
Paul Krugman: Paul Krugman here with another conversation with my favorite military historian/expert, Phillips O’Brien. We do this every time there’s a new war, which means I guess we’re gonna be having a lot of them at the rate we’ve been going.
Phillips O’Brien: Yeah, I’ll see you when he attacks Cuba, right? That’s the next one. So we have Iran now, and then Cuba in a few weeks, I think.
Krugman: I’m not sure we have the resources for Cuba, but yeah. So okay. We’re recording this a bit less than two weeks into this new war with Iran. There are a couple of specific areas I wanna talk about, but first, do you have anything to say that might be a useful starting point?
O’Brien: I don’t think they know what they’re doing. And I don’t think that they had a plan. He basically did what megalomaniac leaders do. They underestimate their enemy and they think they will do this quickly. It’s what Putin did to Ukraine in 2022. “We will just march in, we’ll do what we want. We have this great military.” He was boasting about American military power, and I think he just thought this would be relatively straightforward. He liked to refer to the Venezuela model and I think he thought, ‘okay, what I’m gonna do is blow up the leadership, kill the leadership, and then I’ll get a new leadership that will be much more compliant and do what I want. I don’t wanna actually bring any kind of freedom or democracy to the Iranian people.’ Because, by the way, he’s talking about a leader for the next five to 10 years. So he is actually talking about putting another authoritarian in place. And he thought it would happen, a little bit harder than Venezuela it seems, but not much harder. And he completely underestimated what he was taking on. And what he’s done is caught himself without a strategic plan. They never thought through the second and third order effects, they were nowhere down wondering what would happen if the Strait of Hormuz was cut and they couldn’t get anything out of the Gulf. And I think they’re just making it up now as they go along.
Krugman: Yeah. That’s what we’re all seeing. I wanna come back to that a bit, but, your specialty has been air power, sea power, and strategically how wars are fought that way. And in a way the United States came in with “the O’Brien Supremacy.” We have vastly more, in normal terms or in historic terms, complete air superiority. We have the Navy but actually, let’s talk first about air power. In some ways it seems more effective. It can do big things.
O’Brien: Well, the United States and Israel can blow up anything they want in Iran. Or practically anything they want in Iran. They can’t get to the deep nuclear stuff, or at least they don’t. They’re not sure if they can get to it, but otherwise they could blow up any target on the ground they want to blow up and there’s nothing the Iranians can do about it. Their air defenses, from what we can tell, have mostly been neutralized.
The issue with air power is, it’s great for blowing things up if you have air supremacy, but it’s not great for putting anything else in its place. And this is what they hadn’t worked out. They thought, ‘Okay, we’ll blow things up and something we want will come along and start ruling Iran in a way that we’d like.’ They also didn’t understand that Iran has air power. Not to defend itself, but to strike back. So they totally missed the Iranian capacity to strike back. And Iran has struck back with very cheap drones and very cheap sea drones from what we can tell. And so the Americans haven’t been able to take out Iran’s strike power coming back at them. And it’s why we’re left in this situation.
The US and Israel can destroy anything they want in Iran. And that’s what they’re doing every night. But that doesn’t leave them in the ability to keep Iran from striking back. It doesn’t allow them to put anything else in the government’s place.
Krugman: They can destroy anything they can find. I guess part of the issue is that there’s stuff you can’t find.
O’Brien: This is what I was just saying in the article for The Atlantic. I know it’s only been over a year into Trump’s second term, but already I think we see signs of rot in American institutions. They spent months preparing for this, and on the first day they attacked a girl’s school on one of obviously the high priority targets. You would’ve thought they would’ve had the best intelligence possible. They had a long time to prepare this, but what they did is they committed a massive war crime. Because they didn’t have good intelligence, that alone should set alarm bells off. If you’re planning this intricate military campaign, you would think, at least on the opening strikes, you would have some idea of what you were attacking, but clearly they didn’t have an idea of what they were attacking and if that was the quality of intelligence that they had when it started, now that the Iranians are probably hiding more, spreading things out, trying to protect themselves, we don’t know the quality of the intelligence that they’re gonna have.
They don’t seem to have gotten the second supreme leader. So they got the first one because they knew where he was. But since then, they’ve seemed to have had more trouble tracking down the Iranian leadership. So I think it’s a sign of rot that the Trump administration has brought to US institutions.
Krugman: Yeah, I was really struck by the decapitation strike. That was an intelligence triumph—not the weapons that were there, but actually being able to find, basically, the entire leadership and wipe them out on the first day. That seemed to say that they had very good intelligence. And yet on the same day, they struck this girl’s school. And I don’t know how to reconcile that.
O’Brien: Well, they had very good intelligence on one strike package, but they didn’t have the depth of intelligence throughout the system. A lot of good people have left the US government, a lot of good analysts, so they might have had enough ability to do the strike on the leadership with, by the way, the help of the Israelis. We assume Israelis played a big role in providing a lot of that intelligence, but they haven’t had the depth and they didn’t have the depth to protect those troops in Kuwait. They clearly left American soldiers in Kuwait, unprotected. And unable to fight to protect themselves from what they should have anticipated coming at them. So there’s just all these really worrying signs. The US military is still gonna win every battle it fights with the Iranians. That’s not the issue. They can win any battle. But what we don’t know is if they can maintain the high level of excellence to actually triumph in this war.
Krugman: Just as a very casual observation, the Israeli IDF seems to be less degraded as a force. I don’t like at all what Israel has done. Gaza is a massive war crime. But the IDF seems to be functioning in a way that I’m not sure the US military is.
O’Brien: No, I think the Israelis have maintained a higher level of military efficiency. What Israel has done, a very small country, arguably has the second most powerful air force in the world, or third most powerful air force in the world. We don’t know how the Chinese one would actually operate, but we could say that the best air power in the world is the US, China, and Israel probably among first rank. No one else would be in that category. And the Israelis also have great intelligence of what is happening in Iran. So that is absolutely key. On the other hand, the Israelis seem to also have a much harsher group of political objectives than the United States. Not that the United States’ objectives aren’t harsh, but the Israelis seem t…