Listen

Description

In this episode, Regan Boychuk and Mark Dorin discuss the critical role of media in shaping public perception and the importance of discerning trustworthy news sources. We explore the systemic biases in mainstream media, particularly in the context of Alberta’s oil and gas industry, and how these biases impact public understanding and policy. Our guest, Regan Boychuk, an independent researcher with extensive experience in political science and journalism, shares his insights on media analysis and the importance of good faith in journalism. The need for independent research and the role of alternative media in providing accurate and unbiased information is discussed.

Introduction to Regan Boychuk and Oil and Gas Liabilities

Alex:

Welcome to The Gravity Well, where we break down heavy ideas into small buckets anyone can handle in our work and at play. We seek the wisdom of the elders, individuals, and communities that share our knowledge and care for our water, air, land, life, and resource needs. Caring for our homeland will be our guide.

Jenny:

Awesome. Thank you, Alex. Okay, we’ll start with an update on what we’ve been doing. A couple of weeks ago, Alex and I did episode one of The Gravity Well, where we talked about why we’re doing this. We see that people are in crisis. Either it’s a social crisis, having health issues or a belonging issue, or they’re feeling they’ve been displaced because there’s flooding in their community or a fire, things like that. Or financially just pinched and not feeling safe, let’s say because you’re financially stressed. We’re trying to be a place for people in that space. We took a course together. Alex and I took a complex decision-making course. It was a five-week course, but it helped us have a framework to have discussions so that we could have at least a similar style to a topic.

It’s easier for people to take in small bits of heavy information and be able to say, okay, that was okay. Right? Build like a muscle. The idea is that we want people to learn how to use these skills. When I think about news how we intake information and how we know what is for our benefit when we read something, how do we know that it is serving us not only today, but in the long run that it’s a good thing to be doing? How do we know that? And it’s difficult right now. Regan and I have been working together since last spring, and we met online on Twitter. I saw, well, actually to be fair, I saw you talk on Ryan Jasper’s show Real Talk, and I was like, oh my God, I need to speak to this person because we have a very similar understanding of the liability problem in Alberta.

Jenny:

Liability, the oil and gas sites that need to be cleaned up in our province. There are only so many people who understand the problem because it’s one of those things that it’s like Fight Club. We don’t want to talk about liability. Nobody talks about liability. It’s one of these things that’s not talked about, but it’s a massive problem. Regan has been working on this for years, and I don’t want to go too far down that path, but that is to say that we will be talking to Regan a lot throughout the year. This conversation is to help me understand the research you’ve done along with this and how long you’ve been at it, we’ll get you to start there. Help us know that amount of effort, already. And then we’ll just walk through some questions about how you look to information and help decipher [the truth]. And we’re going to share how we do it too as we speak so that there’s a flavour of how I break down the same challenge, how I would do it or things like that. I think you understand, right? Does that work?

Regan:

Yeah, sure. My name’s Regan Boychuk. I’m an independent researcher. I have a graduate degree in political science and have been studying Alberta’s oil patch for 20 years. I went to journalism school. That’s when I started to get, I didn’t go to university straight out of high school. I wasn’t interested, but when I started reading newspapers and getting more interested in things. That’s how I started by reading the newspaper, learning about current events and then trying to make sense of them. And that leads me further astray to longer, to magazines, to books, et cetera, trying to make sense of events, but always had a strong base in journalism, been reading a lot of newspapers for a lot of years on a daily basis, and that sort of basic filtering that might be kind of the foundation of all of my research on whatever the topic is, just that wide-ranging, constant reading. And it wasn’t that strange in 1998 when I started studying journalism at sat in Calgary, but today I don’t know anyone, I don’t have any friends. I don’t know anyone who reads the paper, let alone reads a bunch of newspapers carefully. I’m at a bit of a loss for how folks these days get their information.

I started during the 2007 Royalty Review in Alberta, I started working with the Parkline Institute, volunteering analysis and data, trying to make sense of it. I was working in the oil patch doing research and studying the royalty review very closely. And that was kind of my first epiphany into the mystery of Alberta, Alberta. It’s really hard to make sense of Alberta. When I started guilty, it was such a disconnect from reality, from the public debate, and academic study, I still had trouble reconciling the reality of the data with the media and the academic narrative.

Media Analysis via Media Lens

Jenny:

Yeah, a hundred per cent. Okay. What we’re going to try and do is we’re going to talk through three different sources that we used and we’re going to use them to talk through how we analyze these or what we’re using these sources for. The first is a source called Media Lens. This was something that Regan brought forward to us and the media. I’m going to stop talking and let you explain to us what media lens, why you brought it forward, what it’s used for, how it’s different, et cetera. Just give us a little bit of colour around it. And then Alex has done some research on it. He’s going to ask you a few questions. Once you’re done doing that, that’ll be our first thing. Thanks.

Regan:

Sure. My curiosity in journalism was sparked by Herman and Chomsky’s book, Manufacturing Consent, their analysis, and their political economy analysis of the media. I went to journalism school with a very skeptical eye. I’d begun studying the Middle East, and the newspaper narrative was quite a bit different than the factual record, and it’s that disconnect that I first saw Herman and Chomsky make sense of. Then Media Lens is two British activists inspired by that work, take that analysis and apply it on an ongoing daily basis to the British media. They’ve been doing it for 20 years. They’ve written three or four books, have a library, a whole community. Dave and Dave have been doing very serious current events, and media analysis for 20 years, and it’s been incredibly insightful. Having a framework of understanding how the institution works, and applying it constantly, I think is the biggest insight, the biggest benefit, and the biggest recommendation I have is that’s the reason there are daily newspapers and not just books. There’s a big benefit to this constant surveillance of regular repeating. It’s all flawed to one extent or the other, but there’s a huge benefit from the repeated constant measurement, checking things slip through, there’s mistakes and media lens, A big part of its value is the wisdom and insight from applying this for so long and they’re very calm, very patient.

Jenny:

You cut a little bit. I’m going to offer something if you don’t mind for a second, which is just one takeaway I had from it. I read the FAQs and Alex dove into them, he’s going to take off from here is, what I read, what they understand is that the increasingly centralized corporate nature of the media means that it acts as a de facto propaganda system for corporate and other establishment interests. It is, in my view, when I hear th…



Get full access to The Gravity Well with Jenny Yeremiy at www.thegravitywell.net/subscribe