A customer short-pays an invoice. Your team retrieves the backup, investigates the claim, chases an internal approval, and eventually clears the balance. But has anyone fixed the problem that caused the deduction…or will the same issue generate another hundred claims next month, and the month after?
In this rebroadcast of the May 22, 2025, Credit on the Go Podcast, TCLM’s Bob Shultz speaks with Jessica Butler, founder and principal of the Attain Consulting Group, about moving deduction management beyond clearing transactions to preventing avoidable losses. Drawing on more than 25 years of helping companies manage deductions, chargebacks, and short payments, Butler offers a practical roadmap for finance executives responsible for order-to-cash performance.
Smarter decisions start here. Subscribe to Trade Credit & Liquidity Management for expert insights, strategies, and updates on the evolving quote-to-cash landscape.
The Starting Point
The fact is that disputes and deductions are taken for a variety of reasons. They are not one undifferentiated backlog. They are a window into chronic process breakdowns, system glitches, or staff training opportunities. In some cases, they can be driven by a customer working the system to delay making a payment.
Each driving issue requires a specific corrective action. For example: Valid trade-promotion deductions need fast validation and resolution. Shortages, pricing discrepancies, late deliveries, and other compliance claims need a different approach, one that identifies invalid charges, addresses underlying process failures, and prevents repeat deductions. Reliable reason codes and historical data help determine where to focus.
The conversation explores several choices that directly affect workload, profitability, and customer relationships:
* Accountability: Deduction management cannot sit with finance alone. It is a cross-functional business issue. Sales, customer service, and operations all influence the outcome. Butler explains why a concise monthly dashboard (showing major deduction categories, aging, invalid claims, and underlying responsibility) can engage senior management more effectively than a lengthy report.
* Write-offs: Automatic thresholds can reduce low-value processing, but they should not make small deductions disappear from scrutiny. Periodic reviews of grouped write-offs can reveal recurring errors, recoverable claims, or customers repeatedly deducting amounts at the threshold.
* Automation: Before selecting a solution, measure where the team spends its time. Butler finds that retrieving supporting documentation often consumes much of the workday, leaving little time for analysis. Automating document collection and reason-code assignment can help redirect that effort.
* AI: Beyond extracting information, AI can use historical outcomes to help distinguish likely valid deductions from likely invalid ones. That creates an opportunity to prioritize disputes with recovery potential while reducing unnecessary research on claims likely to be valid.
Butler’s closing advice is deliberately manageable: start with one troublesome customer or deduction category, make a measurable improvement, and build from there. For executives facing a persistent backlog, this episode reframes the objective: not simply to process deductions faster, but to reduce preventable claims, protect the bottom line, and make the process work better for customers and employees alike. Removing one root cause can eliminate unnecessary costs, wasted time on repeated reworks, delays, the erosion of customer satisfaction, and your company’s competitiveness.
Did you enjoy this podcast? Then why not share it with a colleague?
Check Out this Related Content: