In this episode, Alex and I delve into critical environmental issues, focusing on the conservation and restoration of Alberta’s Eastern Slopes. Guests Kevin Van Tighem, Lorne Fitch, and Colin Smith, discuss the urgent need to address cumulative impacts on the environment, particularly water security and biodiversity. They emphasize the importance of collective responsibility, local community involvement, and informed land use decisions. The conversation highlights successful grassroots mobilization against coal mining and advocates for large-scale restoration projects. The podcast underscores the interconnectedness of land and water management and calls for a shift in cultural and political perspectives to prioritize ecological health and sustainability.
Welcome and Introductions to Kevin and Lorne
Alex:
Welcome to The Gravity Well Podcast. Here we break down heavy ideas into small buckets that you can handle. Our mission is simple. Help us work through your dilemmas and conversations and process. And together you, we and our communities will face your dilemmas and make our world a better place for all beings.
Jenny:
In the spirit of truth, I acknowledge I’m a settler on stolen Blackfoot Treaty Seven and Metis Districts Five and Six Territories. I take Reconciliaction by seeking the wisdom of elders and individuals who aim to restore water, air, land, life, or community. A healthy living relationship with the earth and each other is our guide.
Thank you for being here, Kevin and Lorne, and Colin again, I’m excited to speak with you three. Lorne and Kevin are two conservationists and writers now, biologists and ecologists by background and have worked, they’ve said together for nearly 40 years trying to help make sure that Alberta is moving in the right direction in terms of restoring our environment and looking after the ecology. And Colin, this is his third time on the show for us (episodes 4 and 11). Colin, myself, and Alex have been working together to try and bring community together and understanding of where we need to go.
A lot of what we’re doing, of course, is following what you’re doing, Kevin and Lorne. Thank you very much for all the work you’ve been doing and we are trying to honour [your work] and make sure that as we go, that people understand that. I’m going to tee off the conversation with a first question. I want to start with purging, if you will. Let’s talk about what we are doing wrong in the province. If we can just go around, Kevin, I’ll let you start. Please, if you can just help us understand some of the things that we’re seeing that’s going wrong in terms of cumulative impacts on our environment. Thank you.
What is Going Wrong in Alberta with Respect to Cumulative Impacts?
Kevin:
I think the biggest thing, the overarching thing is it’s really past time that we stop thinking we can do whatever we want without consequences. There’s a bit of a libertarian colour to the Province of Alberta where people just want to be left alone to do what they want. We don’t want to regulate industry too much. We don’t want ourselves regulated too much. We all want to do what we want, but it’s a finite province. It’s a shrinking world, it’s a changing world, and we’re already seeing the stresses all around us. I think that would be the big overarching thing I would say is that we’ve got to stop living as if there’s no consequences to doing whatever we want. We need to start really taking, I think, at a more micro scale, since my primary focus for the last few years has been on water security.
I would say we really have to take a look at the Eastern Slopes and recognized that they were originally intended recognized from a policy point of view as our water resources, the place that generates our water. And we are doing a lot of things out there that are actually compromising their ability to deliver us water. We’re getting bigger floods more frequently. We’re getting very low warm river flows in the summer. The overall flow water production in the South Saskatchewan River Basin has dropped by at least 12% since they started monitoring it. That’s the natural water flows when you’re seeing that sort of thing going on in the province that uses this much water. We have two thirds of Canada’s irrigated agriculture here, just as one example. It’s a recipe for disaster. And it’s an example again of what I’m saying, of we’re living as if there’s no consequences and there are consequences. They’re on us now and they’re going to be even greater if we don’t turn the ship around and start managing water security for the future.
Jenny:
Yeah. Thank you. That was great. I’m going to let everybody go around first before I comment. Go ahead, Lorne. You’re next please.
Lorne:
I think we have to start with the notion, maybe the prevailing opinion, at least in a lot of circles, that especially the Eastern Slopes is an unexploited frontier of endless possibilities. If you’re listening to this and you’re still skeptical of where unrestrained development leads us to cumulative effects and crossing ecological thresholds, I would suggest try this simple at-home experiment, invite more and more people to live in your house until the refrigerator’s empty the toilet’s, plugged the air wreaks of sweat and old socks, and then add a kid with a drum set to the mix. And then ask yourself, was there a line beyond which this just wasn’t a good living arrangement? And this is what cumulative effects assessments do for us. And there are at the current time, 20 associated cumulative effects assessments and similar studies that have been done up and down the Eastern Slopes.
And every one of them, every one of those cumulative effects assessments, including the ones done by the government of Alberta, indicate that maintaining the status quo in land use, which is really about increasing our land use footprint, leads to or has exceeded the thresholds for ecological integrity and resilience. The problem with the status quo is the quo has long passed its status, we’ve got to stop ignoring the evidence and use that evidence in terms of the next steps to help us understand where we need to go, particularly with the Eastern Slopes, and as Kevin said, the primary importance of Eastern Slopes to Albertans, and a reminder to us that we’re a headwaters province and that we’re also responsible for two other provinces downstream from us.
Jenny:
Agreed. Sorry, Lorne, can you touch a little bit on irrigation just in the context of what we shouldn’t be doing potentially?
Lorne:
Sure. Well, again, Kevin has helped us understand that we live in a world of declining water supply, and yet the irrigation sector, you would think based on their aspirations for more and more irrigated acres that we live in primarily a wet landscape. We don’t live in a semi landscape, and it’s getting more arid progressively as climate change impacts us. And the madness of expanding irrigation agriculture with more and more reservoirs, more and more onstream dams just strikes me that this is a zero sum game. That we cannot do this and expect that we’ll have living rivers as a consequence, as an example. And the other one is that we can’t out engineer climate change. We can’t run ahead of it. And building more reservoirs and dams, it’s a prevailing engineering motive that doesn’t recognize that there are ecological constraints. Thank you.
Kevin:
I got to say something about that last point too. The irony of this is we’re hearing the Alberta government wants to build a new reservoir on the Red Deer River because of drought. Well, in 1989, I believe they finished building a dam on the Old Man river because of drought. And for the last year and a half, for most of the last year and a half, it’s that empty dams don’t cure a drought, you got to have water. And the water doesn’t come from the dam, it comes from the headwaters.
Lorne:
Yeah. As someone who, as my wife says, is a bit anal about gasoline and our capacity to drive distances, doesn’t matter h…