1. Strategic Actions and Decisions
* Prepare for Persistent High Prices: Underwrite investments for a scenario where oil prices remain high for 18 months or more due to record inventory draws, even if the Strait of Hormuz reopens tomorrow. Supply normalization will take 3-6 months, but inventory normalization will take significantly longer. [04:35]
* Ignore the “Super Glut” Narrative: Discard consensus forecasts predicting a large oil surplus and price crash, as these models were fundamentally wrong in January and February 2026, showing no build. Base decisions on physical inventory data, not paper market narratives. [11:30]
* Avoid “Safe” Passive Energy Exposure: Do not rely on broad energy ETFs (like XLE) for alpha, as they are dominated by overvalued majors (Exxon, Chevron) with different risk profiles. Instead, seek idiosyncratic, small-cap value in out-of-favor niches like services and small-cap E&Ps. [15:05]
* Focus on U.S. Onshore Drillers: Prioritize capital allocation towards undervalued onshore drilling companies (specifically Ensign Drilling) trading at a significant discount to replacement cost and offering high free cash flow yields, as this subsector shows a clear inflection point that the broader market is missing. [16:58]
* Follow the Capital Allocators: Monitor insider activity closely; specifically, follow the lead of self-made billionaires like Murray Edwards and Fairfax Holdings, who own nearly 50% of Ensign Drilling, signaling high conviction when management buys at current levels. [36:57]
2. Executive Summary
Despite the Strait of Hormuz closure causing short-term panic, Josh Young argued that the fundamental oil market was already tight before the conflict, with no supply build in early 2026. Current high prices are sustainable due to record low inventories and declining U.S. shale productivity. The primary action is to allocate capital to onshore land drillers (specifically Ensign) trading at 25% of replacement cost with a ~25% free cash flow yield. The market mistakenly views rig count declines as bearish, ignoring that lower productivity now requires more rigs to maintain production. Key risks include political irrationality prolonging the Strait closure, but the reward asymmetry is high. Avoid major integrated oils and tankers; focus instead on small-cap E&Ps and drillers where volatility offers a margin of safety.
3. Key Takeaways and Practical Lessons
1. Inventory Levels Drive Price More Than Daily Supply: The market is underestimating how long prices will stay high because inventory normalization will take up to 18 months, resetting the global floor price permanently higher.
* Practical Lesson: Monitor weekly inventory reports rather than daily news headlines; calculate the “days of supply” forward to gauge price duration rather than just the current price.
2. Low Rig Counts Are a Bullish Signal, Not a Bearish One: The falling rig count has created a value trap narrative, but falling well productivity means producers need 25% more rigs just to stay flat, creating an imminent demand surge for drillers.
* Practical Lesson: When analyzing cyclicals, calculate the “efficiency gap”—if productivity falls but output is flat, input demand (rigs) must eventually rise, creating a lagging buy signal.
3. “Precisely Wrong” Models Create Opportunity: Consensus forecasts from the IEA and banks predicting a 4-5 million barrel build were wrong; relying on precise but inaccurate models leads to mispriced assets.
* Practical Lesson: Favor “directionally right” over “precisely wrong.” Reject any forecast that projects specific surplus/deficit numbers beyond 3 months unless they explain the margin of error.*
4. Passive Investing Ignores the Best Dislocations: Broad energy ETFs are dominated by two majors (Exxon/Chevron). The best value (25% free cash flow yields) is in small, illiquid names that passive funds ignore.
* Practical Lesson: Screen for companies with a “double discount”—trading below replacement cost and offering a high free cash flow yield. This provides a margin of safety even if the cycle takes longer to turn.
5. Volatility is the Entry Fee for Alpha: Absorbing the volatility of hated sectors (onshore drilling) is the mechanism for outperformance, similar to taking illiquidity risk in the Yale model.
* Practical Lesson: Set a “volatility budget.” Add to positions on sharp drawdowns when the thesis (falling productivity, tight inventories) remains intact, using the market’s fear to lower your cost basis.
Follow Josh Young here on X - @JoshYoung
Watch on Youtube below -
