Listen

Description

Some time early in life, we are introduced to the ideas of academic fields interested in the evolution and history of humans. For many, this triggers their first intellectual awakening. In our private conversations, human origins is a subject we’ve returned to a few times. These discussions have been stimulating and often cut to the core of what it means to be human. These ideas have deep implications for how we should think about ourselves as individuals and populations and as a species.

We couldn’t even come close to covering everything in this brief conversation, and there may have been places where we said something unclear, contestable or outright incorrect. So in the show notes here, we’re providing additional information presented in a Q&A format for any listener looking for more related content on human evolution and population histories. This content is based on Manjul’s prep questions and Stetson’s answers. Stetson does his best to answer based on his background in genetics and his reading of various sources. There is some overlap with what actually appears in the podcast as well.

Questions and Answers on Human History:

Human Evolution Narratives

* Can you explain the significance of the “Out of Africa” (OOA) theory and how it has shaped our understanding of human migration?

* Yes, OOA is the standard model for explaining modern human origins. It is still taught in classrooms. The idea is that modern humans emerged from archaic human populations in Africa and then quickly migrated to the Near East and then the rest of the Eurasian landmass sometime between 100-50 kya.

* New data from ancient DNA is complicating this story. The basic issue is that the Near East and NE Africa are a continuous landmass and so genes can flow back and forth. We also know archaic humans had already populated Eurasia prior to the OOA migration and that these populations contribute to our modern human lineage.

* We do know from genomic and archaeological data that human origins begin in Africa, but the extent to which our modern lineage owes itself specifically to African ancestors remains somewhat unclear. The preferred working model today, I believe, is that of deep but weak African structure with likely multiple introgressions from archaic humans. 

* From the human origin that is agreed to have started in Africa, how did we get here?

* Think of the broad Human lineage as a trellis that fans out or bunches together at different places. 

* If we rollback 1-2 mya, we have an archaic human group in Africa. We don’t know a lot about the genes of these early ancient humans. Some of these groups left Africa and populated Eurasia. This includes groups like Homo erectus and later Neanderthals. At some point we start seeing remains that look like modern humans ~300kya. Things are a little unclear in this period but then between 100-50 kya modern humans sweep up out of Africa/the Near East into the Eurasian continent. From there, we get some mixture with Neanderthals and population bottlenecks (events that dramatically shrink the human populations). Things stay as hunter-gatherer groups moving around a bit until agriculture begins to emerge around ~10kya. Then we get a resettling of Eurasia again by the groups developing agriculture. There are different waves of these groups. One of best studied is a group of pastoralists (a ghost population - meaning a population that no longer exists in unmixed form today) thought to be responsible for the wheel and Indo-European languages called the Yamnaya, who came from the steppe lands north of the Black and Caspian. The Yamnaya swept through Europe and down through some of Asia and have contributed substantially to modern populations in both those regions today. This occurred ~5000 years ago.

* Here is a summary of the population history of Europe.

* Perhaps the best archaeological evidence of early modern humans in Africa is from a partial skull and skeleton discovered in 2017 in Morocco. This finding is 300,000 years old. This is largely consistent with the ancient genetic data, which extrapolates our shared maternal lineage to around 160kya and various regions of the genome can be followed back further to Africa. 

* Omo I by Richard Leakey is another example of modern human remains dating back to pre-OOA migrations.

* Unfortunately, the African climate is not hospitable to the preservation of DNA and so much about the emergence of modern humans from archaic humans remains speculation. However, the best available evidence today suggests that modern humans emerged from mixtures of archaic humans in Africa around 300kya or more. 

* There were also certainly archaic human groups in Africa 1-2mya that are important contributors to modern humans. 

* What are the most significant discoveries in the study of human origins?

* This is of course a judgment call, but Svante Pääbo was awarded the Nobel prize in physiology and medicine in 2022 for developing techniques that allowed for the sequencing of the genome of Neanderthals from a thumb bone recovered from a cave in Siberia. 

* Building on this work, the lab of David Reich developed statistical methods that have demonstrated that Neanderthals and modern humans interbred outside of Africa and that lineage populated Eurasia. 

* Reich argues the biggest finding is that aDNA has complicated or contradicted most of our traditional narratives about the past. Namely, the idea that populations of the past look like those of the present has been shown to be erroneous. Migration and mixture are also fundamental features of human population-level behavior.

* Another major finding is the existence of “ghost populations” or ancient populations that can be inferred to have existed based on sequencing of ancient genomes but no longer exist in unmixed form today. It is incredible that even a single genome contains a population history due to the “magic” of genetics.

* How do genetics and archaeology complement each other in tracing human origins?

* These fields have been increasingly working in collaboration to refine our narratives about human prehistory and the substructure of contemporary populations. This has upturned a lot of conventional wisdom. Both fields are reliant on each other to push our understanding forward but ancient DNA genetics has proved a powerful tool for confirming past migrations and mixture events between past human groups. 

* How do we define what it means to be human from an evolutionary perspective?

* This is a bit of a philosophical question, which runs parallel to the philosophical questions about what defines a species. But generally, the idea is that modern humans are those that both look like us morphologically and have the capacity for language and complex culture. We don’t have a precise definition that everyone accepts. Hence, all the talk about Neanderthals and other ancient humans being a different “species” of humans is often not endorsed by geneticists. 

* What are the main challenges in obtaining and interpreting fossil and genomic data related to human origins?

* The first big challenge is actually obtaining the samples. These are rare and precious. There are ~6000 human fossils and ~16000 ancient DNA samples have been sequenced.

* The next is contamination. Microbes set up shop in human remains and when scientists handle the remains they can introduce contamination from their own DNA. There are now intense and elaborate methods used to exclude the microbial contamination and prevent the human contamination. These are significantly methodological innovations.

* Can you share any recent breakthroughs in ancient DNA research that have significantly impacted our understanding of human evolution?

* We are really just beginning to study the evolutionary changes that are responsible for modern human behavior. The evidence we have today suggests that there have been many small changes deep in our history rather than a few large and important changes. To most, this is an unsatisfying answer so I can call attention to the interesting findings …



Get full access to Views from Cleve-Mandu at clevemandu.substack.com/subscribe