For all my interviews and more, subscribe on YouTube.
. . .
TRANSCRIPT: Paul Krugman in Conversation with Vanessa Williamson
(recorded 8/12/26)
Paul Krugman: This week, I’m talking to Vanessa Williamson, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and author of a fantastic short history of taxation called The Price of Democracy, which is, I’m pretty sure, an allusion to Oliver Wendell Holmes’ “the price of civilization,” but a very different take. And because I’m so interested these days in tax policy, I thought I could talk to Vanessa to get a sense of a lot of these issues where I am very much an amateur and she’s done the homework. So, hi!
Vanessa Williamson: Hi. Thank you so much for having me.
Krugman: So, yeah, let’s talk about the title of the book first, because obviously the famous Oliver Wendell Holmes quote, which I’ve seen in slightly different versions, was basically saying, you know, if you want police and roads and public order, then you need to have taxes to pay for it. But you’re making a much broader point there. Why don’t you explain why you say it’s the price of democracy?
Williamson: Yeah. So I love the Oliver Wendell Holmes quote, that it’s the price of civilization. But as I was writing this book, which was just going to be a history of taxation in America, it struck me that taxation is really more than the price of civilization—it’s the price of democracy. And that’s because democracy isn’t just being able to vote; it’s people having the power to actually make change to their government. And if the government doesn’t have enough money to act, then, even if you can vote, it’s inconsequential.
Historically, this is a very deep story. Taxation and representation really do develop together. This goes back all the way to 1215 with the Magna Carta, when King John had been taxing at a higher level, and the barons demanded that if there were going to be extraordinary taxation, the king had to get the general consent of the realm.
Krugman: Right.
Williamson: And that was a very early iteration—an attempt to create what eventually became Parliament. So the very origins of representation in our historical tradition are really about taxation, because what you find is that when rulers want to tax, they become dependent on the taxpayers. And it builds a connection between the ruler and the ruled, and it gives the taxpayers power.
I think commonly the story you hear in this anti-tax mythology that’s around is you’d imagine the taxpayers use that power to avoid taxation. The opposite is true: when representation develops, taxes go up because, of course, the taxpayers can now have a say in what the government is doing. So taxation and representation developed together historically, and they developed together cross-nationally. The freest countries today are high-tax countries.
Krugman: That would be, above all, the sort of Nordic countries that are very high-tax?
Williamson: Sure, but it’s true across the board. Even highly developed economies that are authoritarian have lower taxes than you would expect given their level of development. And that’s because authoritarians are simply not very good at raising taxes. They much prefer other forms of revenue, whether that’s a gold mine, the spoils of war, or fees and fines that they can apply to their political opponents. There are just other mechanisms that do not make them dependent on the rank-and-file people of their country.
Krugman: Okay. And I want to come back to the high-tax countries in a minute. But one point that you make at several points in the course of the book is that the idea that taxes are okay is very much a challenge to wealthy people saying, “Well, my wealth is mine, and nobody has the right to take some of it.” And there’s a statement of principle that says, “Well, okay, but you too are subject to the laws of the republic and must pay.” Right? That seems to be a pretty big part of the story.
Williamson: Yeah. There’s this long-standing tension, and it’s not all wealthy people or all the elites at any time in our history, but there are often some who are very, very wealthy. Fundamentally, they don’t like to see themselves as citizens, right? They like to see themselves as masters. The first group of people who felt this way, of course, were the slave owners who were desperately opposed to taxation. The anti-tax components of our Constitution were all put there as part of a compromise with slavery, right?
Krugman: That’s a good point.
Williamson: Yeah, the slaveholder class was afraid of mass democracy, even if only of propertied white men. So we get the Three-Fifths Clause. And they were specifically afraid that if every propertied white man could vote, what you would end up with is abolition by taxation—that we would tax slavery out of existence. And so that’s why you see these anti-tax measures in the Constitution.
It happens again in the Gilded Age. You see Rockefeller claiming that high graduated taxation is the most fundamental threat posed by democracy. You see efforts to roll back suffrage rights during that period, even in Northern cities. So it’s a very long-standing fight between the mass public and the kind of things democratic governments usually want to do—roads, schools, and things of that sort—and a fraction of the elite who are willing to accept democracy as long as that democracy is too poor to threaten their power.
Krugman: Wow. Okay. I’ll come back to the history shortly. One thing that I probably don’t talk about enough when writing about these things, but it’s something I certainly always taught when teaching a class on the economics of the welfare state, is that the high-tax, generous welfare state countries don’t have highly progressive tax systems. The state of the US debate always seems to be about, “Shall we raise taxes on the wealthy?”, which is an important concern. But places like Denmark or Sweden or, just in general, European welfare states, have high taxes sort of on everybody.
Williamson: Yeah. That’s exactly right. I mean, that’s also how we pay for Social Security and Medicare. Big social safety net programs are typically funded by broad-based taxes.
Krugman: Right.
Williamson: I think it’s really important to remember all the things that taxes do. We really focus on the redistribution part. And it’s so important, absolutely, especially now with the incredible consolidation of wealth in this country. We focus on the straightforward redistribution part of the top rates, that kind of thing, or whether we should have a wealth tax. That’s important, you’re exactly right. But at the same time, we just need a lot of revenue. Traditionally, and in terms of long-term sustainability, that’s something that we fund by taxing everybody. But that’s part of citizenship.
One of the things that is part of that anti-tax mythos that you hear all the time—people are under the impression that Americans hate paying taxes. It’s just not true. People are quite proud to pay taxes, and they’re very willing to pay taxes for things they think are valuable—things like Social Security and Medicare. So I think the fact that we’ve shied away from asking people to support their government by paying taxes at a federal level has really weakened the civic rhetoric of this country. I think it’s left us in a terrible position. If we can’t convince people that their government is worth paying for, how can we convince them that democracy is valuable?
Krugman: Yeah, indeed. There are several episodes that I actually was ill-informed about. I kind of knew the numbers, but not at all the political history. There was this period, basically under the New Deal and through World War II, when the idea of broad-based taxes—that lots of people pay into social insurance programs, but also a broad-based income tax—really became established. That came as kind of a surprise, that people were willing to accept it, right?
Williamson: Yeah. Before World …