Listen

Description

This episode looks at the practical assessment of personality. We explore the nuances of psychiatric diagnosis, moving beyond simplistic heuristics with a focus on the DSM-5's Alternative Model for Personality Disorders. Learn about assessing self-functioning (identity, self-direction) and interpersonal functioning, using clinical interviewing, psychosocial history, and even your countertransference as vital tools for a more comprehensive understanding of personality pathology in busy clinical settings.

What we cover

* Why personality disorders are often diagnosed from vague heuristics, countertransference alone, or a single feature such as recurrent self-harm or arrests, which leads some clinicians to ignore personality or assume medications will not help.

* The case for combining what is seen in the visit with the history over time, using a two-step approach that begins with sensitive signs and moves to confirmatory assessment, much like screening before confirmatory testing.

* Using the interview itself as data: the mental status, how the patient relates to the clinician, and the clinician's own reactions, with the caution that none of these is specific and that the skill takes years to build.

* The four elements of personality functioning in the DSM-5 alternative model (identity, self-direction, empathy, intimacy) and the history that maps onto each: work and school, legal trouble, substance use, relationships and family.

* Confirmatory options: SCID-style narrative questions for clear cases, STIPO-R questions for subtle ones, the Level of Personality Functioning Scale, and optional testing such as the MMPI, PAI and PID-5.

* A reading of level 1 (some impairment) and level 3 (severe impairment) from the scale, plus defenses to listen for: paranoia, idealization and devaluation, black and white thinking, and externalization.

Clinical takeaways

* A personality diagnosis from a short assessment carries lower certainty than one built over repeated visits, because the diagnosis is only as good as the database behind it.

* Judge personality functioning after you understand the onset and history of other psychiatric conditions, and look for patterns that are pervasive and stable rather than one crime or one career change.

* Ask for narratives instead of yes or no answers, for example about extreme ups and downs in close relationships followed by 'tell me more'. This depends on a trusting alliance and a non-punitive tone.

* Listen for discrepancies, such as a relationship described as perfect alongside repeated betrayal. Defenses often become clear only in reflection after the visit, so name your own reaction and compare it across patients.

* Interview patients with ordinary functioning to build a baseline, and ask what happened to the patient in development. One host stresses that the purpose is choosing between psychotherapy, medication or both, not punishing the patient.

Read the full transcript

The complete transcript of this episode is on psycho.farm: Assessment of Personality: Practical Assessment in a Short Timeframe.

Related episodes

* What Psychiatrists Get Wrong About Personality Disorders

* Healthy Personality Traits, Trauma vs. Personality, and Why Trauma Doesn’t Explain It All

* CPTSD vs BPD: How to Think About the Difference and What to Do About It

For education only. Not medical advice.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit psychofarm.substack.com