In this episode of The Gravity Well podcast, you hear about the environmental and health impacts of coal mining with Dr. David Swan, Dr. Norm Campbell, and Dr. Brad Stelfox. The conversation highlights the significant health risks, including selenium toxicity, increased cancer rates, and respiratory issues, lifestyle degradation as well as the environmental damage caused by coal mining. The guests emphasize the need for a comprehensive (cumulative) assessment of energy and land use, prioritizing renewable sources and reducing overall consumption. They ask you to demand stronger political action to protect Alberta’s natural resources and ensure a sustainable future.
Introductions to Brad, David, and Norm
Alex:
Welcome to The Gravity Well Podcast with Alex and Jenny. Here you break down heavy ideas with us to understand their complexities and connections. Our mission is to work through your dilemmas with you in conversation and process making our world a better place for all.
Jenny:
We acknowledge that we live on the traditional territories of treaties, 4, 6, 7, 8, and 10. The ancestral homelands of diverse First Nations, Inuit, and Metis. Peoples whose ancestors have walked this land since time immemorial and whose histories, languages, and cultures continue to influence our vibrant communities. We pay respect to indigenous people through our ethical relationship building efforts. Our community agreement asks for genuine conversations, real hearts, open minds, and different perspectives in conflict. Let’s rely on our six W system and live participant feedback. What matters most is finding common ground.
Alex:
We dedicate this podcast to our children, nieces, nephews, grandchildren, and all future generations. The gravity well is on YouTube and streaming wherever you get your podcasts. Join us at thegravitywell.net.
Jenny:
Welcome. I am thrilled to have Dr. David Swann, Dr. Norm Campbell and Dr. Brad Stelfox here today to talk about coal mining; the harms of coal mining, both on our health and on the environment. I’m excited to know David Swann quite well. We have an opportunity almost every week to meet, we discuss as a group of, I was just saying we should change our name to Concerned Canadians on Climate Change. We meet weekly basically as a therapy session first and foremost, but then work through the things that we’re trying to help inform, educate, or take action in our community. I’m grateful for all that I’ve learned from you, David, and I appreciate you helping me co-host today. I’m going to go ahead and let you guys introduce yourselves, Norm and Brad. I’ve had the opportunity to meet with Norm through CAPE, the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment.
We were in a meeting recently trying to work through this coal mining issue and also just trying to take action together in the environmental space, which is great. And I had the opportunity to hear Brad back in, geez, I want to say it was the summer of last year, down in Brag Creek talking about cumulative impacts on the landscape, which was really valuable to see and hear, to witness a large group of people learn how tremendous this problem is. I’m going to stop there and let you guys introduce yourselves properly. Norm, if you wouldn’t mind going first. Thank you.
Norm:
Sure. I’m Norm Campbell. I’m a retired professor of medicine from the University of Calgary. Relevant to this podcast, I drafted a report for the Alberta Medical Association on the adverse health effects of coal mining. Most of my work in my career was developing coalitions of health and scientific organizations around public health issues to create unified fronts. I’m a very keen outdoors person, love the Alpine in particular, and when I retired, one of my projects was to develop a coalition of Alberta Health professional organizations to address environmental health threats that are really important to the world and all life forms going forward. Thank you, I’ll end there.
Jenny:
Thank you Norm, so much for your work. I really appreciate it. Brad, you’re next please.
Brad:
Thanks Jenny, and good to learn a lot about Norm right away. My name is Brad Stelfox, like Norm I’m retired, a career wildlife ecologist that many decades ago started focusing on the issue of commutative effects of land use and looking how multiple overlapping land uses create not only benefits but they create liability. So that’s been my focus, been largely retired for several years, but got involved with a variety of stakeholder groups along the east Slopes Alberta that were very concerned about a broad variety of negative consequences of coal mining in our headwaters. So yeah, that’s the background I bring to this conversation.
Jenny:
Thank you, Brad. David, you’re next please.
David:
Yes, 20 years in medical practice, including public health and environmental issues, were very much to the fore in public health and 15 years in politics in the provincial government and the opposition related to a lot of the contention over both healthcare and environment. Glad to be here. Thanks Jenny.
Dr. Norm Campbell’s Medical Assessment of Coal Mining Harms
Jenny:
Thank you so much, David. Okay, well let’s get into it. Norm, if you wouldn’t mind leading us off, I’d appreciate you outlining. Spend some time outlining the concerns that you raised in your report that you did for the Alberta Medical Association with respect to coal mining. Thank you.
Norm:
Sure. Thank you so much. This is just a short summary. One of the main issues and the one with the greatest evidence is really selenium toxicity. Selenium is a byproduct of coal mining that gets into the water and from the water into the soil. Humans and animals and fish are exposed to it. The level at which it creates problems, health problems is not that much higher than what’s required for good health. If people are eating food that’s grown on soil that contains high amounts of selenium or drinking water with high amounts of selenium, they could be subject to toxicity and this includes diarrhea, nausea, feeling tired, achy muscles, hair loss and damage to their nails. This type of toxicity can actually result in death, although that’s usually when exposed to high amounts of selenium acutely. There’s also adverse health effects on fish that would be swimming in the waters high in selenium.
They can have death of the embryos and deformities of their embryos. There is a very high level of evidence that this is a significant health problem. In my review though, it’s not just the individuals who are exposed to high selenium that are a problem around coal mining. There’s a whole host of other issues that result in unhealthy communities and individuals. One of the things that’s observed particularly from high income United States where there’s good standards for coal mining is that there’s increased cancers, heart attacks, strokes, lung disease, congenital disease, chromosome abnormalities in the vicinity of coal mines, and this is, I believe, likely to increase exposure to environmental contaminants related to coal mining, heavy metals and other things. We do know the areas that are going to be mined. I know this because I go there; very high winds and the dust blow far. Some of the dust particles create something called silicosis or coal miners lung disease, and that can occur in the coal miners.
But people who are in the vicinity of the mine who already have underlying lung disease such as asthma or a chronic lung disease from smoking may also be exposed and have problems and it can also be associated with an increase of lung cancer. The other thing that’s overlooked is open pit coal mining is one of the highest risk professions of anything for death of the workers and injury. There’s about a sevenfold higher risk of death in open pit coal miners from the Southeast United States. Again, a place where there’s very high standards. Some of the other issues, and this may relate to the type of workers that are there, is there’s a mar…