In this episode, The Gravity Well changed things up. Mark Dorin, of the Polluter Pay Federation, Colin Smith, and I co-host a few groups facing gravel pit activities in their communities. Firstly, you hear about 13 wetlands being destroyed, though a request for the activities to cease (having a stay) and an appeal is underway to protect the fourth largest Spring in Canada, Big Hill Springs in Rocky View County.
Then we hear about the eight gravel pits in South McDougal Flats, Mountain View County which have been instructed, by the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER), to allow water trucks to such groundwater from the gravel pit sites when water levels are dropping by meters across the 400 homes in the area, and six local water wells have tested positive for elevated toxins. Water from the pits is being hauled away for hydraulic fracturing “frac’ing” operations for Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) wells in Central Alberta.
Asides:
* Water used for frac’ing is being removed from the ecosystem, even the water that returns is disposed of. Using freshwater for frac’ing is not good for production, either. It introduces bacteria, degrades the gas/oil (introduces H2S), and lowers production rates/revenue.
* Water well levels dropping by meters is a common concern across Southern Alberta beginning in the spring of 2023.
Before Mark offers his reflections, we hear about the 30+ year battle with gravel pits in Medicine Flats in Red Deer County. There are at least two wells with known turbidity and contamination in the areas, and many residents are concerned about new gravel pits being proposed. How their local Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) candidate, their provincial representative, assured residents that they would not proceed with further gravel extraction. How the day after the May 29, 2023 election, the Provincial government approved a new gravel pit!
Welcome to The Gravity Well where we break down heavy ideas into small buckets anyone can handle! Our mission is simple. To set aside our differences and collaborate with others through conversation and process. Together we can face our dilemmas and make the world better for all.
In the spirit of truth, we acknowledge we are settlers on Blackfoot Treaty 7 and Metis Region 3. We take reconciliACTION by seeking the wisdom of elders and principled individuals who aim to restore water, air, land, life, and community. A healthy living relationship with our homeland and each other is our guide.
Listen to Rocky View County Gravel Pit Neighbours
Muriel:
My issue is with the gravel pits next to Big Hills Springs Provincial Park, we live right adjoining, practically, the prospective gravel pits and our water could be compromised. Hillstone has an operating gravel pit. It’s been operating for some years, monitoring and sending in reports that are not being questioned or made to report. It makes us wonder what’s going to happen with the others [proposed gravel mines]. There are several [gravel pits] in a row, about six that are immediately next to the headwaters of the Big Hill Springs Provincial Park. The one that has been approved and is under appeal right now, both by the Big Hill Springs Preservation Society, myself, and others. It’s 800 meters away from the headwaters of the spring. These springs feed the Big Hill Creek, which then empties into the Bow River, we’re talking pristine water “the 4th Largest Spring in Canada”. It holds this ranking, it’s a very important spring, and Rocky View [council] said, “Go ahead.”
[New gravel pit applications] went forward to Alberta Environment and Protected Areas (AEPA) and they approved it. An appeal is underway, the Big Hill Springs Preservation Society asked for a stay so they wouldn’t begin [mining], but AEPA allowed them to start anyway. There are 13 wetlands on that one piece of property, the one Mountain Ash property, and that’s being allowed to be wiped out to make a berm to protect from dust and that to our properties. Not by the park, but everything that goes before the development board or before the county [is approved].
Then gets AEPA approved. We’re talking water [loss and contamination], dust, and noise. The huge equipment that they use to grind up the gravel will be right next to Big Hill Springs Park. The prevailing west winds will carry it into the pond and it’s a wildlife corridor. The noise will be horrendous, as well. And yet the AEPA says, “It’s okay” “They’ll monitor” and “If it contaminates the water, well then they’ll be asked to stop at that point”. Water doesn’t get decontaminated that easily. The board has said that stopping Mountain Ash would be too expensive or difficult for them, they shouldn’t have started in the first place.
Lyse:
[The gravel company] dug a berm and AEPA said they couldn’t allow a stay because they had already done the work.
There was an ARP meeting and the county and the [public] were supposed to reach a consensus. They only agreed on three points between the industry and [the county and the public], but the industry does not believe in setbacks. We [discussed] being 800 meters from the headwaters and one meter [above the aquifer]. [The county and the industry] don’t believe in this. The [public] thought they should provide some money, increase the levy from 40 cents per ton of gravel, but giving into the [public}, they don’t want to support these groups at all. Also, there was no agreement on cumulative impacts. Interesting, as Rocky View County had done a biophysical attribute rating. Rating, the biodiversity, the water, and so on, in 2003. This study wasn’t provided to the group or the council.
Now Listen to Red Deer County Gravel Pit Neighbours
Jody:
We have some private pits by us as well as a municipal gravel pit. We are in Red Deer County. In our situation, we’ve had multiple public hearings. In 2020, [council] passed [new mines] and added the land beside us into the gravel district overlay. We were told the same as Dale and Adele that we had no appeal option. What ended up happening about two weeks after the bylaw got overturned, they reapplied for the same bylaw and we dealt with that for another two years. It came up under three different bylaws, and then in July of last year, the council ended up voting on it. We’re immediately adjacent to the Red Deer River and the land beside us has been designated as an environmentally significant area. There were concerns given its proximity to our water well, that we would lose our water. Well in 2022 we discovered our water well was contaminated.
During this whole process, it was unknown what the cause was, but coincidentally, the municipal gravel pit uphill from us had been digging what appears to be in the groundwater. You can see it from satellite imagery as they were expanding their operations and getting further in the water, we saw turbidity starting in our water and then it became contaminated and not drinkable. The municipality filed for a Water Act application to mine in the groundwater. They’ve applied now to have end pit lakes. They were approved even though we sent in a statement of concern and we’ve now filed that with the Alberta Environmental Appeals Board and we’re going to mediation with that next week. We now have a very shallow water well because of economic reasons, our only option. We had to try this first and our water well is only 15 feet deep that we’re using.
It’s supplying more water now than we had from our other well. Our concern is that they will be permitted to dig in the water table right uphill from us. Then we’ll end up seeing contamination or losing our shallow water well. We’ve been told that it won’t impact it at all and they’ve said that the water, even though they’re almost directly straight south of us uphill, they say the water will be flowing to the east because that’s the way the surface goes, not downhill towards the river towards us.
Adele:
A little bit of history, back in about 1997 or 98, a previous owner had applied to mine the same piece and it was appr…