Listen

Description

For all my interviews and more, subscribe on YouTube.

In my writing about wealth concentration and oligarchy, I steal a lot from lean heavily on the truly work of Gabriel Zucman, who is a hugely important researcher (winner of the 2023 Clark Medal) who is also starting to play a major role in policy. I’ve talked to him before, but this seemed like a good time to bring him back.

. . .

TRANSCRIPT: Paul Krugman in Conversation with Gabriel Zucman

(recorded 7/23/26)

Paul Krugman: So, hi everyone. Paul Krugman here, bringing back Gabriel Zucman, probably the best guy for thinking about inequality, especially wealth issues. And since I’ve been writing about that and stealing a lot of Gabriel’s research, I thought we should talk again. So, hi Gabriel.

Gabriel Zucman: Hi Paul, thanks for having me on.

Krugman: Yeah. So, you have been writing—and now I’ve been, you know, cannibalizing it—a lot about wealth concentration. Why don’t you tell us about your reasons for focusing on wealth.

Zucman: Basically, because there’s a fundamental tension in democratic societies between extreme wealth and the very possibility of a well-functioning democracy. And it’s not a new idea—don’t get me wrong. All the thinkers of democracy have written about this, all the way back to Aristotle, more than two thousand years ago.

Krugman: Right.

Zucman: But there was a period of time after World War II when many people thought that this issue belonged to the past. And it corresponded to a very particular moment in history when extreme wealth had largely disappeared after World War II, after the shocks of the first half of the twentieth century.

But now, of course, it’s making a dramatic comeback. And so we are back to this discussion of: how do we deal with this tension? How do we organize the economy and our society to prevent the forms of capture of the political process, in particular, that are associated with extreme wealth?

Krugman: Now, there’s a question. I mean, I’ve been on the inequality beat for an alarmingly long time—since you were a small child, actually. But in the early nineties, let’s say, it was all income rather than wealth. And a lot of it was top quintile, and maybe top one percent. And now you’re telling us that we need to focus on the wealth rather than the income of the top 0.0002 percent. Why that shift? Why wealth rather than income?

Zucman: Well, it’s for two reasons. Number one is a macroeconomic reason, which is that wealth as a whole has been growing much faster than income. So if you look at the ratio of total household wealth to GDP in the US in 1980, it was around 200–250%, and today we are past 500%. This means that the total wealth of the country is equivalent to more than five years of annual production, five years of annual GDP. The second reason is that wealth itself has become much more concentrated, and the rise of wealth inequality, especially at the top of the distribution—at the very top—has been massive and has been even faster and stronger than the rise of income inequality.

So we all know about the rise of the top one percent; the top one percent’s share of total income has increased from about ten percent of income in the US in 1980 to about 20% today. But at the top of the wealth distribution, the increase has been even much more dramatic than that.

Krugman: At the risk of derailing it slightly, one thing that I myself have gone back and forth on—and certainly I get from comments on things I write—is a question comparing the wealth of the top 0.001%, or whatever: should we be comparing it to total wealth or to total income? And I know you’ve used wealth to GDP, and I have some thoughts, but you’ve done it both ways. Which do you use, and why would you use it? I don’t know which is right, but what are your thoughts?

Zucman: I think both statistics are interesting and capture different aspects of reality. So if you’re interested in wealth inequality, in the concentration of wealth, the most meaningful statistic is to divide the wealth of the super-rich by total wealth in the economy. So, for instance, if you look at billionaires—roughly the top 0.1 percent of the population—they own about seven percent of total US wealth today. In 1980, they used to own about one percent of total US wealth. So it gives you a sense of the rise in wealth concentration. If you look at the super-top, you know, the oligarchs, the twenty wealthiest families—a very, very small fraction of the population—their total wealth is 2.0 to 2.2% of total household wealth in the economy. So I think that if you care about wealth inequality, these are the relevant numbers.

Now, it’s also interesting to compute another statistic, which is the wealth of those top groups, and in particular the oligarchs, relative to total income or total output in the economy, because it gives you a sense of their influence on the economy and also because it gives you a sense of how much revenue there is at stake from taxing their wealth. So let me illustrate. If you get back to the 20 wealthiest people in the country, they have about 2 to 2.2% of total US wealth, and that’s equivalent to about 12–13% of total US GDP.

Okay, so now you’re dividing a stock—their wealth—by a flow. And what it means is that if they spend their wealth—of course, they’re not going to do that in a given year, but imagine that they spent all their wealth in a given year—then they could buy 13% of all the goods and services produced in a given year in the US. So it really gives you a sense of just how big they are relative to the economy as a whole. And also it gives you a sense of what’s at stake with taxing billionaires. Because, of course, the way we think about tax revenue and about government budgets, is often in relation to GDP.

And so here, what you have with billionaire wealth is that there’s a potential tax base; we are not taxing billionaire wealth today, which has been skyrocketing. That’s the flip side of the rise of wealth concentration. The positive aspect in all of that is that now there’s a lot of tax revenue at stake from potentially taxing the wealth of billionaires.

Krugman: Yeah. I mean, my version is, I mean, most people have very little wealth, right? Wealth is highly concentrated, and what most people have is income. But the very top has wealth, and in some sense, the wealth-to-income ratio is telling you how many minions they can buy, how much influence they can buy in the economy and in politics. Is that kind of what you’re saying, or is there something else?

Zucman: No, exactly. When I say that expressing their wealth relative to total income gives a sense of the influence they have, precisely it gives you a sense of how much they can spend on buying media companies, on funding electoral campaigns. Billionaires accounted for nineteen percent of total political spending during the 2024 federal election cycle.

Krugman: Right.

Zucman: They can fund think tanks and foundations, and influence the prevailing ideology like that. So it’s in that sense that it’s really useful, I think, to express their wealth relative to the value of the total income of people in the country.

Krugman: So again, what’s your take on why total wealth has grown faster than income?

Zucman: There are different stories, and I think the one that makes most sense to me and that seems most consistent with the data is that there’s been a number of policy changes since the 1980s that have favored wealth and capital, broadly speaking. So, for instance, you used to have rent controls for housing in many countries; when you lift rent controls, the value of housing wealth tends to go up. Many countries used to have pretty high corporate income tax rates, of almost fifty percent on average at the world level in the 1980s. Well, when the government takes half of the profits of companies, it capitalizes into stock prices; it reduces the market value of companies. But then when governments slash the cor…



Get full access to Paul Krugman at paulkrugman.substack.com/subscribe