Listen

Description

Join renowned therapist Dr. Mark Ruffalo as he unpacks the complexities of Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). This discussion delves into the relational patterns, effective communication of diagnoses, core anxieties, and the need-fear dilemma. Whether you're a mental health professional or someone seeking understanding, Dr. Ruffalo provides invaluable insights.

What we cover

* Mark Ruffalo's description of borderline personality disorder as a disorder of contradiction: the need-fear dilemma of wanting closeness and then pushing the other person away, an origin that includes biology as well as trauma, and why he disagrees with folding BPD into complex PTSD.

* Renaming the diagnosis (such as the ICD-11 emotionally unstable or dysregulated personality) and why he expects stigma to remain, plus the term borderline, its link to psychosis, transient psychotic symptoms, paleologic thinking and reports of improvement with clozapine.

* The twin anxieties of abandonment and engulfment, the push-pull pattern like a yo-yo in relationships and in treatment, and where splitting, idealization and devaluation fit.

* Lumping versus splitting: a borderline-narcissistic continuum, subtypes ranging from the neurotic to the psychotic end, and wide variation between severely impaired and higher-functioning patients.

* Advice for prescribers: medication as symptomatic treatment, transference and countertransference around prescribing, splitting and triangulation in split treatment, and how to answer questions about another clinician's choices.

* Communicating the diagnosis, answering 'is it my fault', can't versus won't, the expectation of improvement, and a shift from DBT as sole gold standard toward transference-focused, mentalization-based and good psychiatric management.

Clinical takeaways

* Share the diagnosis with a clear rationale. Ruffalo ties it to the suffering the patient described, says others have similar experiences, and notes that models of treatment exist. Some patients feel relieved and others labeled.

* State early that patients are expected to improve. Ruffalo says many patients with BPD get considerably better over time.

* Balance validation with reflection. Ruffalo argues that supporting and validating alone can reinforce defenses and encourage splitting.

* Expect enactments around medication. Refusing a request can be experienced as withholding, and trainees can feel pushed to prescribe what they doubt will help. If asked to judge another clinician's prescribing, send the question back to that clinician.

* The diagnostic hierarchy divides us. One of us would treat mood symptoms before diagnosing a personality disorder; the other rejects strict hierarchy and weighs each diagnosis against longitudinal data. We both reject labeling from early impressions of primitive defenses.

* Notice who gets the label. We argue it is sometimes reserved for patients clinicians dislike, which feeds stigma, and that formulation should rest on data across the lifespan.

Read the full transcript

The complete transcript of this episode is on psycho.farm: Understanding Borderline Personality Disorder with Dr. Mark L. Ruffalo.

Related episodes

* Treating Borderline Personality Effectively aka How To Be A Good Psychiatrist Through GPM

* CPTSD vs BPD: How to Think About the Difference and What to Do About It

* What Psychiatrists Get Wrong About Personality Disorders

For education only. Not medical advice.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit psychofarm.substack.com